Vacation rentals in Castalia

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 233 reviews

Cabin in Bellevue

Cabin near Cedar Point with Hot Tub & Fire Pit

We personally hand-crafted and built Dancing Fox with 95% gathered salvaged and re-purposed materials to enable us to offer our guests an environment that will sweep you back to the earlier life and times in rural plains Ohio. Relax and experience unique lodging combined with modern amenities yet enjoy the casual rustic nature of what our cabin will radiate during your stay. You'll enjoy features like antique chalkboards used as countertops, hayloft floors, handmade lighting fixtures and more.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews

Cottage in Milan

Private Hillside Cottage near Cedar Point, Milan

The Odd Cottage is an old house with new tricks. Built in 1853, it stood during the time that Thomas Edison himself wandered the streets of historic Milan, Ohio. Inspired by his story, inside you'll find a modern space that's designed to enable both comfort and creativity. We're centrally located between the area's best attractions: North - Kalahari Resort / 10 min - Sports Force Park / 15 min - Cedar Point / 20 min South - Summit Motorsports Park / 10 min East - Edisons Birthplace / 3 min

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 296 reviews

Siesta in Sandusky

Welcome to Siesta in Sandusky! A great place for couples, friends, and older children. Sandusky was voted Best Coastal Small Town. Your 1850’s historic upper apartment has been completely remodeled! Come home to a relaxing atmosphere, enjoy a book, sit on the porch, or cook a grand meal in the new kitchen! Sandusky has much to offer. We are 8 blocks away from Lake Erie, close to shopping and restaurants. A 5mile drive to Cedar Point and 10miles to Kalahari indoor water park. Enjoy your stay!

5 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Cottage in Norwalk

Hickory Creek Cottage

Welcome to Hickory Creek Cottage! Our place is designed with couples in mind, to relax & reconnect. Come celebrate a birthday, anniversary, milestone or simply spend quality time together. Enjoy the peaceful setting this property has to offer, while still being close to town and major attractions. Sit back and relax in the hot tub that is open year-round! The outdoor fire pit and indoor fireplace also add to the charm of our cottage. *All guests must be 18 yrs of age to book and/or stay*

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

Luxury Curated Couples Retreat. 1 Bedroom. 5 Stars

This is not your typical Airbnb experience. Indulge in a luxury stay at this carefully curated unique place, perfect for a couples retreat. The design features Restoration Hardware furniture, Chinoiserie Artwork, and floor-to-ceiling flax linen drapes, making it an absolute gem. Plus, with a room dedicated to getting ready, you can pamper yourself to your heart's content. Be inspired by the simple yet elegant design elements in each room. Located downtown Sandusky. 3 mins to Cedar Point.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 582 reviews

Barn in Amherst

Bock's Jukejoint Magical barn! Near Lake Erie

AMAZING! Our recycled barn has a private entrance, tons of space, tons of huge old antique lead glass windows for tons of natural light, huge loft with King size bed, and tons of fun twinkle lights, couches. Bathroom on the main floor of the barn with a toilet, keg urinal and a sink. Beautiful views of the local orchards. Kitchen including fridge, microwave, sink, coffee pot, toaster, blender, toaster oven, electric skillet, crockpot, dishes. Featuring a shuffleboard table in the saloon.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 248 reviews

Cottage in Amherst

The Farmer's Cottage

The Farmer's cottage is a cozy one bedroom mid-century farm cottage on 2 acres of land nestled among farm fields and woodlands . It features a queen-sized bed, bath and full custom kitchen along with a smart TV and Wi-Fi. . A park-like yard with a stone fireplace and solar installation awaits. This country property features self contained utilities including a water well, sanitation and electricity. Enjoy fresh eggs from our chickens and baked goods from our farm kitchens.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 69 reviews

Guesthouse in Sandusky

Pet Friendly Stable 2, 5 miles from Island Ferries

The stable rooms are individual (double occupancy) rooms with private baths. Built in 1880 the stables fronted with an open courtyard is where guests once mounted their horses to enter the marshy Lake Erie countryside hunting for ducks & pheasant. The dutch doors of the stable rooms are still in place to allow you to enjoy the country air! Enjoy the Lodge kitchen (coffee maker, fridge, microwave), sitting room (tvs), and vintage bikes to cruise around the property at your leisure.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Downtown Sandusky Apartment on Fulton!

This special place is close to everything, making it easy to plan your visit. This house (a triplex) was built in 1860 and is being updated for guests to enjoy and feel at home while spending time in Sandusky, the NUMBER ONE small coastal town in the USA! It’s walking distance to all of downtown, including Jackson Street Pier where you can catch the ferry to Put-in-Bay and Kelley’s Island. It’s also less than 3 miles away from one of America’s best theme parks, CEDAR POINT! 🎢⛵️🎣

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 314 reviews

Charming Rustic Elegance- 1856 limestone home

1856 limestone home converted into a rustic elegant stay. Located within walking distance of America's Best Coastal Small Downtown. Private, quiet, and unique atmosphere equipped with kitchen, 3 beds, and full bath. Entertain by visiting our famous downtown or relax at the unit by watching Smart TV, Wifi, play wooden board games...checkers, Dominoes, or Yahtzee. Office space available for work needs. We promise the design will leave you amazed in this one of a kind place.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

Farm stay in Sandusky

Close to Cedar Point! Our Guest house at The Oak

The guesthouse at The Oak at Millsite Farm...a peaceful property surrounded by pastoral Ohio farmland. The guesthouse, originally the farm granary, is full of rustic charm, while providing a comfortable, well-appointed space to relax with family and friends. The historic Cold Creek, brimming with trout ($), and one of Ohio's oldest oak trees is located just beyond our restored barn from the 1880's! (IMPORTANT: guest restrictions in details below)