Vacation rentals in Cayuga Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cayuga Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favourite
A spacious loft bedroom is characterized by vaulted ceilings and soft natural light filtering through two sets of French doors. A cozy seating arrangement includes a tufted bench, and a neutral color palette is complemented by decorative pillows. A modern light fixture hangs above the area.
Loft in Niagara-on-the-Lake
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 536 reviews

Luxury In The Heart Of Wine Country

Hidden along the shores of the Niagara River, Grayden Estate is nestled on a quiet dead end street in beautiful Queenston/Niagara on the Lake. A short drive to Old Town and within a few minute walk or bike to world class wineries, art galleries, farmers markets, hiking trails, parks and the waterfront, Grayden Estate is the ideal location for a peaceful quiet getaway for anyone looking to surrender to the simple living quiet life. Complimentary tour bikes are available for use. Lic # 112-2023

Top guest favourite
The exterior of a two-story barnhouse is illuminated in the evening light. A spacious upper balcony is adorned with wooden railings and features a cozy hanging chair. The lush green lawn complements the red siding and white accents of the structure.
Guest suite in Niagara-on-the-Lake
5 out of 5 average rating, 426 reviews

Wine country loft, breakfast included

The Barnhouse Loft offers a very unique opportunity to enjoy Niagara Wine Country in full privacy and great comfort. You will be treated to a delicious full hot breakfast every morning and have exclusive use of the entire apartment. We are located right on the Niagara Escarpment, halfway between the majestic Niagara Falls and historic Niagara On The Lake. ***NOTE: We are not able to accommodate any pets or service animals due to serious allergies in the family. Thanks for your understanding.

Guest favourite
A modern kitchen features a wooden countertop with two place settings, including plates and glasses. A stainless steel sink is paired with a silver refrigerator. Shelves hold potted plants and glassware, while a wall clock adds a practical touch to the light-colored walls.
Home in Niagara Falls
4.81 out of 5 average rating, 517 reviews

Blue 74 Niagara Falls USA(3 beds/1.5 baths)

Welcome to Blue 74 of Niagara Falls, NY USA! We offer a private, fully furnished home that sleeps 7 total ( 2 queen beds, trundle and a sofa. We're located 6-8 minutes from the US side of the Falls. Conveniently located in nice, quiet neighborhood near Outlet shopping, Seneca Casino, hiking, biking, movie theaters, and a full array of dining choices. WE ARE LEGALLY PERMITTED BY THE CITY. Please see rules and info below. We are looking forward to having you as our guests! - Colin and Jim

Top guest favourite
Cottage in Niagara Falls
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 225 reviews

Waterfront Niagara River Cottage

Listed since November 2020. Completely remodeled cozy cottage on the Niagara River! Quick 15minute drive down the river to Niagara Falls! Also easy access by car to surrounding Buffalo and all that it has to offer. Or relax, secluded away with full access to the entire cottage and amenities during your stay. Sleeps up to 4 people, two beds, washer/dryer, electric stove, oven, and microwave, complimentary internet access, Smart TV, and a private river-front backyard with sweeping views!!

Superhost
A cozy bedroom features a spacious bed with white bedding, positioned beside a small table and a desk with a chair. Natural light enters through two well-draped windows, illuminating the hardwood floor and areas of soft gray walls.
Home in Niagara Falls
4.84 out of 5 average rating, 382 reviews

♥3 bdrm Niagara Falls Home ♥ A/C♥ Hot Tub♥ Parking

• Full, clean two-level house with hardwood floors (Recently remodeled) • Very quiet and safe neighborhood • Central Air Conditioning • Fully stocked and equipped kitchen with granite countertops. • On-site laundry • Large private backyard with grill, spa, and deck. • Streaming device on TVs, Netflix and Disney+ • Private off-street parking • Close to the interstate 190 entrance & 7 minutes to Niagara Falls State Park • Close to the Niagara River for fishing and some beautiful hikes.

Guest favourite
A modern kitchen space is showcased, featuring a wooden countertop and sleek stools. Stainless steel appliances are positioned beside ample storage, with a clock adorning the wall. Natural light filters through the windows, creating a bright and inviting cooking area.
Home in Niagara Falls
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

The Owl's Nest of Niagara Falls

Welcome to The Owl's Nest of Niagara Falls, NY USA. We offer a private, fully furnished, 2 Queen beds/Futon sofa and Full Bathroom home located just minutes from beautiful Niagara Falls USA and Canada. Our home is conveniently located in a nice neighborhood near shopping, the Seneca Niagara Casino, hiking, biking, movie theaters, and a full array of dining choices. Please read the rules and info below. We are looking forward to having you as our guests! -James

Top guest favourite
A tranquil backyard space is illuminated by string lights, creating a cozy atmosphere. Adirondack chairs surround a fire pit, complemented by flowering plants and well-maintained landscaping. A privacy fence provides a secluded feel, with trees lining the area for added serenity.
Apartment in Niagara Falls
5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Cozy retreat near Niagara Falls

Welcome to this cozy retreat in the Niagara Falls suburb of Wheatfield! This apartment is bright and warm with a wall of windows facing the sun all day long. Conveniently located to Niagara Falls and every local amenity you can imagine. With 2 bedrooms and 1 full bath, there’s space to comfortably accommodate 4 people or a family with children. Both bedrooms feature comfortable plush queen beds. This is your place to call home for as long as you are here.

Top guest favourite
Home in Niagara Falls
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 260 reviews

Forest Hideaway - Private Apartment

Welcome to the Forest Hideway Convenient location in Canada, a short walk to Niagara Falls and the main attractions. A home away from home. This completely private unit has a Double bed and a big bathroom with a rain shower. Private entrance. A private full kitchen with everything you need. Includes free coffee and tea. Includes free a parking spot. A 43inch flat screen TVs with complimentary NetFlix and fast wifi.

Top guest favourite
A cozy interior features a comfortable seating area with a sofa and decorative pillows. A small wooden table sits in front of the sofa, and a wall-mounted television is positioned above a modern fireplace. The bright, open layout connects to a kitchenette visible in the background.
Tiny homes in Port Colborne
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 242 reviews

Tiny Farm Retreat

Escape to the Country to relax and reset! You’ll love our Tiny House with your own designated outdoor space. It’s totally private and separate from our family home to ensure a peaceful getaway. Perfect for a romantic trip or a quiet space to refresh. This small cottage is built on an oversized trailer frame, and feels very spacious. A private 4 season hot tub allows you to enjoy outdoors all year long!

Top guest favourite
A spacious living area opens to the kitchen, featuring a large, sectional sofa facing a mounted smart television. Bright natural light filters through multiple windows. The modern kitchen in the background is equipped with new appliances and bar seating, creating an inviting gathering space.
Home in Niagara Falls
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Modern 3-Bedroom Home, 10 mins to Falls & Golf

Relax in this stylish 3-bedroom retreat just 10 mins from the iconic Niagara Falls & Fallsview District. Backing onto Legends Golf Course, this upscale unit features high-end finishes, a full kitchen, and a cozy pull-out sofa. Perfect for families, golfers & explorers seeking comfort and convenience in a prime location. Equipped with ping pong table and games table for an ideal family getaway!

Top guest favourite
A charming exterior view of a recently renovated home is captured at night. Soft light illuminates the entrance and windows, while snow gently covers the surrounding area. The welcoming porch features wooden railings and steps leading to the front door, framed by trees in the background.
Vacation home in Niagara Falls
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

Gorgeous Gem in Niagara’s Wine Country

A newly renovated, well appointed artistic home. Centrally located near the Falls, Niagara Parkway, Niagara-on-the-Lake, casinos, wineries and the largest outlet mall in Canada. (A car is recommended since the closest public transportation is 2 km away.) A great gathering spot in any season with a full kitchen, laundry and outdoor space ready to entertain family and friends.

Superhost
Apartment in Niagara Falls
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

Charming 2BR Apartment• 15 Mins to Niagara Falls

Enjoy the waterfront view from this centrally located home, just 15 minutes from one of the most famous waterfalls in the world, Niagara Falls, and 25 minutes away from the City of Buffalo! **Located 26 miles from Highmark Stadium (Home of the Buffalo Bills). Go BILLS! **Located 17 miles from the Key Bank Center (Home of the Buffalo Sabres).

Popular amenities for Cayuga Island vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Niagara County
  5. Niagara Falls
  6. Cayuga Island