Vacation rentals in Conestoga

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Conestoga

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favourite
A view of lush green farmland stretches under a pastel sky, where sheep graze peacefully in the foreground. A white fence frames the scene, with distant barns and trees outlining the landscape, creating a serene countryside setting.
Barn in Ronks
5 out of 5 average rating, 247 reviews

The Carriage House: Beautiful Farmland Views.

The Carriage House is the second floor of our cedar stables that was turned into an apartment years ago. It was completely redone this spring and professionally decorated to make it a cozy + luxe retreat with views to die for. While we no longer use the stables to house animals we still keep a few head of cattle + sheep in the pasture for your enjoyment. The wall of windows along the back of the apartment offer you the most stunning views of the surrounding farmland and an unforgettable sunrise.

Top guest favourite
A cozy living area features a stone wall accentuated by natural light from multiple windows. Two upholstered armchairs and a sectional sofa are arranged around a fireplace, which is complemented by a mounted television above a wooden shelf. A floor lamp stands nearby.
Barn in Quarryville
5 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews

The Barn at Locustwood Farm

Come enjoy your stay in our 1900 sq ft 19thcentury restored stone barn. We’re 15 minutes from Sight and Sound and the shops at Strasburg. With lots of trails and the Susquehanna River close by, your family can spend many hours hiking in southern Lancaster County. Experience the local Britain Hill Vineyard,coffee,and ice cream shops nearby. The charming city of Lancaster with its many authentic restaurants is only a 20 minute drive. We would love to have you come and enjoy the barn stay with us

Top guest favourite
A welcoming living area features a light-colored sofa adorned with yellow and gray cushions. A coffee table sits at the center on a patterned rug, with natural wood beams enhancing the ceiling. Large windows allow natural light to illuminate the space, overlooking the greenery outside.
Home in Pequea
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

The Trolley House / Romantic getaway

Step into history in our 1860-built stone home, where character meets modern comfort. This charming abode exudes timeless appeal, showcasing the craftsmanship of yesteryear alongside contemporary amenities for a perfect blend of old-world charm and convenience. Nestled along the Pequea Creek, outdoor enthusiasts can embark on scenic hikes right from the front door, leading to a picturesque covered bridge. Immerse yourself in the tranquility of this historic gem, where every corner tells a story.

Top guest favourite
A dining area features a sturdy wooden table surrounded by four chairs. Natural light is provided by large windows that overlook the yard. A woven light fixture hangs overhead, and a potted plant is displayed on the table, adding a touch of greenery.
Guesthouse in New Providence
5 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Farmette Guesthouse|Fire pit|Private|Creekside

Nestled between Amish farms just south of Lancaster City, the Spring House on Big Beaver Creek provides a quiet & relaxing getaway. Located on 5 acres along creek, the Spring House is a private two bedroom guest house that is attached to our family’s home. Relax by the fire pit overlooking the pasture, walk down to the banks of the creek and enjoy the slow moving waters. 10-15 Min: ⇒Downtown Lancaster ⇒Fulton Theatre ⇒Sight & Sound Theatre ⇒Amazing food!

Guest favourite
A serene bedroom is featured with a spacious bed dressed in a soft green coverlet. Natural light enters through two windows, framed by light-colored blinds. A wooden dresser and a plant add subtle touches, while a patterned area rug complements the hardwood floor.
Home in Conestoga
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

The Safe Harbor Home (Peaceful, Quiet, Nature)

Quiet and calming, this retreat rests at the end of a private road in a historic village, nestled right up against the forest. Under 30 minutes from: -Spooky Nook Sports -Dutch Wonderland -Tanger Outlets -Sight and Sound Theatres -Downtown Lancaster -Central Market -Lauxmont Farms -Fulton Theatre -Strasburg Railroad -Tanglewood Manor Golf Club -Lancaster Convention Center -56 minutes from Hershey Park -10 minutes from the Pequea Boat Launch -11 minutes from Millersville University

Guest favourite
A bright bedroom features a wooden four-poster bed adorned with neutral linens. Two large windows allow natural light to fill the space, while soft curtains drape along the walls. A decorative area rug adds warmth, complemented by a dresser and a stylish mirror.
Home in Willow Street
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

Charming School House|Outdoor Sauna|Hot tub

You'll love our home & this amazing piece of history staying in the former one room Amish school house. ⇒Hot Tub ⇒55" Smart TV ⇒King room ⇒Quiet, private ⇒ Outdoor fire-pit with wood provided ⇒Cornhole, KUBE, Croquet ⇒Front Porch w/ seating ⇒Fully stocked kitchen ⇒Weber Propane Grill ⇒Fireplace 15-20 Min: ⇒Downtown Lancaster ⇒Fulton Theatre ⇒Sight & Sound Theatre ⇒Amazing food! ✭"Tyler was one of the most responsive hosts we've ever had"✭

Guest favourite
The two-story farmhouse features a classic red brick exterior with a covered porch. Large windows provide ample natural light. A sprawling tree is situated nearby, complemented by lush green grass that surrounds the home, adding to the serene rural ambiance.
Farm stay in Conestoga
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews

Cozy Hilltop Farmhouse

Our cozy farmhouse is your home away from home! This Lancaster county farm is nearly 100 acres of rolling hills and will provide you with a peaceful farm atmosphere with amazing sunrises and sunsets! Perfect for a romantic getaway. There is 1 bedroom with a queen size bed, attached full bath. 1 pullout couch in living room. 1/2 bath on first floor. Come experience the rich heritage of Amish country while checking out the many nearby Lancaster attractions. Also, say hi to our 20 beautiful hens!

Top guest favourite
A spacious living area features a high, wood-paneled ceiling and a prominent stone fireplace, providing warmth and ambiance. Multiple large windows allow natural light to brighten the room, while comfortable seating arrangements encourage relaxation and conversation.
Cabin in Millersville
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

Waterfront Terrain- Relax, Unplug, Enjoy!

This 2,000 sq. ft. House is perfect for families looking to RELAX and UNPLUG in the countryside of Lancaster County while still being close to major attractions. This cabin is nestled between two hills, making it the most serene spot in the area. You will enjoy hearing the gentle rustles of the creek or spot a deer, or eagle! Play ping-pong in basement or lounge in open concept living room with your favorite beverage can also be experienced when you choose to stay at the Waterfront Terrain!

Top guest favourite
A comfortable living room is furnished with a light-colored sofa and a plaid accent chair. Natural light fills the space through large windows adorned with sheer curtains. A wooden coffee table and lamp are positioned near a TV setup, creating a cozy, inviting area.
Apartment in Millersville
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 526 reviews

Comfortable one bedroom with parking

This is a first-floor, one-bedroom apartment with full eat-in kitchen, and living room with Netflix-only t.v. Terrific for budget-conscious travelers who like to save by eating in; families, business travelers and visitors of Millersville University. There is a small bathroom off the bedroom with shower. A private entrance to come and go as you please. Located in a safe neighborhood, this secure apartment is clean and offers plenty of off-street parking. Just 5 miles from Lancaster City.

Guest favourite
The bathroom is designed with a modern aesthetic, featuring a double vanity with rectangular sinks and sleek gold fixtures. Textured wall tiles create a warm backdrop, while a glass shower enclosure accommodates an inviting shower space.
Apartment in Gordonville
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 576 reviews

“Buy the ticket, take the ride” - Luxury retreat

Welcome to a luxurious, countryside retreat in Lancaster, PA - part of a former farmer’s motel turned into a boutique retreat. This thoughtfully renovated space blends cozy charm with modern luxury. Enjoy a comfy queen bed, clean finishes, luxurious bathroom and a peaceful vibe located just minutes from downtown Lancaster, Amish markets, and scenic countryside. Ideal for couples or solo travelers looking for a quiet, stylish place to rest and recharge in the heart of Lancaster, PA.

Superhost
The charming entrance of the cottage features a covered porch with wooden pillars and two chairs. A welcoming door is flanked by decorative shutters and a simple wreath. Landscaping includes flower beds and a stone pathway leading up to the porch.
Cottage in Conestoga
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 382 reviews

Safe Harbor Cottage

This newly remodeled, quaint and cute cottage is sure to please! With over one acre of land to enjoy, beautiful sunrises, a deck with a grill ready to go and of course a HOT TUB to relax in! Enjoy staying among the beautiful countryside of Lancaster County, but a few miles from Lancaster City! Many area attractions listed below for all to enjoy! *Turkey Hill, Enola Low Grade and Columbia Rail Trails *Spooky Nook *Sight and Sound Theatre *Lancaster Central Market

Top guest favourite
A charming blue cottage is set against a backdrop of greenery. The entrance features a dark blue door adorned with a decorative wreath. A spacious deck is visible, framed by trees and a small landscaped area with a potted plant.
Cottage in Conestoga
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Creswell Cottage/no pets

This quaint little secluded cottage. Enjoy beautiful sunrises. Sit on the deck and watch the deer, turkey, rabbits squirrels, and plenty of birds. You can even hear bullfrogs croaking from the neighbors water garden. No pets allowed Enjoy staying among the beautiful countryside of Lancaster County Area attractions include- -turkey hill/enola low grade and Columbia northwest rail trails -site and sound theater -the Fulton theater -Lancaster Central Market

Popular amenities for Conestoga vacation rentals