Vacation rentals in Crestline

Upscale Loft w/hot tub in Private Wooded Setting

Situated just minutes from Mohican, Malabar, and Snowtrails (not far from I-71 or mid-ohio) this is the perfect couples getaway. Settle in to a serene stay with everything you need for a memorable retreat. Hot tub, walk in couples rain shower, kitchenette, cozy fireplace, out door propane fire ring, and luxurious bedding accommodations all nestled in a beautiful wooded landscape. Host is available just off the main driveway. Makes the perfect retreat for couples needing a romantic get-a-way.

The Red Dahlia Guesthouse

A car collector's paradise reimagined into a beautiful guest house situated on 20 acres of manicured landscape, pond, and woods. Lodging includes a deck with built-in grill overlooking the trees and wildlife where guests can enjoy their morning coffee or a private BBQ. Toast marshmallows at the fire pit or play a game of Pickleball, too. Located less than 15 minutes from area attractions including Mid-Ohio Racetrack, Mansfield's historic downtown, Shawshank prison, and restaurants and nightlife.

Luxury Romantic Cabin Retreat w/ Hot Tub: Mohican*

Relax and enjoy this unique romantic luxury retreat. Craftmanship and charm in every detail. The setting is in the country with the cabin nested just inside the woods with a stream and seasonal waterfall, although easy access to highways. With a relaxing jetted hot tub and 2 screened in porches to relax. A loft with a soft cozy luxury queen bed, kitchen, electric fireplace, one of a kind firepit, beautiful bathroom with antique stain glass windows. Perfect for couples for a romantic getaway!

Cozy & Charming Guesthouse

A peaceful getaway that has been meticulously maintained and thoughtfully decorated. This private guesthouse is situated on 10 acres less than 5 minutes from downtown Bellville and just 5 miles off I-71. Unwind on the comfortable couch or one of the two outdoor spaces that have great country views. On the main level where you enter you will find a desk, half bath and washer/dryer. Upstairs is the main living space with a dining table, living room, kitchen, full bath, and spacious queen bedroom.

Erinwood Farms

This memorable place is anything but ordinary. Summer has arrived, and it is one of the prettiest times of the year at Erinwood Farms which is located in the Ohio countryside, just 30 miles from Cedar Point You will be staying in our new Barn, which features a queen bed and two pull-out beds, a kitchenette, and coffee machine. Whether you're seeking a serene country getaway or a peaceful spot to recharge after exploring nearby tourist attractions, Erinwood is the perfect destination for you!

The Reformatory Retreat

Perfectly located in central Mansfield at the end of a quiet street. This 2 bedroom home is close to the best of the cities attractions, including the famous Ohio State Reformatory only a 6 minute drive away. Also, conveniently located close to Kingwood Center, hospitals, and Mid-Ohio Raceway. This home has everything you need from cooking your own meals to doing laundry. Enjoy evenings on the back deck or around the firepit. Disc golf basket and discs are provided for your entertainment.

Wooded Aframe Retreat | Hot Tub and Outdoor Shower

We look forward to welcoming you to the secluded beauty of our space, designed and built by my husband on our 20 acres of wooded property in the rolling hills of Central Ohio. A floor-to-ceiling glass front provides you with a view of fields green in summertime and ripe with goldenrod in the fall, four outdoor deck spaces invite you to relax in the beauty of nature, and a second story loft suite with a soaking tub are ready to provide you with rest and refreshment.

Inn a Schoolhouse; circa 1895

Romantic get-away in a historic one-room schoolhouse! We are approx. 15 minutes to most area attractions, restaurants, wineries, shopping and nature! Mid-Ohio Race Track, Ohio State Reformatory-SHAWSHANK; Clearfork Reservoir, Kingwood Center Gardens, Ohio Bird Sanctuary and the beautiful paved Richland B&O bike trail. ALL NEW FOR 2026 - Relax and pamper each other in our newly decorated massage and relaxation room! Dark and moody and very romantic!

The Carriage House- "Coachman's Inn unit"

160 Year old Historic Landmark, Centrally located in downtown Mansfield! Just a couple minute drive to Prohibition at the Caverns or about a 15 minute walk to the Carousel District! Originally built as a Carriage Barn for the Bissman Family circa 1860 ...Only 3.2 Miles from the Reformatory, 9.7 Miles from Mid Ohio Race Track, 1 Mile from Kingwood Center & only 7.3 Miles from Snow Trails Ski Resort! Rest assured we take cleaning very serious!

The Black Weller Inn

This beautiful fully updated historic home is located right in the heart of Crestline! With The Hub event center right down the road, multiple local restaurants, and local retailers within walking distance, there will always be something fun to do. This home sits centrally located and your able to get to the Mansfield Reformatory, Mid-Ohio Sports Car Course, Snow Trails Ski Resort, and many more attractions all within 20 minutes!!

GG’S Place - Where memories are made.

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. This house was built in the 1900’s. The Fox family moved in around 1955. GG lived here until 2025. Raising seven children here, many memories were made. We look forward to sharing this home with friends we know and people we meet along this adventure. We also have a pickleball court available for you to make a reservation to use.

The Voegele Historic Loft BnB Apartment

The Voegele Historic Lofts in Mansfield's revitalized Carrousel District offers Guest couples a delicious taste of the best of downtown's arts, music, and culinary culture. A newly redesigned private one bedroom(plus) suite serves as your homebase for friends/family visits or to spring from to any number of local venues and activities.