Skip to content

Top restaurant recommendations from locals

Seafood Restaurant
$$
“One of our summertime favorite places. Angela votes this the best lobster roll on Cape Cod despite all other claims! During peak season go early or be prepared to wait in line and risk not finding a parking spot. If you find parking, don't dismay, the line moves quickly! We often choose lunch during the busy season. Seating is all outdoors on communal picnic tables so the atmosphere is beachy casual which includes BYOB. In addition to bringing your own beer or wine, bring cash, this is a cash only establishment althought there is an ATM on site.”
  • 60 locals recommend
American Restaurant
$$
“Want to meet some of the locals? Go hang at the baaah. You'll catch an earful of those Baaastin accents while you knock a few back. Look for my brother's license plate hanging amongst their collection which covers the ceiling and walls. Surfs Up. I happen to love the Portugues Soup - Kale, potatoes, beans and Chorizo. I mean... All the food is good but that's my go to.”
  • 37 locals recommend
French Restaurant
$$$
“Authentic French bakery and restaurant. Provides amazing pastries. Sometimes a line but it moves fast and well worth it ”
  • 52 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“This is a locals spot- we always go here for special occasions. I absolutely love Mac's Shack for everything from draft beer and cocktails to sushi to fresh seafood. These folks know what they are doing and the atmosphere is impeccable. Sit inside or out- odds are, one of the waitstaff helping you is a local and a friend of mine. Great people, great food. Plus- they have Gluten Free options”
  • 48 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$$
“Excellent, top quality food. A bit pricey and be ready to wait. However, if you want some good food and fine dining...this is the place to go in Brewster. ”
  • 27 locals recommend
Wine Bar
$$
“creative types hit this charming hangout for art shows & live music, plus wine bar & local fare.”
  • 19 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$
“American fare served alongside New & Old World wines in a Colonial setting with a fireplace.”
  • 24 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Local restaurant with more upscale dishes and a full bar with a nice atmosphere.”
  • 24 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$
“One of the best restaurants on Cape Cod is right in Sandwich (10 min drive) super fresh right off the boat seafood and shellfish, a raw bar and sushi. Local favorite and casual but can be considered a more fancy night out as food is upscale.”
  • 26 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Lunch or dinner, Sunday brunch, water views, expansive menu, just really good food.”
  • 16 locals recommend
Restaurant
$
“Stop at Sunbird on your way to the Cape Cod National Seashore for a coffee and treat. They also serve healthy lunch items, including salads and quinoa bowls. Highly recommend the chocolate chip cookie with a hint of orange and salt.”
  • 16 locals recommend
American Restaurant
$$
“Relaxed, "Cape-y" place. Food is very good. A bit of a ride but worth it. ”
  • 18 locals recommend
American Restaurant
$$$
“Tucked in the quiet east end, The Mews is open year round and has gluten free options. A must dine experience. As always, reservations are recommended. The Mews hosts a weekly Monday night open mic. ”
  • 30 locals recommend
Sandwich Place
$$
“Open year round, food is delicious and atmosphere is so much fun...frozen on the beach?”
  • 24 locals recommend
Hotel
$$$
“Parking. Trendy and fairly expensive. People love this restaurant for the incredible views of the bay especially during sunset. They also have an oyster bar during the afternoon if you want to sit in an Adirondack chair and stare at the water.”
  • 25 locals recommend
Restaurant
$
“Family-owned roadside stop for hearty servings of cooked-to-order comfort food until afternoon. A great meal at affordable prices! Grumpy’s is the place to go for breakfast or lunch year-round 7 days a week from 6 AM to 2 PM.”
  • 23 locals recommend