Skip to content

Top bakery recommendations from locals

Pie Shop
$$
“PIE! And really good pie at that. They have a big communal table and I've witnessed a few interviews taking place here. Great vibe. ”
  • 49 locals recommend
Garden
$$
“Great spot right next to the train station. Try their cake truffels or bagel bombs! You won't regret it.”
  • 27 locals recommend
Bakery
$
“Carbohydrates enjoy bygone reverence at this cozy Henry Street fixture. Try the best-selling lard bread studded with bits of salami and provolone, or the porous, pillowy ciabatta, jacketed in a hearty, flour-dusted crust.”
  • 24 locals recommend
Bakery
$$
“My birthday treat go to spot! The best Italian bakery - fruit tarts, pignoili cookies, mascarpone, chocolate tarts - make sure you try them all. ”
  • 16 locals recommend
Bagel Shop
$
“Very good bagels. Very irritating tables. If the weather is good, take your bagel across the street and eat it in the always-lovely Carroll Park.”
  • 10 locals recommend
Bakery
$
“The is a bread bakery. They make and sell delicious bread. Go one block further to Monteleone's for pastries. That's how we roll in Brooklyn!! ”
  • 9 locals recommend
Bakery
$
“Great spot for breakfast, brunch, coffee, snacks, or lunch. Amazing treats shop that once was only a food truck! ”
  • 4 locals recommend
Bakery
$
“Best bagels in the area, always hot and fresh. Grab one before heading to the subway.”
  • 3 locals recommend
Restaurant
$
“One of the oldest Italian bakeries in New York. Get the Lobster Tail, Italian Ice, Cheesecake, and (if you still have room) cookies by the pound.”
  • 4 locals recommend
Bakery
$
“We love their muffins and chocolate croissants and their sandwiches are so good!”
  • 2 locals recommend