Skip to content

Top restaurant recommendations from locals

American Restaurant
$$
“A favorite! Sophisticated bar scene. Part of the Hillstone Group, well known for their beautiful rich interiors, open kitchen, superior service and great food! ”
  • 45 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$
“This and Bostwick's On the Harbor off Gann Road in Springs are def favorites for Seafood!!! The Harbor has incredibly beautiful sunsets and great happy hour specials. The Chowder House is casual and fun w extra delish seafood! Warning: ALWAYS CROWDED!”
  • 35 locals recommend
Italian Restaurant
$$$
“Casual Italian restaurant that is kid friendly! Also, a nice place for a drink and great outdoor seating.”
  • 28 locals recommend
New American Restaurant
$$$$
“Historic inn built in 1770 with lovely restaurants upstairs and in the tavern downstairs. ”
  • 18 locals recommend
Italian Restaurant
$$
“Long history of being super cozy w delicious food and extra delicious pizza!!!”
  • 18 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“I don't understand this photo! This is a real sort of Irish Pub w exceptional dining! usually sports on tv at bar, dining room always bustling. Most known for their delicious burgers(beef, turkey, veggie) the menu and specials are wonderful before or after movie or just to relax and enjoy an evening inside or out(in summer only).”
  • 22 locals recommend
Steakhouse
$$$
“Well known and beloved, The Palm is a classic sophisticated Steak House w white table cloths and great service. If you want to keep it casual, try the bar area. BEST bartenders. Super cozy! Clearly the Steaks and Lobster are outstanding, but really ANY dish there is to die for! Great sides and family style. TELL SHEILA WE SENT YOU!;-)”
  • 12 locals recommend
Organic, local, vegan-friendly fare in a cozy café
$$
“When you don't mind an expensive breakfast in East Hampton before shopping..”
  • 14 locals recommend
Diner
$$
“Great for all day breakfast and lunch. Old school diner type place with Greek specialties. ”
  • 9 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Late night ice cream - and early morning fresh Dreesen's Donuts, made before your eyes and hot from the oven. Have a couple there and take home a dozen. Yum!”
  • 9 locals recommend
Bar
“A pretty boutique hotel with a Scandinavian influence located at the end of our street. Come here for a nice brunch, cocktails, also a pretty back patio to sit and enjoy the scenery.”
  • 8 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$$
“Walk to this excellent restaurant, near the train station. Sit at the bar for dinner.”
  • 5 locals recommend
Coffee Shop
$$
“High end cafe and take out spot. Baked goods, soups, sandwiches, salads and great tasting coffee ! Great place for a quick coffee and muffin !”
  • 7 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Delicious Italian in a really charming restaurant and cozy fireplace. Sister restaurant is in Sag Harbor.”
  • 3 locals recommend
Bar
$$$
“Since you chose to stay at our charming cottage rather than the historic Maidstone Inn, go instead, for a cocktail and excellent, but pricy, farm-to-table Scandinavian inspired meal.”
  • 5 locals recommend
American Restaurant
$$$
“If you feel like going somewhere very nice with great food, but don’t want to travel to Sag, Bridge or East Hampton then look no further than Highway Restaurant - you’ll not be disappointed ”
  • 3 locals recommend