Skip to content

Top restaurant recommendations from locals

Seafood Restaurant
$$$
“Best food in town; though pricey, it's well worth it. Try the Oysters Friskafella.”
  • 24 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$
“Probably Greenport’s most famous restaurant. Main restaurant has a bit more formal menu than the Waterfront. Waterfront/Pier dining is more casual, and a great atmosphere especially in the summer when they have live music. Highly recommend for both food and drinks!”
  • 19 locals recommend
Bar
$$$
“Probably our favorite restaurant in the North Fork. Nice variety on the menu. Cool but casual (like all of the north fork) scene.”
  • 25 locals recommend
A wide array of oysters in a former bait and tackle shop
$$
“Tucked away behind the buildings of Front St. Access down path next to Ralph’s Italian Ice & Ice Cream.”
  • 17 locals recommend
Hotel
“This is a great restaurant with a very nice ambience. You need to make reservations. There is almost always a wait. ”
  • 14 locals recommend
Restaurant
“This is one of my favorite places in Greenport. Sarah and Dan are the owners and are the ultimate Greenport hosts. The food, the atmosphere and the staff are incredible! ”
  • 19 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“One of my favorite places to eat on the North Fork! Mouth-watering tacos. ”
  • 15 locals recommend
Pizza Place
$$
“Best pizza place in the area. Wood fired ovens and in a great location in the heart of Greenport.”
  • 9 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Probably Greenport’s most famous restaurant. Main restaurant has a bit more formal menu than the Waterfront. Waterfront/Pier dining is more casual, and a great atmosphere especially in the summer when they have live music. Highly recommend for both food and drinks!”
  • 8 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Brunch favorite! This is one of the more upscale choices in Greenport for brunch. They are only opened on the weekends during brunch. ”
  • 10 locals recommend
Sushi Restaurant
$$
“This is a great sushi choice with very authentic and fresh options and is an easy 5 minute walk (.3 miles)”
  • 3 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Barista made beverages and a creative menu made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients – and love. From the Crazy Beans website: “We cook everything to order. We believe that when you go out to eat, you deserve to have your meal prepared just for you. Sure it takes a bit longer, but it’s worth it… We are from here and live here. Because of that, we love our community and we support our local businesses. Our amazing staff makes Crazy Beans possible. They work really hard. We love them. Please be nice to them. On that note: we’re not robots. If there is anything we can do better, please tell us. We are here to make you happy. That’s the truth. What it comes down to is this: we love eating a”
  • 4 locals recommend
Bar
$
“I love this place. A lobster roll, an outdoor table and some good local wine. Thats all I need.”
  • 8 locals recommend
Italian Restaurant
$$$
“Ok, honestly, i'm reluctant to even tell you about this one because next to American Beech, it is my favorite and i'd like to keep it to myself!! It is a stylish instant transport into some kind of utopian futuristic yet nostalgic Italian world. It is absolutely gorgeous inside and out. American Beech has had better vegan options in the past, but the food here is very unique and artistic. This place is a beauty worth seeing at least once (or every weekend ha ha).”
  • 4 locals recommend
Bar
“Pick up stuff for lunch here. Great salads, breads, baked goods - especially pies. ”
  • 5 locals recommend
Restaurant
“This is a great choice to eat on the water. Lunch and dinner are both really nice. The ferry to cross over to Shelter Island is right next to it so if you plan to travel across to the South Fork through Shelter Island or to explore Shelter Island this might be a good choice before or after. You can walk here but its about a 20 minute walk from 744 Main Street ”
  • 4 locals recommend