Skip to content

Best restaurants in Highlands

Seafood Restaurant
$$
“A landmark destination restaurant. It's a tradition...Right on the water, one feels as if they are inside of a great big ship...( actually I think it is!) and there is a mini museum inside with great old photos and oceanic Brik-a-brac. Oh and the food...usually excellent! Great service too. Not cheap, but great. ”
10 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$
“Restaurant and Bar with live music on weekends. On the water, great for sunset views. Favs tuna taco appetizers (but large enough for entree) ask for it in a soft tortilla and conch fritters. During summer, reservations suggested.”
11 locals recommend
American Restaurant
$$
“Great views of Sandy Hook while enjoying live music, good food, and drinks.”
5 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“always packed, food isnt great but their outside deck can be a lot of fun (if you like crowds and live music)”
8 locals recommend
Mexican Restaurant
$$
“Great Mexican food and bar.....over 250 Tequilas Lov grilled shrimp enchiladas...”
6 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Everything is farm to table, BYOB. Everything is fabulous. My favs. crab cake appetizer and scallop entrée and lobster entrée, carrot cake. Ask for our favorite waiter COUZIMO, tell him Daniella sent you. Reservations recommended in the summer. ”
5 locals recommend
Italian Restaurant
$$
“This is a great little Italian BYOB. The food is amazing. The eggplant parm is off the charts. ”
4 locals recommend
Bar
“This is a local bar. They have an indoor and outdoor bar. They usually have live music and or events. The wings are awesome.”
4 locals recommend
Fast Food Restaurant
$
“Great cafe/bistro. Serving breakfast and lunch and also dinners to go, smoothies, fresh juices, sandwiches, fresh soups, salads, home made deserts, loaf breads potato chips, pita chips and more.... In/outdoor dining and take out.”
4 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$$
“Great outdoor casual seafood restaurant, bar, icecream shop on the water. Great views of Sandy Hook/NYC skyline. Bahrs owns, but half the price.”
4 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Cuban food with great mojitos and a delicious cuban sandwich. They sometimes have live music on Saturdays or Sundays”
3 locals recommend
Restaurant
1 local recommends
New American Restaurant
$$$
“Lovely new restaurant on the water! Great live music! Outside on the deck and patio with drinks, good food and company- you can't beat it!”
3 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Anything and everything fresh from the sea. They are the seafood supplier for all the local restaurants. Seafood market, takeaway only, catering. ”
2 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Great Italian food..... Reservations suggested in the summer. Closed Sunday and Monday BYOB ”
1 local recommends
Pizza Place
$
“Italian restaurant. All their food is good but they have the best pizza around.”
2 locals recommend