Skip to content

Top restaurant recommendations from locals

American Restaurant
$$
“Very popular, reasonably priced, large portions. Large menu and great spot to purchase cheeses, homemade chocolates and hard to find beers. ”
  • 32 locals recommend
American Restaurant
$$
“Perfect for a special night out or an afternoon cocktail. The property is gorgeous so is the drive up the mountain. ”
  • 37 locals recommend
Breakfast Spot
$
“Pop in for the standard coffee shop soup/salad/sandwich, but stay for the donuts! Do you really think you can make a trip to Tannersville WITHOUT having a fresh, made-to-order s’mores donut? The answer is no, you really can’t. Also a great spot just to hang, with comfy couches and relaxed vibe.”
  • 25 locals recommend
Burger Joint
$
“Great burgers (vegetarian options too) and ice cream spot. Wonderful after a hike. ”
  • 32 locals recommend
Bar
“Modern and minimalist hip hotel with good pool parties during the summer as well as movie nights. ”
  • 21 locals recommend
Breakfast Spot
$
“I love this place especially for breakfast. Its a 5 minute walk to this Zagat rated hot spot. I get there about 7:30 am and sit outside watching the village wake up. Breakfast for me is 2 eggs over easy and bacon. She makes these roasted potatoes that are to die for and always adds salad and sauteed veggies. Her french toast and pancakes are delicious and always a interesting twist. Could be expensive for kids. Check her out on line delicious.”
  • 28 locals recommend
Mexican Restaurant
$$
“If you’re looking for the good ole Tex-Mex food you know and love, look no further. The food’s definitely worth your time, but the margarita’s nothing to write home about. ”
  • 19 locals recommend
German Restaurant
$$
“Hearty and authentic German fare! Great after a hike or a day on the slopes.”
  • 20 locals recommend
American Restaurant
$$
“The restaurant at Scribner's Catskill Lodge. A wonderful view & incredible food. A great spot to catch the sunset over the mountains.”
  • 18 locals recommend
Miscellaneous Shop
$$
“Main Street, Hunter. These guys are pouring the classics in addition to rotating and local flavors each week, and the food is standard pub fare. A solid choice for a few beers and a few laughs within minutes of the cottage.”
  • 13 locals recommend
Meal Takeaway
“Great eats if you like BBQ type foods and a great beer selection. Good for families, dates, or groups.”
  • 11 locals recommend
Restaurant
“A solid stand-by for brunch, lunch and dinner on Main Street in Tannersville, with locally sourced food and a rotating menu. Lots of outdoor seating and a decent bar for a laid-back evening.”
  • 8 locals recommend
Restaurant
“An extension of their first location in Windham, NY. Sit down or take out, the Country store is great for breakfast or lunch, or a quick browse with the kids. They sell tons of toys, candies and country gifts. Another note worthy reason to stop in is for their home made fudge and old fashioned ice cream!”
  • 7 locals recommend
Restaurant
“This is an entertainment complex near hunter mtn ski area where you can play paintball, ride horses and snow mobiles. Check out their website for more info. ”
  • 8 locals recommend
Restaurant
“This is one of those buildings that looks small on the outside and then surprises you when you get in. The place is so authentically French that the chef is named Gerard. Reasonably priced bottles of wine and a dining room with a roaring fireplace make this a must see experience. You will need a reservation on a holiday weekend but you’ll probably be okay without one otherwise, especially on a week night. ”
  • 6 locals recommend
Restaurant
“I almost don't want to tell my guests because I don't want it overrun with visitors, but it is too good to keep secret.”
  • 6 locals recommend