Skip to content

Top restaurant recommendations from locals

Seafood Restaurant
$$
“Best place to see the Florida Keys Sunset. Great Food. Restaurant has a built in pool Boat Docking Live Music”
  • 20 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Great food, service, drinks and has a friendly, casual atmosphere on the water.”
  • 13 locals recommend
Bar
$$$
“Their calamari is hands down the best I've ever had. Conch fritters are good too! Wait to sit by the water if you can!”
  • 15 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“The choice of stake, sea food and sushi was more than enough to chose from. They do have a happy hour, so arrive early and stay late. ”
  • 13 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Great food and beautiful setting. Try the little coconut/lime mints after dinner.”
  • 5 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$
“Grab a burger here! They're amazing! Or really most things on their menu :)”
  • 9 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Restaurant and Bar... less than a mile walk. Stunning ocean-view... so so food, nice bar.”
  • 4 locals recommend
Cafe
$$$
“This is our go-to dining option for date nights and special celebrations! Located in a beautiful, traditional Key West style building, and set in a tropical garden, the Butterfly Cafe offers fine dining experiences for both lunch and dinner. Diners can choose indoor or outdoor seating. The outdoor seating area is on a large porch overlooking the resort pool and beautiful, tropical landscaped garden. The Butterfly features fine dining with excellent service, delicious food, and great drinks from the bar. Reservations recommended. ”
  • 4 locals recommend
Restaurant
$
“The Stuffed Pig is known for their delicious breakfasts, large portions, and reasonable prices. They also serve lunch, and have both indoor seating, and tables out back under a large tiki hut. If you're interested in trying something different, order their gator tail and eggs! ”
  • 5 locals recommend
Bar
“This long-time local's favorite restaurant is located on the golf course in Key Colony Beach, a small community near Marathon. This traditional restaurant serves lunch and dinner, and features a large menu with many Italian options as well as steaks, seafood, and sandwiches. The bar is known for great martinis! Try the espresso martini! It's one of our favorites. We also recommend the prime rib and salmon dinners, and the Ahi tuna appetizer! Along with great service, this restaurant has lots of menu options and every diner should be able to find something they love! ”
  • 5 locals recommend
Bar
“ We enjoy going there for Happy hour, there are several appetizers that are 1/2 off till 6”
  • 4 locals recommend
Bar
“We have never been, but heard from numerous people how good the food was. You may want to make a reservation before going. This restaurant has indoor seating only (strip mall)”
  • 6 locals recommend
Restaurant
$
“We love Pass A Grille and the Hurricane is a great first stop off. Head up to the top floor for a drink and to check out the view of the whole beach. ”
  • 1 local recommends
Restaurant
$$
“Small, bustling breakfast & lunch diner with a quirky vibe & many wooden spoons on the walls.”
  • 3 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$$
“Good meal, unique location. How many 7 mile bridges does one get to traverse? As with all Keys restaurants, save room for key lime pie. I only eat it when in the Keys. ”
  • 2 locals recommend
Restaurant
$
“Casual seafood with Cuban flair Will cook your catch Good quality very reasonable ”
  • 3 locals recommend