Jim and Dave were very welcoming and friendly. We felt at home. We rented all three rooms that were available - five of us stayed there for two nights while we attended a family wedding. The beds were very comfortable, rooms were great, breakfast was perfect!

We had a wonderful experience. Jim and David were very nice, accommodating, and helpful with information for a fall foliage drive.

Jim's a great host, he met us when we arrived and gave us the whole tour. The next morning he made us a lovely breakfast and even gave me a ride over to the casino to pick up my car. The house is really nice too, super comfortable. We didnt get to try the massage unfortunately, maybe next time.

Jim's place was absolutely perfect for our short visit to Monticello. He's such an interesting guy - loved sitting on the patio and hearing about his adventures. Jim's the ideal host and we were more than impressed with his hospitality. His place had cool furnishings and an extremely great vibe. We would have loved to stay longer. Thanks Jim!

Jim and David were great hosts, They made us feel very welcome and when we got there we had a great chat in the back garden patio. They offered us drinks and we talked for about 2 hours. They were very friendly and it was very nice and tranquil in the house. They had breakfast ready for us to eat every morning and were very informative about the surrounding area. We will definitely stay with Jim and David again. We have made two new friends!

What serendipity to happen upon Jim and his incredibly cool curated home of mid-century decor and furnishings!! Upon meeting Jim, with in the first fifteen minutes it felt like we were visiting an old friend. Incredibly hospitable and considerate-Jim showed us the entire house and property , all the while sharing (URL HIDDEN) of how he has lovingly procured his fantastic collection of mid century decor and furniture. Jim is a natural with hospitality and attends to guest needs/comforts with calm cool competence. It really feels like you are staying in a dedicated "bed and breakfast". Pre- Bethel Woods concert wine and terrific conversation on the deck with Jim was a special touch ; only to resume the same great connection over a very delicious cup of coffee the next morning . Jim is a stand out- and his generosity of spirit , along with the very chic and comfortable home he opens to guests made for the perfect overnight. Guests have lounging freedom in the home and out in the lovely back yard, it's very relaxing. We look forward to joining Jim in Monticello very soon- we highly recommend him and his home and will most definitely be back !! Thank you so much Jim, xo Beth and Jeff

We enjoyed our stay at Jim's home tremendously. He was very friendly, engaging, and accomodating. When he discovered that one in our party was gluten free, he adjusted the breakfast to accommodate us. The house is clean, decorated tastefully, and conveniently located. We felt at home. There were no other guests during our stay so we had the entire upper floor to ourself. That was especially nice. We highly recommended this place.

We loved Jim's house. It was spacious, clean, and very stylishly decorated in the mid century motif. Amenities included a pool table, a piano, and a beautiful fire place that kept us warm while it was -15F degree outside. Jim himself was very hospitable and accommodating. He made himself available if we had any questions or needs, and even asked us what we wanted for breakfast. (Breakfast by the way was both delicious and exactly what we had asked for.) Jim was very knowledgeable of the area and was kind enough to give us some recommendations for how to keep busy on a frigid weekend in the Catskills, which as a result made our weekend getaway much more fun. We would definitely recommend Jim and his house and do plan on coming back in the near future!

Jim's house is pretty cool, cozy and comfortable. And Jim himself is so nice and considerate. Great stay here!

Jim and Dave were very welcoming and friendly. We felt at home. We rented all three rooms that were available - five of us stayed there for two nights while we attended a family wedding. The beds were very comfortable, rooms were great, breakfast was perfect! We have stayed at many AirBNB locatons and will say this was one of the best!

My boyfriend and I had a fantastic trip in Monticello at Jim's lovely home! From great accommodations in both our room and beyond, an amazingly decorated home (very clean and organized too!) to awesome conversations, wine and pool-table access, and a full spread for breakfast, we cannot say enough good things about our stay here. Jim is super friendly and outgoing, has had great experiences with interesting stories to tell, and provides everything you could need and want as a host. We hope to be back soon! Thanks for everything, Jim!

Nice couple, spacious clean house with amenities. Highly recommend!

Such a nice experience we stayed an extra day. Kind host, beautiful setting and home.

Cherise is an excellent communicator and very accommodating. I will be booking with her again

What a beautiful place! The photos don't do this property justice. Cherise made us feel very relaxed and welcome. We came for the proximity to the St. Nektarios Greek Orthodox Monastery in Roscoe, a wonderful spiritual retreat center. Would be delighted to come stay here again anytime.

Cherise's home is a great place to stay. She is a welcoming and gracious host and her house was comfortable, peaceful and well appointed.

Thief! Makes up rules along the way. Beware!

Lovely cabin, good balance of rustic and nicely furnished. Very relaxing stay!

Matteo was super friendly and helpful, even offering to drive us to the store when we came up on a motorcycle. The quarry was a nice walk and there are woods surrounding the house. The roads had a bit of traffic in general (even later at night). There is a small farmer's market store nearby and a large wallmart about about 8 minutes away. Kitchen is well-stocked and had stuff for S'mores! By far, our favorite thing was the fire pit in the front yard. It is large with kindling and wood everywhere. We had a lovely time. Thank you.

Matteo was a great host. He had everything prepared and the house looking wonderful when we came. He showed us around and was available if we needed to get in touch with him.

Great place. Very secluded!

Matteo is very efficient with communication, he let me book two days prior to coming up for Labor Day weekend, which was a plus since it was so last minute on a busy weekend. The house was as described , when checking in i noticed work boots around the living room and as well other personal stuff that shouldn't have been left out when expecting guests, thats my opinion. When it came to looking in detail at the beds there was hair on bedsheets in two of the three rooms(has to be from pets on premises). That caused a problem for me and my group , we had to go to Walmart to get new sheets and towels for a two night stay ... As another issue I thought was intruding to me and my guests was that Matteo stopped by unannounced .

All amazing, Brian did excellent food for us on top of the place being great! Highly recommend!

Brian's place is exactly what we were looking for. We were working in Moticello and needed a clean relaxing place to come back to each evening. Brian made himself available if we needed anything. We will be back! Thank you Brian!

My friends and I had a great time at Brian's home. The house was cozy, secluded, and exactly what we were looking for in a weekend getaway. I would definitely stay here again. Thanks again Brian!

We enjoyed our stay at Brian's place. The house is well-equipped and Brian was very helpful.

Brian's place was immaculate and equipped with anything and everything we needed to be more than comfortable! His property is beautiful! The service we received was above and beyond and he was especially personable! This place was just far enough to feel like we were away from it all but close enough to get what we needed if need be.

Brian was super helpful. We had a small issue with our stove and he came a long way to fix the issue and built a camp fire for us, which was awesome. Totally recommend him.

Wonderful host. Texted me before hand with recommendations on what to do in the area. A+++++

Brain is a champion. Great space. Great location. Great experience. We will be back often.

As this was our first experience using Airbnb, our natural first reaction prior to meeting Roberta was to feel a bit dubious, hesitant, unsure, uncomfortable and awkward. But immediately upon meeting Roberta, all of that instantly vanished and we became totally comfortable and enamored by the wonderful person that she is. Our spacious, luxurious and clean suite was perfect and absolutely delightful. We felt at home the minute we walked in the door and will definitely be returning in the future! Roberta's intelligence, energy and amiability were so magnetic that we could've spent our entire time hanging out with her! :)

Entering Roberta's home for a second time felt like visiting an old friend. She greeted us with enthusiasm and welcomed us with open arms - literally!! She went out of her way to make us comfortable and offered guidance on places to go and restaurants to try. Given the peace of the neighborhood, I had one of the best sleeps I'd had in a while. I look forward to my next visit!

Roberta was every bit of accommodating and very pleasant! Room was private and spacious. Bathroom was well kept and clean. We had a great time staying at her house and would definitely come back if we need to stay around the area again!

Very nice host and neighborhood! 5 stars!!

This was our second time staying with Roberta. She's so warm and welcoming, and the large room with a new king-size bed is perfect. We love staying here every time we visit Monticello for an event at the Motor Club.

Staying at Tim's cabin over the 4th of July weekend was an absolute blast. There are awesome hiking paths nearby which Tim sent me information on. We spent the weekend hiking, grilling, and sitting around the fire. The cabin is perfect for a weekend get away in the woods. The backyard, which is full of cars, boats, excavators gives the place a peculiar charm. Bring bug spray, extra toilet paper, and meat to grill, and be ready to enjoy Tim's cabin.

Tim is an extremely gracious host. Upon arrival, he made sure that his space was ready to go, and had enough wood for the fire pit to last us through a long weekend. His house is hidden behind a long driveway, ducked behind massive trees so it felt very secluded. In addition to an outdoor bar and a massive fire pit, there is also 26 acres of woodland to explore. He was super communicative and really went out of his way to make sure that we had a wonderful time at his home. Thanks Tim!

The atmosphere was very relaxing and quiet, the outdoors was amazing lots of scenery and if you like taking pictures you will enjoy the rustic ambiance. Charlotte was always available to answer questions. We took our 8month old baby with us and they even had a crib for him, so if you are thinking about taking the kids it's family friendly. Would recommend this place to others. Thanks Tim & Charlotte we had a blast !!!

This home was exactly what we were looking for! It was a very quiet and private location which we loved. Tim and Charlotte are great host and give you your privacy to enjoy your weekend. We were grateful for the flexible check-in/check-out time as well as the home being ready at arrival with linen and towels. We had our own space and were able to have a great time with friends in a beautiful area. We would stay here again and I would recommend it to my friends and family. Thank you for a great weekend!

Pictures do no justice to the property. It's secluded with all the latest amenities. House is cozy,clean and stocked. I would definitely go back. We really enjoyed our stay!

Great place to stay, truly unique American base.

Tims home was perfect. The fire pit was great in the evening. We wanted a weekend of relaxing away from the city and coming to tims house was it. Communication with him and charlotte were the best. Thanks again tim.

Tim was an excellent and very accommodating host. The cabin, which is behind a very long driveway, has a very secluded feel. There's a huge area of woods to explore in the back as well. The interior of the cabin itself is also quite beautiful. Everything was clean and ready for our arrival and Tim was always available for any questions.

Perfect experience! The place was very nicely decorated and maintained, and Jim accommodated every possible need. Really easy access to Bethel woods as well. Highly recommend!

Jim and Dave are terrific hosts with remarkable taste in mid-century furniture. Their house is a gem in Monticello. They also make wonderful coffee and breakfast and went above and beyond to make sure that we had a comfortable stay. We'll be back!

Jim and Dave were very welcoming and friendly. We felt at home. We rented all three rooms that were available - five of us stayed there for two nights while we attended a family wedding. The beds were very comfortable, rooms were great, breakfast was perfect!

Great hosts and a beautiful, cozy place to rest and rejuvenate

The host canceled this reservation the day before arrival. This is an automated posting.

Joe and Amy's guest house/barn had all we needed for a quick and relaxing weekend getaway. Joe was welcoming and full of suggestions of things to do in the area. The barn was a bit closer to the main house than we realized from photos but we always felt tucked away and private in our own space. It is impressive to explore and see all that Joe and his brother have built on this property. Oh and the hot tub! That was the highlight of the whole weekend--sitting in the hot tub looking at the stars. To top it all off, we left with 2 dozen fresh eggs and Joe graciously let us hand around past check-out so we could enjoy our Sunday afternoon.

The Barn was an amazing experience. The place was clean, new, cozy, comfortable and perfect for a get away weekend. Joe made the experience perfect by welcoming us and respecting our privacy. The Chickens and the Fresh eggs were my favorite part of this trip. Being from the city and being able to wake up to a beautiful sunrise and being able to walk outside be greeted by chickens and get your own eggs was great. Joe provided suggestions to some amazing hikes in the area which were amazing. I would for sure stay at the barn again! Thank you Joe!

I can hardly put this property into words. The "Barn" is simply AMAZING. The attention to detail can be seen everywhere, from the living room, to the bathroom, to the spacious loft bedroom. Joe was a terrific host. He quickly made us feel welcomed (EMAIL HIDDEN)munication was quick and clear. The fresh eggs, milk, and apple cider were also a pleasant surprise. My wife and our dog loved the chickens out back and taking hikes on the property. The pictures of the deer are not stock photos. We actually seen four deer grazing in the yard, while sipping on our morning coffee. We will certainly be back. Thank you Joe and Amy for a wonderful weekend!

Our stay was everything we expected and more... Joe was very welcoming and accomdating in every step of the way. We had fresh eggs in the morning brought from his chicken cope out front and we got a chance to feed and play with the birds... BBQ and fire pit was a big plus... The hot tub experience was an out of this world experience esp in the freezing cold....with 100% privacy! We would definitely highly recommend Joe's home to family and friends.... and will make sure to make this our family's romantic gateways. One spot in the barn on the scond floor at a specific time of the night looking over all the property litterly makes u feel on top of the wolrd! Than you Joe for everything - u r the best :)

Joe is very hospitable, generous, communicable and welcoming. The house is beautiful, clean, well furnished, and warm. The area is large so our pup was able to run around a lot in the snow, and was very interested in the chickens coop. It's a very relaxing atmosphere where you surround yourself with nature. The town is about 15 minutes away and def ask Joe about the reservoir while you visit because it's breath taking. We can't wait for our next visit!

The hospitality is perfect

Joe & Amy were wonderful hosts in this beautiful modern barn. It was just what was needed, a short drive from NYC to get away from it all. The location was quite, scenic and offers plenty to do including hiking, scenic drives and great local restaurants. The space is cozy and offers sun bather's paradise. We would definitely recommend staying at least 2 nights to take in all it's beauty. We cannot forget to mention the fresh eggs each morning - simply amazing. Book this place asap without question!

Loved our stay. Joe was a great host and was on the ball with communication. He gave us our provacy but was there when needed. Loved the barn...very cute and quiet. Favorite part of our stay was the chickens and thr fresh eggs innthr morning. :)

Mary's bed and breakfast experience was absolutely fantastic. Everything from the hospitality, cleanliness of home, and of course the incredible breakfasts and baked-goods made this trip unforgettable. The house is wonderfully close to the best bars and restaurants, Camp Lakota, wineries, and other attractions. We will absolutely be back during another visit to upstate NY. Thank you Mary!

John provided extensive information on the property and surrounding attractions before arrival and during our stay The listing description and pictures are accurate, and we were very satisfied with every aspect of this rental.

Perfectly secluded, amazingly quiet, you'll find a rare balance between comfort and nature.

The cabin was rustic and cozy, we had a really amazing stay. The pond is not a body of water for swimming, but the kayaking was fun. Check your kayak for snakes! The location was secluded, but as the other reviwers mention, you will see visitors at the main cabin if you don't book both, so it's not totally 'away from it all' – all in all it was a fabulous fun weekend and it's a perfect romantic getaway. Easy from start to finish!

This, folks, is the perfect weekend. The cabin is no-frills, but absolutely comfortable. The pond, complete with kayaks, is literally right outside the door. If you tire of the water, then jump on a bike, wander through the surrounding woods, or sit in the hot tub and look at the stars. A perfect weekend needs a perfect host, and that's John. I unfortunately didn't get to meet him, but he was extremely helpful and responsive to messages - even recommending a few activities. I would book with him again in a heartbeat.

The Walden Pond experience was AMAZING and perfect for my get away. Having a very busy life I like to escape to where there are not many or basically no others to interact with and this was a great find. For two days all that there was to do at the pond was enjoy nature. Everything was as described, but much better. One would have to experience it to totally understand how amazing this stay was. Fortunately, for me there wasn't anyone at the upper cabin. So it was just the pond, the amazing little water fall, the cabin and my book. Next stay I will most likely book both of them to have the same experience. There are also a ton of critters in the area that make wonderful noises all day and all night. Highly recommend this to everyone who has a choice between Walden Pond and any others in this area. You will be happy you did.

This place was so peaceful and comfortable Perfect for disconnecting and finding solace in solitude. Great attention to detail: everything had a place and there was nothing missing or superfluous. Highly recommend paddling out to the middle of the pond during sunset; it was such a beautiful vantage point to see the deep reds and oranges of the skyline and to enjoy the symphony of birdsong! John was very communicative and helpful in setting up my stay!

Thank you John for receiving us, the place is tremendous, even though the other cabin was a bit closer than imagined and the hot tub was shared, this was a great experience.

Loved staying here! The cabin is cozy and comfortable and just as described. During our stay there was lots of rain and gloom but we were very warm and comfortable. There are beautiful trails and a pond just steps away. John was very helpful and, even in the bad weather, made sure that we were stocked with everything we needed and that the long driveway was clear and salted. A wonderful place to come and get away from it all. We hope to come here again in all kinds of different weather!

The listing was great and well equipped. It would have been nice to easily access the wifi and not have to go out of our way to ask about that and the hot water or anything else.

This house is just beautiful. Modern. Clean. Spacious. Clearly, the hosts have very good taste in design and furnishing which makes it all the more inviting. Gail stocked it to the brim with everything you need to enjoy it. All amenities from internet to towels were perfect. Gail was also super responsive and extremely helpful with everything. All directions for where to find things etc. were very clear. Only thing I'd say that might be helpful to understand is that when the description says there is a bit of a steep walk and ramp down to the lake this is indeed accurate. It's a really pretty lake, but as the description states, this may not be ideal for older people, kids or perhaps just people a little nervous with this sort of thing (i.e. you can't just walk from shore right into the lake - you have to walk down steep stairs and then a steeper ramp into the water which some members of my family were nervous to do). So it really is as described. The rest of the backyard is great, with gazebos, and terraces and plenty of places to relax. So whether you stay in or go outside it's welcoming, quiet, peaceful and pretty. A very lovely find. All in all, my entire family thoroughly enjoyed it and I highly recommend it.

I cannot explain enough how amazing my group's stay was at P&G's Lakehouse. First off, the property was magnificent. The pictures really don't do the listing justice. The house was spacious and very accommodating from its well stocked kitchen (supplies and even cooking materials) to its fun filled backyard (fire pit, gazebo, and lake access). The host Gail was very accommodating and was there every step of the way if we had any questions. The bedrooms were the perfect size and the bathrooms were clean and well stocked with towels. Overall the house was great and exactly as we pictured. Would highly recommend. Thank you Gail!

The unit was exactly as described. The lake access was great and the property beautiful. We had a great time, but I think our dog had the most fun, definitely a great getaway. The variety of a gas grill, charcoal grill, indoor cooking, and fire pit make the culinary options unlimited. I strongly recommend the property for couples or groups.

The Lakehouse provided the group with the perfect getaway. The house is way more spacious than the pictures lead you to believe but the descriptions are still very accurate. We never had any issues during our stay and Gail was very communicative the whole time. Lastly, I'd highly recommend that all guests take advantage of the Lakehouse's outdoor space; especially if you have dogs.