Skip to content

Top recommendations from locals

From sightseeing to hidden gems, find out what makes the city unique with the help of the locals who know it best.
Scandinavian Restaurant
$$
“This restaurant also has rosemaling by Sigmund Aarseth and was also imported from Telemark Norway. The original owner, Al, was good friends with the original owner of Binkhaven. They also have goats on their grass roof, a tourist favorite.”
  • 18 locals recommend
Sports Bar
$
“Good food. They have an outdoor beer garden and live music many nights throughout the summer. ”
  • 14 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Our favorite place for wood fired pizza in the County. Don't let the name fool you though because their salads and sandwiches are awesome! Be sure to ask about their Donation Creation pizza----$1 from every one sold is donated to the designated non profit organization for the month! ”
  • 10 locals recommend
American Restaurant
$
“A hidden oasis with beautiful sunsets, drinks, chill vibe, American food with gluten-free options available.”
  • 11 locals recommend
Travel Agency
  • 1 local recommends
Bar
$$
“Referred to by locals as "the Bowl". Very popular fish fry Friday's and also a great place to go on a rainy day for a few games of bowling. ”
  • 6 locals recommend
Café
$
“Great sandwiches. Small menu, affordable and extremely delicious. Order at the counter and it will be delivered to your table. Very casual. AMAZING chocolate chip cookies! Gelato (made with goat milk), wonderful cheeses and spreads.”
  • 8 locals recommend
Steakhouse
$$$
“You have to dine inside the Globe! Winter hours- 5 P.M. Thursday- Saturday ”
  • 6 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Grasse’s serves a great breakfast with super service. Once a gas station, then a dairy and now a restaurant honoring the family’s long history in Door County, it’s not to be missed. Lines can get long so plan your breakfast hunger accordingly.”
  • 5 locals recommend
Beer Garden
$$
“Tiny place with great beer selection and food. Try their Ramen Bowls, different each week! Fills up quickly, try during 'off' hours”
  • 5 locals recommend
Park
“Great for families. There is a nice playground and family-friendly beach just a short walk from the chalet!”
  • 3 locals recommend
Golf Course
  • 1 local recommends
Seafood Restaurant
$$$
“This is a great restaurant especially for fish. It is run by the same people that own Pasta Vino and Chop.”
  • 4 locals recommend
Home Goods Store
$$
  • 1 local recommends
American Restaurant
$$
“Awesome food with an amazing view. The outdoor seating on the top deck provides the best view. The "garage doors" open up to provide a wonderful lake breeze for diners seated on the main level. ”
  • 4 locals recommend
Boutique
“fun, unique boutique that you will only find in Door County, with both women's clothes and home decor.”
  • 4 locals recommend

Top restaurants

Scandinavian Restaurant
“This restaurant also has rosemaling by Sigmund Aarseth and was also imported from Telemark Norway. The original owner, Al, was good friends with the original owner of Binkhaven. They also have goats on their grass roof, a tourist favorite.”
  • 18 locals recommend
Sports Bar
“Good food. They have an outdoor beer garden and live music many nights throughout the summer. ”
  • 14 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Our favorite place for wood fired pizza in the County. Don't let the name fool you though because their salads and sandwiches are awesome! Be sure to ask about their Donation Creation pizza----$1 from every one sold is donated to the designated non profit organization for the month! ”
  • 10 locals recommend
American Restaurant
“A hidden oasis with beautiful sunsets, drinks, chill vibe, American food with gluten-free options available.”
  • 11 locals recommend
Bar
“Referred to by locals as "the Bowl". Very popular fish fry Friday's and also a great place to go on a rainy day for a few games of bowling. ”
  • 6 locals recommend
Café
“Great sandwiches. Small menu, affordable and extremely delicious. Order at the counter and it will be delivered to your table. Very casual. AMAZING chocolate chip cookies! Gelato (made with goat milk), wonderful cheeses and spreads.”
  • 8 locals recommend
Steakhouse
“You have to dine inside the Globe! Winter hours- 5 P.M. Thursday- Saturday ”
  • 6 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Grasse’s serves a great breakfast with super service. Once a gas station, then a dairy and now a restaurant honoring the family’s long history in Door County, it’s not to be missed. Lines can get long so plan your breakfast hunger accordingly.”
  • 5 locals recommend

Get to know Sister Bay

Explore more on Airbnb

Experiences in Sister Bay