Skip to content

Top restaurant recommendations from locals

American Restaurant
258 East Montauk Highwaycowfishrestaurant.com
  • 82 locals recommend
Pizza Place
157 Wooster Streetwww.pepespizzeria.com
  • 59 locals recommend
Pizza Place
254 Crown Streetwww.barnightclub.com
  • 49 locals recommend
Caribbean Restaurant
43 Canoe Place Roadwww.rumbahamptonbays.com
  • 61 locals recommend
Italian Restaurant
  • 51 locals recommend
American Restaurant
99 North Main Streetwww.easthamptongrill.com
  • 56 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
  • 37 locals recommend
Hotel
183 Edgemere Streetwww.thesurflodge.com
  • 27 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
  • 48 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
  • 35 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
  • 39 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
1980 Montauk Highwaywww.lobsterroll.com
  • 38 locals recommend
Beach Bar
4 Old West Lake Drivewww.crowsnestmtk.com
  • 31 locals recommend
American Restaurant
1615 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpikewww.estiaslittlekitchen.com
  • 40 locals recommend
Restaurant
  • 36 locals recommend
Italian Restaurant
29 Newtown Lanewww.cittanuova.com
  • 33 locals recommend