Guidebook for Shelter Island

Thomas
Guidebook for Shelter Island

Food Scene

Great pastries, prepared food, fresh meat and seafood
41 locals recommend
Marie Eiffel Market
184 N Ferry Rd
41 locals recommend
Great pastries, prepared food, fresh meat and seafood
Best muffins on the island
22 locals recommend
Stars Cafe
17 Grand Ave
22 locals recommend
Best muffins on the island
Best dinner venue on the island
61 locals recommend
Vine Street Café
41 S Ferry Rd
61 locals recommend
Best dinner venue on the island

Drinks & Nightlife

Probably the only real "scene" in Shelter Island. Some love it, some don't. The restaurant is quite good and the drinks and atmosphere are great.
93 locals recommend
Sunset Beach
Shore Rd
93 locals recommend
Probably the only real "scene" in Shelter Island. Some love it, some don't. The restaurant is quite good and the drinks and atmosphere are great.

Parks & Nature

great hiking trails and beautiful scenery
70 locals recommend
Mashomack Preserve
79 S Ferry Rd
70 locals recommend
great hiking trails and beautiful scenery

Shopping

Great fishmonger
22 locals recommend
Commander Cody's Seafood
41 Smith St
22 locals recommend
Great fishmonger
The island's main supermarket
28 locals recommend
IGA Shelter Island
75 N Ferry Rd
28 locals recommend
The island's main supermarket