Vacation rentals in Sherwood

Beautiful is an understatement. The home itself is breathtaking but the view is priceless. The water is genuinely as clear as it is pictures. You can easily see fish swimming around. The home is immaculately clean with everything you could need during your stay. The host communicate extremely quickly. We truly have no complaints. We will return! We had no idea how close we were to the third largest Amish and Mennonite community in the United States. We loved everything that came with the community from snacks to education. Stop by the meat and cheese shop, Menno Hoff, the Blue Gate bakery, Five Lakes coffee, and Gramby’s is worth the drive. If you needed a reason to book this location, let this be your reason. You won’t regret it! ☺️

Sharon Ann was very responsive. The house was super clean and welcoming. There were many small things that helped make the experience more pleasant. For instance, Q tips in the bathroom, wide variety of basic kitchen items such as baking soda, measuring cups and spoons etc. so much attention to detail. We are very thankful the family allowed us to visit their lovely home.

We very much enjoyed our stay. Easy access to water. We set out to have a relaxing weekend. This home offered plenty of areas to relax. Cottonwood Cottage was very warm and inviting and we hope to make it back.

The house was super cute and had everything we needed for a girls weekend. Big table for games, HUGE couch to lounge on and watch movies. We made the very quick trip to Olers for supper on night 1 and didn't have to leave the house the rest of the wknd. We all were happy and said we would stay again.

Family Traditions is way more beautiful than the pictures!!! Don was so responsive and accomodating. We had an absolute fabulous stay at this getaway! We highly recommend this spot for a friend/family/couple's getaway! You can't ask for anything better ~ it was clean, well stocked, plenty of room for all, perfect location, we can't wait to go back!!! Thank you, Don!!!

Daniel was extremely quick to reply whenever we messaged him. Had some issues with electricity and he sent an electrician right away. Fantastic host! The sunrise over the lake was the highlight of every morning for me. There’s few things better in life than a cup of coffee and a sunrise over a lake. 10/10!!!

This was our third year staying at Chris’s cottage. The cottage was spotless as always, equipped with snacks, water, plenty of towels and amenities. The cottage is on Fish Lake, beautiful and peaceful but also fun to watch all of the water activities and wildlife. The weather was perfect. The mark of a fantastic place and location is never having to turn on the TV to pass the time. We will be back next year if it’s available! Thank you, Chris!

A short getaway for us and the cottage was the perfect setting! Everything was immaculate and had all the amenities of home! Town was near by for restaurants or any needs and right near the lake. Lots of exploring nearby or within an hour or two drive. We’d stay there again! Thanks, James!

Great place to stay for our trip down to Colon to attend a dinner at Farrand Hall. Loved looking out at the lake- even spotted a bald eagle!