Restaurant

CASE'S PLACE

8 locals recommend,
Permanently closed

Tips from locals

Joanna
July 25, 2017
Stunning waterfront setting, fabulous daily specials, great service, excellent local wines. Our new favorite place ....shhhhhhh
Leah
November 8, 2019
Cozy, nautical spot. Large outdoor space with porch seating right on the bay.
Doug
June 22, 2017
Enjoy lunch or dinner overlooking the beautiful bay. Within walking distance.
Laurie
October 10, 2021
great afternoon spot, soaking up sun on back porch. Family Fun❤️

Unique things to do nearby

Shelter Island Private Electric Bike Tour
  1. Cycling tour
  2. 3.5 hours
Location
650 1st St
New Suffolk, NY
North Fork