Skip to content
Bar

Old Mill Inn

4 locals recommend ·

Tips from locals

Mary
Mary
May 27, 2016
On the water (Mattituck inlet) and is a great spot with live music venues, fresh seafood and a great happy hour with $3.00 drinks M-Friday.
Jen
Jen
August 22, 2015
The best spot on the water - fantastic water view and good food. Sit outside and watch the birds and hear the water. Fun bar that stays open late and live music on the weekends.
Deborah
Deborah
July 22, 2015
On the water dining. Also very old bar area. Great new management. Tons of history. Make sure to ask! Pretty ride to the north side of the fork also.
Jesse
Jesse
May 17, 2013
Check out Albert Einstein's favorite bar, it was his dive when he was living on Long Island. Go sit at the rounded bar for happy hour; enjoy local drink & fresh local oysters by a roaring fireplace.
Location
5775 West Mill Road
Mattituck, New York 11952
Phone+1 631-298-8080