Vacation rentals in Bimini Bay

Sand & Sea Oasis: Condo with Private Beach Access

Escape to your very own piece of paradise at this charming 2BR/2BA condo, located just steps from the beautiful Gulf of Mexico on Holmes Beach. Perfect for families or small groups, this condo comfortably sleeps 5-6 guests and offers everything you need for a relaxing getaway. Whether you’re lounging by the pool, playing tennis, or strolling along the shore, this condo offers the perfect blend of comfort and convenience. Book your stay today and make memories in your very own beachside paradise!

Ground-Level AMI Gem: 3 Blocks to Beach & Shops!

Welcome to a vibrant island getaway- Beaching it on AMI! This newly renovated home on AMI is bursting with bright colors and modern flair. Walk to a boat launch, dock, playground, tennis and basketball courts, a perfect spot for fun in the sun. With a fully equipped kitchen and all beach essentials included, plus front and back patios for lounging, get ready for a cozy retreat filled with endless relaxation and adventure! Centrally located to restaurants and shops. Only 3 blocks to AMI beaches!

Be an AMI

This stylish and light home offers single-level private accommodations. The recently updated interior and private backyard oasis with plunge pool offers the perfect space for a truly relaxing and enjoyable vacation. Inside, the stylish and comfy space has room for everyone to spread out and relax while enjoying the two flat screen TVs. No expense was spared in designing and furnishing this home. The sleeper sofa pulls out to a memory foam queen bed, meaning the cottage can comfortably sleep 4.

New! Heated pool/Spa~Water Slide and Grotto! Views

Welcome to Harbor Haven, a stunning vacation rental nestled in the heart of Anna Maria Island. This 4-bedroom, 7-bathroom oasis is just a 5-minute stroll from the pristine Gulf beaches. Immerse yourself in the ultimate relaxation with our gorgeous freeform pool, complete with a hot tub, waterfall, water slide, and grotto for endless fun and tranquility. Whether you're lounging in the sun or enjoying a family barbecue, Harbor Haven offers the perfect backdrop for unforgettable memories.

Starfish cottage w/heated pool in PRIME location

Welcome to an old Florida 'The Starfish Cottage" . Enjoy the private heated pool with lush tropical setting. Inside you'll find an open concept living space where dining area, kitchen and living room have been newly furnished with luxurious deep seat couches and lounge chairs, hardwood floors add to the charm. Fresh linens, bath and beach towels are provided along with basic toiletries. Decor has been collected over time and obtained from local artists for a unique old Florida style.

Salty Harbor AMI pool retreat near the Beach

Charming Salty Harbor sits in a quaint, exclusive corner of AMI and boasts a private heated pool and ample parking for 2 vehicles and even a boat: -Ask us if your dates don't fit our calendar! -If you don't have a single 50Lb pet, please discuss it with us -One of the twin boutique MyAnnaMariaStay homes, look us up! You'll love the luxury mid-century feel, lush yard, and a 6-min walk to the beach, Publix or the trolley stop. AMI was voted a top 50 vacation spot in the world in 2024

The Peachy Beach House, steps to the gulf

The perfect place for a combination family vacation and some romance-when the kids are in bed, turn on the spa and music. June, July and August, Saturday to Saturday only. If custom trip length is wanted- ask Two bedroom, 2 full bathroom, new heated private pool/spa Steps to semi-private gulf beach, on quiet street in N. HB Well-stocked kitchen, 2 TVs, large primary suite and amazing gulf views from bedrooms. Crib, high chair, beach chairs, wagon, umbrella, beach toys and towels

Newly Remodeled Beachfront Studio - On the sand!

ONE SHELL COVE on Anna Maria Island has been totally remodeled after Hurricanes Helene and Milton. Wonderful studio floor plan with amazing kitchen. Beautiful view of the waves and the beach right outside your window. Grab your towel, take a few steps and you're on the beach. The sand comes right up to your door in this ground floor unit. Amazing Location Walk to some restaurants Free Trolley goes up and down the Island Rent Kayaks and Paddleboards and enjoy the Beach

83rd St Villas East by Duncan Real Estate

Welcome to The 83rd St Villas East! A stunning ground-level vacation villa just a 6-minute walk from the beach! With two bedrooms and two bathrooms, this rental sleeps up to six guests. You and your guests can sit back, relax, watch movies, and connect over effortless conversations in the living area. Top of the range, fully equipped kitchen with Caf appliances, ample counter space, cook top and oven, extra-large fridge/freezer making meal prep a breeze.

2-Nights Available 6/18 - Private 30' Dock & Pool

* It doesn't get much better than being right on the water, located on a wide canal, and ½ block from the beach. * Enjoy the large 16' x 30' private pool in a picturesque tropical landscape along with a 30' fishing/boat dock. * Within walking distance of Pine Avenue, City Pier, Two Scoops, Waterfront Restaurant, Galati's Marina, and Island Ocean Star Restaurant. *Less than a 3 minute walk to Bay Beach and a 15 minute walk to Bean Point.

L'Oasis West w/Dip Pool

Completely remodeled, this beautifully 2-bedroom duplex, crafted to enhance your living experience. Every detail has been thoughtfully designed to create a serene and inviting atmosphere. New images showcase this stunning transformation, come visit us to see the beauty in person! Additionally, West and East are now available for rent together, featuring convenient adjoining doors through the utility room.

The Boathouse

Would you like to feel like you are sleeping in a tree house with all the luxuries and comfort of a high end hotel? Then welcome to our brand new guest house, which accommodates a maximum of two guests and is a completely private tropical oasis. Standing on the edge of Lake LaVista, surrounded by tropical palms where you have use of the private and beautiful pool which we heat during the winter months.