Vacation rentals in Butterfield Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Butterfield Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favourite
Cottage in Hammond

River Ledge Hideaway | Waterfront | Views

New construction home designed specifically with the thought of guests in mind overlooking the Saint Lawrence River. Enjoy a memorable fall or holiday getaway to this waterfront oasis. Highlighting this home is a large master bedroom overlooking numerous islands speckled throughout the expansive water view. Outdoor fire pit and grilling area will be set up for the fall season. Walk down our path to your own private waterfront. Great place for couples, small families or friends getting together

LocationValueBeach

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 230 reviews
Top guest favourite
The exterior entrance features a set of steps leading to a white front door, flanked by large windows for natural light. The surrounding area displays a small garden with greenery and flowers, contributing to a welcoming approach.
Apartment in Redwood

A Simple Roof

THIS IS NOT A VACATION HOME. Self-check-in/check-out. Old-fashioned, rustic apartment, painted wood floors, full kitchen, mud room, screened porch; boat/ATV parking; tent space. Ready for year-round outdoor sports, fishing, boating, biking, family camping trips. Near 1000 Islands, several lakes/waterways, 5 room apartment is one side of host duplex, 3 private entrances. King bed, 1 twin upstairs, 2 folding cots, comfy couch for sleep. Bathroom downstairs. WIFI; FireTV, HDMI cord; TVs w/DVD.

ValueLocationAmenities

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 197 reviews
Top guest favourite
A modest house features a red metal roof and brown siding, with white trim around the windows and door. A front porch is visible, providing an entrance. An American flag stands near the house, surrounded by a landscaped green yard and a stone fire pit in the foreground.
Guesthouse in Redwood

Fisherman's Getaway

Attention Fisherman or anyone looking for a getaway. Book this tranquil little house for the perfect fishing trip. We are right in the middle of fishing paradise. Ten minutes from two Rivers, Indian River and the St Lawrence. Twenty minutes from Black Lake and just minutes from several local Lakes. Butterfield, Clear, Lake of the Woods, Millsite are just a few. We have U shaped driveway easy in and out for your boat. Ten minutes from Alexandria Bay and Twenty five minutes from Watertown.

FamilyLocationHeating

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews
Top guest favourite
Home in Gananoque

NEW - Waterfront Island Retreat | Sauna | Firepit

You love getting away to a cottage by the water, but you also appreciate elegant interiors that feel like a high-end spa. Why choose when you can have it all in the same place? Come stay in this 3000 sq ft, newly built bungalow on Howe Island, where tranquility, contemporary elegance and the natural beauty of the Thousand Islands come together to create one extraordinary getaway. Use this home as your HQ as you explore the Thousand Islands or stay in for a luxurious, rejuvenating retreat.

FamilyLocationGrill

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews
Guest favourite
Home in Clayton

Hidden Gem! 1/2 of Duplex in the Heart of Downtown

Charming 3 BR, 2.5B duplex located just steps from the St. Lawrence River & Riverside Drive with guests vacation needs in mind! Pet friendly, two floor duplex home. Perfect for couples, families, or a small group. Guests will be staying in the front left hand side of home (230). - The duplex is separated down the center by a concrete wall and has separate back door entrance with private back porch. Front door entrance shares an entry way with 228 unit (hosts residence when in the area).

ValueLocationComfort

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 202 reviews
Guest favourite
The exterior of the home features a welcoming porch with large windows. Flowering plants, including yellow lilies and red blooms, line the garden bed, adding color to the landscape. A pathway leads to the door, framed by greenery and a blue railing.
Home in Clayton

Thousand Island Clayton Home Pet Friendly & Quiet

This home is located in Clayton, NY in The Thousand Islands. It resides on 11 acres bordering The French Creek situated on The St. Lawrence River. One mile to historic downtown Clayton. Spacious back deck. This is a pet friendly home. New fenced in back yard. All new flooring. New paved driveway. New larger firepit. It is not directly on the River but it is about 1/4 away as the crow flies. It is very close to downtown. About a 5-minute drive or a nice, 20-minute walk. Level 2 EV charger.

FamilyValueDecor

4.73 out of 5 average rating, 295 reviews
Top guest favourite
Three blue Adirondack chairs are positioned on a grassy area by a calm river. Lush green trees surround the water's edge, creating a serene setting. A soft pink and purple sky hints at sunset, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere of the outdoor space.
Cabin in Redwood

Rossie Rest

Relax with the family at this peaceful cabin on the Indian River with great fishing and a private setting. Walk out the front door and start fishing or enjoy the view with your morning coffee. It is in the perfect location to view the Eclipse on April 8. This cabin is kid and pet friendly. It has electricity, running water, a small kitchenette, fire pit and wood. It is located 45 minutes from Watertown, 20 minutes to exit 49 on Route 81, and close to the Thousand Islands and Black Lake.

LocationValueAccuracy

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews
Top guest favourite
The exterior of the home showcases a two-story structure with a light-colored siding and prominent windows. A large front deck features white railings, surrounded by a spacious lawn and mature trees, offering a serene atmosphere. Clear blue skies provide a bright backdrop.
Home in Alexandria Bay

Swan’s Nest

Swan’s Nest is nestled between the American narrows portion of the main channel of the St. Lawrence River and peaceful Swan Bay. This 4 bedroom/3 full bathroom home features a gorgeous floor-to-ceiling river stone gas fireplace as the focal point of the main floor, as well as a fully stocked kitchen and king master suite. Downstairs is a cozy sun room with a fireplace, and an Irish pub style bar room. To the rear, double decks overlook the wide lawn and waterfront access to Swan Bay.

FamilyValueOutdoor spaces

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews
Guest favourite
Home in Redwood

Sixberry Bay

15 minutes from Alex Bay! Beautiful Lakefront tucked away on Sixberry Lake. Peaceful, gorgeous, beachfront property perfect for swimming, fishing/ice fishing, and kayaking. One of the only shallow beach areas on the lake. Enjoy coffee in the morning with the loons on the large deck overlooking the lake and joyous evenings at the nearby firepit. A spacious great room, Central AC, Samsung TV, Wifi, 3 season room.....provide fun for the family throughout the entire day and all seasons.

FamilyLocationAmenities

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews
Top guest favourite
A well-maintained gravel driveway is flanked by evenly spaced trees, creating a natural canopy. Lush green grass lines both sides of the path, leading toward an open horizon. Soft clouds drift in the sky, adding to the peaceful countryside ambiance.
Home in Antwerp

Maple Lane Home

A four-bedroom farmhouse nestled in a serene country setting offers the perfect escape to reconnect with nature. You might catch sight of a flock of geese gracefully coming and going from the pond, or spot a heron quietly fishing in the creek. This home provides a tranquil retreat from the hustle and bustle of everyday living. Whether you’re dreaming of enjoying sunsets on the porch, or simply savoring the quiet, this peaceful farm could be your ideal sanctuary.

FamilyLocationCheck-in

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews
Top guest favourite
A charming cottage exterior is framed by lush greenery. A metal roof and blue wooden siding complement the three front windows and central door, while orange daylilies add a pop of color to the surrounding garden. The front porch features steps leading to the entrance.
Cottage in Leeds and the Thousand Islands

Lyncreek Cottage

Lyncreek Cottage is open year round. it sits on private property on Lyndhurst river in Lyndhurst, Ontario. Observe various types of waterfowl or enjoy the sound of our meandering river as it flows into Lyndhurst Lake. This is all part of the natural surroundings in your own private cottage. A great place to stay if you are travelling through the area or while enjoying all the area has to offer including excellent fishing, paddling and hiking area trails.

LocationFamilyLaundry

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 445 reviews
Top guest favourite
The exterior of a modern single-story home is showcased, featuring a mix of dark siding and a stone accent. A welcoming porch with wooden beams is surrounded by landscaped flower beds, while lush greenery from the surrounding forest enhances the serene atmosphere.
Home in Leeds and the Thousand Islands

Thousand Island Oasis: Spa, Sauna, HT | Sleeps 10

The Thousand Islands Oasis is a tranquil retreat nestled on 1.16 acres of partially forested land, offering complete privacy in a serene natural setting. Surrounded by lush greenery, this hidden gem provides a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. The oasis is an ideal place to unwind and reconnect with nature, featuring peaceful seclusion and the soothing sounds of the surrounding forest.

FamilyLocationHeating

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Popular amenities for Butterfield Lake vacation rentals