Vacation rentals in Caldwell

Great condo for a family of five. Plenty of space and everything was clean and inviting. our kids especially loved the loft stocked with games and toys.

Absolutely loved our stay at Mordechai’s place! The home was stunning—beautifully designed, spacious, and super comfortable for our large group. It’s also in a perfect location, close to amazing hiking spots and scenic views. Mordecai was a fantastic host—quick to respond and very helpful throughout our stay. I truly can’t wait for the opportunity to return!

We had a great time! The unit is an easy walk to Minerals, and the layout was perfect for our needs. Joann was a fantastic host and we can’t wait to stay again!

We booked the space for a dance competition at Minerals Hotel. The condo was bright and airy and the perfect amount of space for two mother/ daughter pairs. Everything was extremely clean and nicely decorated - and we enjoyed the basket of snacks and water during the late night returns! We will be booking again!

We had a great time at Carmine's place, highly recommend.

I brought some of my college city friends that are a part of my business honors society to my hometown -Warwick. This cabin fit us all perfectly and was the perfect place to relax and unwind, while getting to know each other. We had a blast staying at this house, it was cozy and felt like we were right at home. The amenities were great as well! Clinton was also very reliable. Whenever we needed help finding something, he would answer relatively quickly. 10/10 would stay again.

A wonderful place to stay with family. Clean and spacious, lots of amenities and extras with the place. Felt right at home, miles better than a hotel. Would recommend if you're looking for a comfortable and wonderful stay.

I can’t say enough great things about my stay—it exceeded all expectations. The space was immaculately clean, with fresh linens, spotless surfaces, and a lovely scent throughout. It felt like stepping into a boutique hotel. The host was incredibly kind, responsive, and thoughtful—offering local tips and checking in to ensure I had everything I needed. Their hospitality truly set this experience apart. The location was another highlight: a peaceful, safe neighborhood that felt like a calm retreat, yet only minutes from JFK Airport—super convenient for travel. I’ve stayed in this area before, and this is by far the best listing in terms of quality, comfort, and value. If you’re looking for a cozy, pristine, and well-located stay with a top-notch host, don’t hesitate—book it! I’ll absolutely return next time I’m in town.