Vacation rentals in Cayuta Lake

Camp S’mores- Modern A-Frame with Pool

Welcome to Camp S’mores- this revitalized luxury A-frame has all the modern amenities you need for your Finger Lakes adventure. We just brought new life into this house from top to bottom. The home features three bedrooms and a Murphy bed in the game room on the lower level. EV charger. It wouldn't be camp without a pool so our home has a large HEATED in-ground pool is open May 15th - Oct 1st. The house is located outside of town on 2+ private acres. Dog friendly, sorry no cats or other pets

Waterfront Home with Sauna on Seneca Lake FLX

Unwind at Red Oak Retreat, a private waterfront home located in the heart of Finger Lakes wine country! This Seneca Lake escape features an expansive deck with magnificent sunset lake views, 100ft of lakeside lawn with a fire pit and kayaks. The property also boasts a two-story seasonal lakeside boathouse with bedroom and game area. Enjoy more than 15 vineyards within a 5 minute drive, with Watkins Glen State Park, "The Glen" Race Track, and Finger Lakes National Forest are only 15 minutes away.

Hilltop hideway for nature lovers w/3 waterfalls.

4 BR 3 BATH home. Relax, restore, rejuvenate or unwind at 1 of a kind retreat in the heart of the Finger Lakes! Perfectly situated on 20 acres, landscaped, surrounded by woods & waterfalls. Enjoy a glass of wine/drink & dine on the large patio while taking in the view of the surrounding vistas. May also view from inside from picture window in living and dining rms. Many types of wildlife visit! NO PETS ALLOWED. No late ck/outs unless arranged with host. Violations will incur fee of $75/ hr.

Naturalists' Retreat

Retreat to paradise at this cozy cottage in the heart of the Finger Lakes. Charming custom woodwork offers a unique, rustic aesthetic while modern amenities provide the comfort of home. Minutes from famous naturalist attractions in all directions. Enjoy the entire peaceful cottage and surrounding yard with outdoor seating, fire pit, and hot tub to yourself. Three acres of adjoining trails and creek shared with neighboring host family, who are fun-loving and approachable but respect your privacy.

Finger Lakes Dropstar on Cayuta LAKEFRONT

Dropstar is a modern spacious 3300 square foot retreat in a peaceful setting on Cayuta Lake in the breathtaking NY Finger Lakes region. Immerse yourself in nature and see the best views of the entire lake through the enormous windows, sunbathing on private decks, fireside on the patio or fishing and swimming on the dock at Dropstar. Grill or cook for a crowd in the fully stocked gourmet kitchen, rest privately in 4 large appointed bedrooms and never wait with 3 full baths. LIVE, LOVE, LAKE!

Beautiful Lakefront Property

Welcome to your lakeside getaway, perfectly situated on Cayuta Lake—known by locals as “Little Lake.” This beautiful home offers the perfect blend of relaxation and recreation, with a private dock where you can fish, kayak, or simply unwind on the water with a float.The home features 3 spacious bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, along with two comfortable pull-out sofa beds to accommodate additional guests. There is ample room throughout the home for air mattresses if needed it’s ideal for families.

Lake Spirit-Lakefront-Hot tub-Pet friendly-Boats

Lake Spirit welcomes you & your pets year-round! This lakeside home provides a retreat-like experience, offering activities for every season. You can fish, ice fish, relax in the hot tub, enjoy the two decks and docks, the boats or explore the Finger Lakes region. Amenities include a Hot tub, BBQ, fireplace, fire pit, books, games, kayaks, canoe, and pedal boat. While off the beaten path, the property is conveniently located near renowned gorges, waterfalls, vineyards, and distilleries.

1875 Renovated Schoolhouse with an Igloo!

Explore the Finger Lakes and make this renovated schoolhouse with an outdoor igloo as your basecamp. Nestled in the countryside, you'll find absolutely stunning views with surroundings that are peaceful and quiet. A perfect escape for couples and friends that is dog-friendly too, you're within minutes of the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, the gorgeous Watkins Glen State Park, and the renowned WG International Racetrack. Want to simply relax at the FLX Schoolhouse? It's the perfect for that too!

4BR w/ Game room & just min. from WGI & Wine Trail

The whole group will enjoy easy access to everything from this centrally located place. Equipped w 4 large bedrooms, 2 Living rooms & a very unique game room. You will have plenty of space stretch your legs. The 4-acre grounds make for peace & privacy. Head outside on the large deck to enjoy the fresh air and do some grilling. This beautifully decorated home comes equipped with plenty of amenities. If you have a larger group, book our sister property next door too, Gracie's House.

Modern Forest Retreat Close to Ithaca/Watkins Glen

Are you looking to escape into the country where you can truly unwind and relax? Our newly designed home is completely updated with a modern kitchen, spacious entertaining areas, a master suite, and situated in the woods with no neighbors in sight! Enjoy wandering 15 acres of your own private forest and being in the heart of the beautiful Finger Lakes region with Watkins Glen (9 miles away), Ithaca (15 miles away), gorges galore, and several nearby breweries, wineries and restaurants.

Magical lakefront treehouse, minutes to downtown

A magical treehouse perched over its own gorge on Cayuga Lake. This place is special! There’s a giant porch wrapped around a 300-year oak tree and a lakeside tea house that can serve as an extra bedroom. There’s a dock, fire pit, room for yard games by the water, plenty of outdoor seating on the porch, by the lake, or on the dock. All of this is minutes from downtown Ithaca, Cornell, and Taughannock Falls state park. It’s also a great base to explore the Finger Lakes wine region.

Rustic 5-bedroom log cabin cottage with hot tub

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway on Little Lake in Alpine, NY. This quiet cottage sits on the oh so peaceful Little Lake. The log cabin cottage takes you away from the hustle and bustle of every day. There are five buildings on this property (main house - sleeps six, boat house - sleeps 2, private room, sleeps four). The fourth building is an out building for trash and recycables and the fifth building is a garage - private to the owners.