Vacation rentals in Eagle Bay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Eagle Bay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favourite
An aerial view showcases a serene landscape where a winding waterway meanders through lush greenery. Several vehicles are parked nearby, and a dock can be seen extending into the water, surrounded by trees. The calm lake reflects the surrounding forest.
Cabin in Eagle Bay
4.81 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Eagle creek house 4th lake access and view

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. You'll love the beautiful views of 4th lake and eagle creek. This four bedroom home boasts Adirondack style and charm. Open concept kitchen dining room. With views of the water from nearly every room. Enjoy sitting on the boardwalk style dock along the water's edge or by the fire pit in the evening. Take a short drive to Inlet and Old Forge, or nearby hiking trails. Rent a boat worry free and tie up on the dock to keep at the house.

Top guest favourite
Home in Speculator
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 487 reviews

Ski at Gore or Oak, Sauna, & Walk to Village

The Speculator Guest House is fully renovated to offer an elevated and thoughtful stay. Guests love the outdoor sauna, Sunday to Wednesday private chef brunch or dinner, espresso maker, fully stocked kitchen, and everything you need for a campfire under the string lights. Walk to the grocery store, restaurants, shops, or the sandy beach on Lake Pleasant (.6 miles). Each guest receives individualized local recommendations. We live in the area year round and love to share our favorite places.

Top guest favourite
An indoor salt-water pool is illuminated with soft blue lights beneath a wood-beamed ceiling. Surrounding the pool are lounge chairs and a small table, with large windows that provide views of the outdoors. The space features a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Cabin in Old Forge
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Luxury Cabin with Indoor HEATED Salt Water Pool

Welcome to Deer Meadows -The Most Unique Luxury Cabin in Old Forge! This property has serious WOW factor as soon as you pull down the private drive, and the WOW's get bigger & better as you open the door to this Adirondack paradise! This newly renovated property is the perfect blend of privacy, modern finishes, & total luxury. Deer Meadows offers a heated, INDOOR salt-water pool inside a massive pool room with 20' cathedral ceilings, BOTH POOL & ROOM ARE 78°, and 24 color changing LED's...

Guest favourite
A charming cabin exterior is shown with a green roof and soft grey siding. Adirondack chairs are arranged around a picnic table on the grassy area, surrounded by lush green landscaping. A large window allows natural light into the inviting indoor space.
Cabin in Eagle Bay
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

Beautiful 3 Bedroom Cabin w/ Private Beach Access.

Welcome to Camp ZZ. Just 2 miles from Inlet & 8 miles from Old Forge sitting lakeside off Rt28 w/ access to 2 private beaches. One is even dog friendly! Sleeps 10 comfortably w/ 3 bedrooms and 1 sleeping loft. The upstairs master offers a private screened-in porch w/ relaxing Adirondack Chairs. Hello, perfect 1st cup of coffee spot. You will find a great selection of lawn games & even a large screen/projector for family movie nights. We hope to host you and yours! (BYO sheets & towels)

Guest favourite
A charming cottage features a rustic exterior with red accents and large windows, set against a winter landscape. Snow blankets the ground and falls gently from a gray sky, while evergreen trees provide a natural backdrop. A fire pit is visible in the snowy yard.
Cottage in Inlet
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

Cozy Retreat in the ADK! Snowmobile and explore.

Charming, spacious and newly renovated one bedroom cottage in Inlet, NY. Location, location , location! Located less than 5 min drive from the village and in an ideal location for snowmobilers! The cottage sits just across from a groomed trail. In the spring, summer and fall enjoy close proximity to lakes, town, major hiking trails, restaurants and other attractions that the area has to offer. Old Forge is just a 20 min drive and Inlet village is just a leisurely walk away.

Guest favourite
A red house with a slanted roof is framed by trees with autumn foliage. Colorful adirondack chairs in white, red, blue, and yellow are arranged in a circle on the grassy area. A wooden fence adds a rustic touch, enhancing the outdoor setting.
Home in Eagle Bay
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Adirondack Red House

The Red House is a beautiful three bedroom home that offers the peace and quiet you're looking for. This cabin is nestled in the forest and situated between the hamlets of both Inlet and Old Forge. We are less than 1/2 a mile from three area restaurants. This camp has lake access rights on Big Moose Lake where you can enjoy canoeing, kayaking, water-skiing, and swimming in the warmer months. We are on a ridable road and located .3 miles to trail 5.

Guest favourite
A spacious cabin is set amidst a lush green woodland. A large wooden deck with multiple entry points is visible at the front, featuring railings and ample space for outdoor furniture. The building showcases a combination of wood siding and large windows, inviting natural light.
Cabin in Inlet
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 90 reviews

Adirondack Cabin | Grill | Fire Pit | Trail Access

Welcome to Camp Bentwood! - Four-season destination in the heart of the Adirondacks - Two full bedrooms and a sleeping loft - Two bathrooms for convenience - One-car garage for vehicles or snowmobiles - Scenic fall foliage and winter snowmobiling nearby - Public boat launch on Fourth Lake and Arrowhead Public Park in Inlet - Nearby hiking, biking trails, and horseback riding Come experience all the Adirondacks has to offer!

Top guest favourite
Cabin in Old Forge
5 out of 5 average rating, 88 reviews

Luxury Adirondack Cabin | Heated Pool & Fire Pit

Luxury Adirondack cabin with heated spa pool, seasonal 4th Lake access, and stunning mountain views. Located on Route 28 between Old Forge and Inlet, you’ll be minutes from hiking, biking, snowmobile trails, shops, and dining — including a top-rated BBQ spot steps away. Glowing knotty pine walls and ceilings plus modern comforts make the Grand Little Cabin the perfect retreat. Note: 4th Lake access available Sept–June.

Top guest favourite
The boathouse features a rustic exterior with a red roof and dark siding, nestled among trees showcasing autumn colors. The spacious deck, illuminated by warm lights, includes chairs and a table. The serene water reflects the structure and surrounding foliage.
Home in Old Forge
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 122 reviews

The Boathouse on Fourth Lake

This historic boathouse is a rare find, situated directly in the waters of the popular Fourth Lake in Old Forge. Complete unobstructed lake views from all three sides of the home provide breathtaking sights during all four seasons. Enjoy the spacious dock, the open concept living area, swim in the private sandy bottom waterfront, and bask in the all-day sun provided by the north shore.

Top guest favourite
Home in Old Forge
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 52 reviews

Four Seasons Landing

Welcome to Four Seasons, a beautiful, modern cabin in Old Forge (under 2 miles to Inlet). Located on South Shore Rd, a ridable road for snowmobiling. Pick up trail 1 at Ferns Park. Want to Ski? We are 20 minutes from McCauley Mountain. Autumn in the Adirondacks is famous for foliage and festivals. Enjoy a quiet spring get away, or when summer heats up, Water Safari is 15 minutes away.

Guest favourite
Apartment in Lowville
5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Collins Street Studio Apartment Pet Friendly

Collins street studio is just a stroll down the street to the center of town where you will find everything our small town has to offer. Favorite places to eat are just a walk away JEBS, Tony Harper’s Pizza and Clam Shack or Crumbs Bakery. The local vet clinic is 1.3 miles away with the nearest Walmart 1.5 miles away The Studio apartment is pet friendly (we love dogs)

Guest favourite
A spacious living area features a gray sectional sofa with decorative pillows, positioned on a patterned area rug. Wooden walls contribute to a cozy ambiance, while large windows allow natural light. A coffee table and various decor items are visible, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.
Cabin in Old Forge
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 60 reviews

Hillside Hideaway

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. Cozy camp with lots of sleeping. Large Parking pad. Backside is state owned mountain so it has a great scenic views. Within minutes to old forge downtown, water safari and lake but far enough away for a little peace and quiet. Has heat, and Ac. Lots of privacy and pretty views.

Popular amenities for Eagle Bay vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Herkimer County
  5. Eagle Bay