Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Eagle Harbor

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

When results are available, navigate with up and down arrow keys or explore by touch or swipe gestures.

Top-rated vacation rentals in Eagle Harbor

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Guest favourite
Apartment in Albion
Lagom Living Not too little ~ Not too Much
Our Airbnb is an entire two-bedroom apartment in an 1800s home in Albion, NY. You’ll have plenty of room to settle in and stretch out here. We can sleep five people on two double beds and a couch. The comfortable living room is stocked with board games and our full kitchen has all the appliances and kitchenware you need to make your own meals. With onsite parking, a private entrance, and washer and dryer, you can really make yourself at home.
Guest favourite
Apartment in Medina
Private Cozy Vintage 1 Bedroom Apt.
Welcome to this quaint vintage upstairs apartment as part of a large 1800's home. Cozy and comfortable with all your basic necessities. Private off street parking in the heart of the village of Medina. You are walking distance from downtown unique shops, boutiques and restaurants. It is less than an hour drive to Niagara Falls, Buffalo and Rochester and about 15 minutes from Lake Ontario (famous for fishermen).
Guest favourite
Cottage in Albion
Lake Front: Beautiful Cottage on Lake Alice
Lake front designer gem has Main House, Boat House and Bath House. Boat House is an additional fee and offered seasonally : see details below. Gourmet kitchen, rock fireplace, expansive deck, stairs to lake with dock, swim platform, fire ring, beach chairs, 4 kayaks and a canoe for your use. Just a day trip away to Niagra Falls or Toronto and 5 min to Oak Orchard River which hosts World Class Fishing.

Popular amenities for Eagle Harbor vacation rentals

Other great vacation rentals in Eagle Harbor

Guest favourite
Guesthouse in Churchville
The Carriage House
Guest favourite
Cottage in Burt
Hook, Wine & Sinker
Guest favourite
Farm stay in Kent
Loft Retreat private getaway at Stonebird Farm!
Guest favourite
Home in Burt
Waterfront Cottage with Hot tub
Guest favourite
Home in Gasport
Uncle Dom's Cottage
Guest favourite
Home in Burt
Parkside Cottage & Hot Tub, Olcott Beach, NY (USA)
Guest favourite
Cottage in Kent
Captain Dan's Lake Ontario Cottage
Guest favourite
Apartment in Albion
Bunked on Bank
Guest favourite
Apartment in Medina
The Cozy Corner
Guest favourite
Cottage in Albion
Otter Creekside Cottage
Guest favourite
Cottage in Lyndonville
Lake Ontario Nautical Twilight
Guest favourite
Home in Medina
Glenwood Lake Retreat

Destinations to explore

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Orleans County
  5. Eagle Harbor