Vacation rentals with lake access in Goodyear Lake

Guillermo’s property was exactly as advertised. Sits on a beautiful lake with picturesque surroundings and home itself is very comfortable. The place was immaculate and well supplied with amenities. Guillermo was a great host who recommended a local restaurant that turned it to be exactly what we were looking for. The home is about 20 minutes from Cooperstown and the Baseball Hall of Fame. Cooperstown is a cute community with GREAT local restaurants and shopping. We loved our lunch at Cooley’s and breakfast at Cooperstown Diner - it’s TINEY so the earlier you get there the better. Lastly, if you are a baseball fan, I can’t recommend the Hall of Fame enough! It was an amazing experience… One in which we would not hesitate to revisit.

Oquaga Lake is my happy place! Twin Oaks is a beautiful and spacious cottage. The porch and the docks are fantastic. We were able to swim and enjoy the paddleboards and kayaks. The water was warm by Oquaga Lake standards! I was very impressed with how well supplied the cottage was. From paper products to cooking utensils and appliances to bath and beach towels, there was everything we needed. It exceeded my expectations. Karen was responsive and helpful. Overall it was a wonderful stay and I highly recommend it.

The house was really well kept, designed and fitted with tons of fun activities. it sits on a gorgeous lake with incredible views! a few bugs of course as you’re so close to nature. marlaina was super responsive even when we had questions early in the morning. we loved staying here and hope we can again!

We had a nice stay with Cora, who is so kind and helpful. We had some issues with the portable AC units and the front door lock but, she took care of it very quickly. It was the perfect place to stay for move in day. Thanks, Cora!

Been there three times now for work related trips. Houses has plenty of amenities. Great for a work crew where everyone had there on space. If we had time to fish it would have been better!

It was a large and clean home - perfect for a weekend stay with family nearby

My husband and I took our two grandsons and met my girl friend with her grandsons, all 5 to 8 years of age. What a blast, from the art studio down stairs to the gorgeous setting to a very comfortable home, our time was wonderful. The boys enjoyed all the treasures of the property from watching the koi fish and geese at the pond to chasing frogs and salamanders. The entire stay was most enchanting. We are contemplating the same trip for next year. I would highly recommend this trip...it was so peaceful and easy.

We spent a week at Laura's and loved the snow and quiet. It's definitely a drive to the main nearby towns, but the countryside is lovely. We know the area well and enjoyed checking out something new. The lakeside community was empty in the winter, but it seems like it would feel busier in summer. Nice kitchen equipment, comfortable beds, hot showers, and cozy spaces to be together. Couldn't ask for more!

My wife and I stayed here last year for the first time and we came back again this year because we really liked this place. The hosts were friendly and accommodating and made us feel welcome. The place was clean and well kept and the 3 bedrooms gave us more than enough space for our needs. They even let our cat stay here which most places won't allow. We really liked the location, the park like property, and being within walking distance to the town pool and the local deli. Thank you again Mustafa and Olena for a wonderful stay!

Great place near Cooperstown for Baseball Hall of Fame visit and overnight stop. Many thoughtful touches. Very cute decor!

Bernie was a great host. He met us to greet us and check us in and show us around the place because it is a little unique. The house is wonderful and oozes with history. There are a couple things about the set up of the unit to be aware of. The kitchen is completely enclosed within the house so there are no windows and no way to exhaust fumes - just be aware of this so you do not unwittingly set off the smoke alarm and disturb the neighbors in adjacent units. Also, the door to the bathroom, which is between the two bedrooms within the cottage unit doesn't lock, so you will need to come up with a system to alert your travel partners when someone is using the bathroom to avoid walking in on each other. Other than those two points for awareness, though, everything else is great. The bedrooms are huge, the beds are comfortable, the linens are pristine, the kitchen has everything you need, and the house is right by Otsego Lake and only a block from Main St. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay.

We had a wonderful stay on Gemma’s property and felt right at home. The kids loved feeding the farm animals — a total highlight!! Gemma generously provided us with an array of breakfast items, which really made for lovely mornings. We would absolutely return!

Francine and Vince were wonderful hosts. They went out of their way to make us feel comfortable and provided many suggestions for local places to visit. The location was perfect for us since we were in town to watch our son play baseball. We were close to both All-Star Village and Dreams, which was perfect. The lake was also beautiful. My husband and I had a great time during our stay.

We had the most wonderful stay at Amanda’s place! The space was exactly as described and perfect for our family while visiting our daughter at Colgate. We loved the location on the lake and views out the front windows. The house is about 3 miles from the Colgate athletic fields or a ten minute drive - 12 minutes if you’re going up the hill. Amanda was such a gracious and accommodating host with excellent communication. We will definitely be back!

The apartment was located in a great area and was walkable to downtown and the restaurants. Once we arrived, we didn't have to move the car.

Paul is the best host I have ever communicated with through Airbnb. He is extremely responsive and keeps a very clean place. Will be staying here for years to come.

My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed our short stay! The screened in patio was perfect for relaxing breakfasts, and my husband was a huge fan of the fireplace. 10/10 would visit again

Wesley was a phenomenal host, beautiful home, extremely clean and comfortable! He checked in with us, making sure all was well during a snowfall, and offering a generator if the power were to go out! The kitchen was well equipped, the beds were comfortable and there were many other little extras like games, snacks, some drinks and all the cleaning supplies you might need. If we ever visit Cooperstown again, I would definitely stay at Wesley’s house a second time! Thank you for making our stay great!

Enjoyed our stay. The place was clean, comfortable, and as described. The host was responsive, and check-in was smooth. Good location and amenities—would recommend.

It was our first time to Cooperstown, it was a Christmas present to my partner. He was so excited and had no idea what to expect, he fell in love with the area as I did ! The stay here was magical. Beautiful and serene. We took very good care of everything while we were there and hope to be welcomed back again.

My favorite Air Bnb stay to date. Quiet and cozy place with everything you could possibly want for a family getaway. These hosts thought of everything all the way to the s’more kits. The fishing was great as well - we caught 49 large pickerel in 2 days (we were doing catch and release so we may have caught the same one more than once). All around perfect place to spend quality time with family - lots of fun things to do in Livingston manor and Roscoe. Great local breweries as well. Definitely plan to visit again!

I rented this house for my grooms folks at my wedding. It was such a relaxing place to come back to after all the stresses of planning and participating in a wedding, and my entire group enjoyed it immensely. Myles was incredibly helpful and a great host. Highly recommended!

Beautiful house and property! Highly recommend— at first I thought it had to be fake because of all the perfect 5 star reviews— but it lived up to expectations.

I had a wonderful stay at this charming cabin! From the moment I arrived, everything was spotless and well-maintained — you can tell the host puts a lot of care into the space. The cabin had a warm, cozy feel and all the amenities I needed for a comfortable stay. The location was peaceful and perfect for a relaxing retreat. The host was incredibly friendly and welcoming, offering great local tips and making sure I felt right at home. Patti even left fresh cut flowers throughout the cabin! Communication was quick and helpful from booking to check-out. I truly appreciated the thoughtful touches throughout the cabin — it made my trip even more special. Highly recommend this Airbnb for anyone looking for a clean, quiet, and friendly place to stay. I’ll definitely be coming back!