Skip to content
Sign up
Log in
Vacation rentals in Gustavus

Vacation rentals in Gustavus

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Gustavus

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

  • Little Tin Cottage-Year Round-Couples-Singles-Dogs
    Entire cottage · 4 guests · 3 beds · 1 bath
    Little Tin Cottage-Year Round-Couples-Singles-Dogs

    The Little Tin Cottage year round get-away is for all couples & fiends to enjoy some "Me Time", "We Time", "Our Time". The decor has something for everyone's taste & is quite comfy. With many things to do & see in the area too. Very close to the lake shore & marinas to fish or enjoy the views. As the seasons change so do the activities. They vary from festivals, fairs, boating, fishing, hiking, biking & hunting to ice fishing & snow snowmobiling. Visitor's info guidebooks are on hand in cottage.

    What guests are saying:

    “If you're even slightly considering this location, book it immediately! The brief review is that this place was the cleanest and best appointed Airbnb that we have ever seen. You know that "mom is coming to visit" type of clean? That is this place. It's not quickly vacuumed before the next guest, it's fully cleaned. Personal touches: The sea shells are perfect. We've been together for 9 years, and we still found then funny. The note on the wall, the cookies labeled with our names, the treats for Pablo, it was all more than we have ever experienced at an Airbnb. Amenities: I was shocked to find cable on several televisions. There was a broad selection of DVDs and board games. We did not use the grill, fire pits or fish cleaning area. But I checked them all out for potential guests. Short answer? It's all clean, ready to use and well-supplied with propane, dry firewood and starter fluid. If it was any warmer, we would have sat in the deck, next time. The kitchen is also very-well stocked. Any equipment you would need is available and is clean. WiFi is throughout and fast. Plenty of parking. Communication: We ran very late, but DeeDee was overly accommodating, they even offered to let us postpone our checkout 7 hours to allow us to enjoy our stay longer. We had to get to our next location, but the offer was a first for us. I had minimal contact with DeeDee (just check in and out) but she answered immediately and you can tell she really enjoys hosting guests in her cottage. Conclusion: I visit family from Linesville to Meadville and this will be our go-to spot from now on. I'm looking forward to visiting when it's warmer to take advantage of the outside amenities. Thank you for a wonder stay.”

  • Cozy Cabin on Lake Pymatuning had a FaceLift!
    Entire cottage · 4 guests · 3 beds · 1 bath
    Cozy Cabin on Lake Pymatuning had a FaceLift!

    Small cabin on beautiful Lake Pymatuning in a quiet, private cove...perfect for a couple or individual seeking peace and relaxation. We remodeled! We listened to your comments and suggestions! New roof,windows, siding...we will update photos when work is completed. Still cozy and quirky with a west coast vibe. Additional space in a classic retro camper in secure backyard. You will have the entire home uninterrupted during your stay. Close to Mortals Key Brewery , Carried Away Outfitters.

    What guests are saying:

    “Such a cute cozy cottage with a view of the lake out front while drinking coffee, and privacy in the back with a fire at night was just what we needed. We were able to easily walk along a path to the lake and docks. Short quick drive to state park and nice little brewery with live music. We enjoyed all the small touchs Carolyn provided for her guests, and the fresh eggs, oranges for fresh juice and yogurt made for a quick little breakfast before heading out on our adventures. Host was easy to get in contact with should you have any problems, questions, or in my case leave something behind! Me and my fiance can not wait to come back again we enjoyed ourselves so mich!”

  • Caroma Lake Cabin- Private & Secluded
    SUPERHOSTEntire cabin · 8 guests · 6 beds · 1 bath
    Caroma Lake Cabin- Private & Secluded

    If you are looking for a great secluded staycation with a change of scenery or a quick getaway from the tight spaces of the city, this is the place you have been looking for. The cabin is nestled in acres of woods and pasturelands and overlooks the lake. Spend the days hiking and riding bikes on the long driveway or fishing and swimming in the lake. Read a book, play games, and gather for family meals on the screened in porch. End the day around the fire telling stories and stargazing.

    What guests are saying:

    “I found this place while looking for somewhere quiet, secluded, and on the water for a mini Easter trip with my family just trying to get away for a few days. I knew this place was going to be great when I found it on here, but it honestly exceeded all expectations. The cabin is adorable and functional, decorated with a “log-cabin feel” of being in nature, while also offering all of the modern amenities needed to stay comfortably: full kitchen where we cooked all of our meals, rainfall shower, electric fireplace, etc. The lake is super close to the cabin and we had such a fun time going out on the boats to fish (we caught a perch and 2 largemouth bass!) or even just to row around the lake and take in its beauty. In my travels over the past 2 years, I’ve been to Niagara Falls, the Everglades, NY wine country right on Lake Erie, and countless state and national parks/forests, but I can honestly say that this is my new favorite place. Kelly is also an excellent host and was available any time during our trip to answer any questions I may have had. She responded promptly when I called about a tree that fell in the way of the driveway of the property which we discovered on our way to the store one day. Sometimes that happens in the middle of the woods, but she had it handled so quickly and I was able to go to the store within 45 minutes of me calling her about it. I would rate this place more than 5 stars if that was possible. Words can’t describe how peaceful it is to just wake up in the middle of the woods, sit on the screened-in porch, and marvel at the lake before going out on the boat. We couldn’t have picked a better place to spend our mini Easter trip at, and we plan on coming back very soon!”

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you.

  • Homes
  • Hotels
  • Unique stays

Popular amenities for Gustavus vacation rentals

  • Kitchen
  • Wifi
  • Pool
  • Free parking on premises
  • Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Gustavus

The White Brick Inn at Pymatuning State Park
SUPERHOSTEntire apartment
The White Brick Inn at Pymatuning State Park
Price:$119 CAD/night
Hockran Family Farms Guesthouse
SUPERHOSTEntire house
Hockran Family Farms Guesthouse
Price:$129 CAD/night
Beautiful Farm house on park like acreage
Entire house
Beautiful Farm house on park like acreage
Price:$204 CAD/night
Quaint Cabin #6 - Pymatuning Lake
Tiny house
Quaint Cabin #6 - Pymatuning Lake
Price:$68 CAD/night
Liberty Raymond Tavern
SUPERHOSTPrivate room
Liberty Raymond Tavern
Price:$94 CAD/night
Pymatuning Lake Cottage
SUPERHOSTEntire cottage
Pymatuning Lake Cottage
Price:$172 CAD/night
Cozy Cabin in Kinsman
SUPERHOSTShared room
Cozy Cabin in Kinsman
Price:$121 CAD/night
The Creekside Cottage
Tiny house
The Creekside Cottage
Price:$95 CAD/night
One Room Lakeside Red Roof Cabin
Tiny house
One Room Lakeside Red Roof Cabin
Price:$61 CAD/night
New York style living at the lake
SUPERHOSTEntire house
New York style living at the lake
Price:$137 CAD/night
TLC Country Lodging
Entire guesthouse
TLC Country Lodging
Price:$272 CAD/night
A little piece of heaven "Up on the Hill"
Private room
A little piece of heaven "Up on the Hill"
Price:$204 CAD/night
Show all