Lake house vacation rentals in Lake Shafer

Find and book unique lake houses on Airbnb

Top-rated lake house rentals in Lake Shafer

Guests agree: these lake houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favourite

Home in Rochester

5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Wenopa (Two Moons) on a Lake Manitou Peninsula

Immerse yourself in the charm of the 1920s with a stay at this beautifully renovated Lake Manitou home. Lot has 300ft seawall and lake views on three sides. Enjoy a cozy stay with 3 bedrooms, remodeled bathroom, & loft with queen bed & office. Outdoors: Revel in the serene sunrise, or gaze at the stars. Spacious deck with Blackstone grill, fire pit, corn hole, 2-40ft boat piers, swim pier, paddle boat, 2 kayaks & tandem bike, Ideal for peaceful escapes or adventures. Close to town. Self-check-in

Superhost

Home in Monticello

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Indiana Beach's best retreat

Minutes from both Indiana beach amusement park and Indiana beach boat rentals. Boat dock available. Includes a fully equipped kitchen, linens, both bath and beach towels. Fully rehabbed. Most furnishing are new including kitchen-equipment/accessories. Provided is an array of sundries including, bug spray, sunscreen, shower gel, shampoo, and conditioner. Kitchen is stocked with basics such as sugar, coffee, tea, condiments, S/P and maybe a few treats and sticks to roast marshmallows or hot dogs.

Guest favourite

Home in Rochester

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Lake house in Rochester

Relax in this newly updated lake house right on Lake Manitou. Enjoy the views from our huge deck with fire pit and grill or head down to the lower level for a covered patio with lakeside yard. Dock access for fishing, swimming, or kayaking or contact us if you have boating experience & interest in renting our pontoon boat. Golfing, hiking on the Nickel Plate Trail, shopping, and restaurants right at your finger tips. Lake Manitou is an all-sport lake with fishing, boating, kayaking and more.

Guest favourite

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Lakeside Bliss: Wonderful Lake Views & Access

Welcome to your lakeside retreat! Newly renovated 2bedroom, 2bath gem offers modern comfort and stunning lake views. Spacious living area flooded with natural light, fully equipped kitchen for easy meal prep, and dining area with breathtaking views. Both bedrooms boast cozy linens and plush bedding, ensuring a tranquil night's rest. Direct lake access for swimming, fishing, or basking in the sun on the private dock. Roll-away bed can fit in any bedroom and queen size air mattress available.

Guest favourite

Home in Culver

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 203 reviews

Perfect spot: 3 FULL baths, 4 bedrooms

All photos are 2025. 4 large bedrooms, 3 FULL bathrooms all separate from bedrooms. Easy walk to academy, Lake Max, ALL restaurants & stores within 2 blocks. Big yard/large deck w/ grill. Washer/dryer, DISH, WiFi. 1 bedroom, 1 full bath downstairs, no stairs for either for older or special needs. 1-night weekday rental ONLY allowed in winter. Central Air + additional room units if someone wants even cooler for sleeping. Annual leader in return rentals in Culver for a reason. Affordable.

Top guest favourite

Home in Knox

5 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

Cozy Lakefront home on beautiful Bass Lake, IN

Welcome to The Lakehouse & Cabana on beautiful Bass Lake, IN. Step in to our cozy home for a relaxing stay, taking in all the views of calming waters and nature on display. A weekend getaway, or maybe a little longer stay, this location offers the perfect escape for rejuvenation. Enjoy a bonfire to warm up an evening gathering, while sipping on some hot cocoa. If fishing is on your list of favorite activities, our cove allows for a great catch! *Pontoon Rental Available

Superhost

Home in Knox

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Last Summer Days Promo! Lakefront | Kayaks |Bikes

Discover Chillin Away, your modern lakefront retreat on Bass Lake! Just 10 miles from Culver Academy, this getaway puts you right on the water with 50 feet of private lakefront and your own private dock. Wake up to unforgettable sunroom views, sink into luxurious linens, and kickstart your mornings with a fully stocked coffee bar. Spend your days swimming, fishing, kayaking, or paddle-boarding—or take your lake adventure up a notch by renting a pontoon (3rd party).

Guest favourite

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Mellow Yellow on Shafer

Bring the family to this beautiful, spacious home on Shafer Lake. 4.5 miles to Indiana Beach 3.3 miles to Tippecanoe Country Club 1.5 miles to Hollow Acres Gold Course 2.5 miles to Battle Ground Golf Club 9.4 miles to Altherr Nature Park 4.4 miles to Lake Shafer Boat Rentals 1.1 miles to The Boat House 9.8 miles to Whyte Horse Winery 4.5 miles to Whisky & Wine Saloon 10 miles to Sportsmann Inn 10 miles to Kopacetic Brewery 12 miles to Fruitshine Wine

Guest favourite

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Cozy Cove Cottage

Lake life is truly the best life—and after a stay at Cozy Cove Cottage, you’ll understand why. Wake up to the gentle sounds of water lapping against the shore as you sip your morning coffee on the spacious deck with beautiful lake views. Whether you’re out on the water or simply relaxing in the peaceful embrace of nature, time seems to slow down here, inviting you to breathe deeper, laugh louder, and soak in every unforgettable moment.

Superhost

Home in Culver

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Culver/Lake Max Home... In-Town & Close to Academy

Clean, Comfortable, Updated Home just steps off of Main Street and a short walk to Cafe Max. A great home for Academy parents to stay while visiting their children. Also, a great residence to stay in if your child's team is playing a Culver team. Dogs are welcome, please no cats. $50 additional pet cleaning fee. Need the house for consecutive weekends? Let me know. Happy to be flexible with cleaning fees and unused mid-week days.

Superhost

Home in Knox

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

The GoodWell, ON the lake-Love! 2 living rooms!

The GoodWell is your dreamy lakefront escape! Sleeps 14 with 3 king rooms, a bunk room, and extra lounge space. Enjoy a screened-in deck, fire pit, private dock, kayaks, paddle boards, canoe, and a ceramic charcoal grill. All linens (yes, even beach towels!) are included. Pet friendly (fee applies). Golf carts & pontoon available to rent. Bonus: Hot tub coming May 2025! Perfect for group trips, families, and lakeside memory-making.

Guest favourite

Home in Knox

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 51 reviews

Lakefront Luxury: Hot Tub, Kayaks, Bikes & More!

Escape to Bass Lake and experience the ultimate lakeside retreat! This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom house that sleeps 15 offers a private dock, rooftop deck, and endless fun with kayaks, SUPs, bikes, a hot tub, and a fire pit. Enjoy lakefront access, a spacious patio, and nearby attractions just 90 minutes from Chicago. Create lasting memories with family and friends in this Indiana paradise.