Vacation rentals in Lake Shafer

Horseshoe Hideaway on the Tippecanoe River!

Rest & Relaxation await you at Horseshoe Hideaway! This bright, open space is ready to host you for your next adventure! Located in the secluded Horseshoe Bend area of the Tippecanoe River, this house is able to host a variety of guests with 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, fully equipped kitchen, smart TVs, electric fireplace, large deck, & washer/dryer. Off street parking is available. This home offers peace & quiet while still being close to amenities & many outdoor activities! Come visit today!

Hot Tub + Bonfires | Lake Shafer Waterfront

Custom-designed lakefront home built for multi-family & multi-generational getaways. • Newly built Main house (2017) • 102 ft of main Lake Shafer waterfront with private dock • Hot tub with panoramic lake views • 5-minute walk to Indiana Beach Amusement & Water Park • Perfect for boaters, families & groups seeking lake life NOTE: Bookings for mid-June through mid-August are only available within 45 days of arrival. For advance bookings during summer, please see our other listing for 15 people.

Your Country Home - Private, quiet wooded setting

Modern house in the country with a reputation for sparkling cleanliness and 2 day minimums between guest stays. Close to Culver Academies (18 min/10 mi), Lake Maxinkuckee (13 min/7.4 mi), Lake Manitou (27 min/16 mi), and the historic Tippecanoe River (5 min/3.5 mi to Germany Bridge or 5 min/1.6 mi to Aubbeenaubbee Landing in Leiters Ford). We keep our prices low for 2 people, so please note that while we have space for up to 6 guests, each additional guest will incur small additional charges.

Lake Shafer 3 bedroom 2 bath lakefront house

Relax in our 3 bed 2 bath lakefront cottage in the heart of Lake Shafer. Enjoy several outdoor seating/eating areas and the party deck that overlooks the lake. Come nightfall, throw some logs into the fire pit and enjoy the lights and sounds of lake life! 2 kayaks with life vests included. Cottage is walking distance to Indiana Beach, Tippecanoe Country Club golf course, putt putt, arcade and basketball courts. Sorry but no pets and no parties. Cottage is in a quiet residential neighborhood.

Lakefront Escape | Dock, Fire Pit & Park Lights

Step into your perfect lakeside getaway — a cozy 2-bedroom waterfront cottage where relaxation and fun go hand-in-hand. Spend your mornings fishing off the private dock or enjoying the gentle breeze by the shoreline, and wind down your evenings roasting s’mores under the stars. Set right on the shores of Lake Shafer, this hidden gem offers unobstructed views of Indiana Beach, where the lights of the amusement park and the hum of the roller coasters create a truly unforgettable backdrop.

Charlesworth Cottage

Relax with the family at this peaceful little cottage hidden away but close to many amenities. It’s 10 minutes from Indiana Beach, 30 minutes from Purdue University, and just a short walk to the Madam Carroll and Sportsman restaurant. It has a friendly neighborhood and includes a dock walking distance from the home. The kids can swim in shallow areas of the dock. This place is where you will be able to get away from the hustle and bustle of life. May you be blessed by your experience.

Lakeside Haven: 4 bed/2 bath/sleeps 9 on the water

Lakeside Haven: Your Dream Walk-Out Ranch Getaway in Monticello, Indiana Welcome to your serene escape on the shores of Lake Shafer—where peaceful mornings, adventure-filled afternoons, and golden hour sunsets create the perfect backdrop for memories that last a lifetime. Tucked away on a private, wooded lot in beautiful Monticello, Indiana, this stunning 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom walk-out ranch is your invitation to unwind, recharge, and reconnect with the ones who matter most.

Sunset Cabin

Unique tranquil get away. Built in 1931 is a very authentic rustic cabin , full of love and gives you a feeling of what it would be like to live in 1931 yet a few luxuries for todays world. The cabin is small & cozy, queen size bed in bedroom, full size sofa bed , 2 small futons in loft that would sleep 2 kids. Sleep 6 if 2 of guest were kids or young teens . Close by Madam Carroll ,Indiana Beach, Summer Beach House beach & Tall Timbers. 27 miles to Purdue !

The Rock House in Delphi - Rock Solid. Charm.

The historic Rock House is full of the character and charm of a classically-styled bungalow — window seats, a rock fireplace, and artfully designed living areas. Furnished for comfort, certain to charm. Guests can enjoy relaxing with cocktails, cooking in a fully furnished kitchen, or using a tandem bike to explore the neighborhood. Fido is welcome too. This two bedroom, one bath, home offers all the modern amenities for a comfortable stay.

Cottage on Lake Freeman

3bedroom 1bath living room along w dining room full kitchen and laundry room. 65 ft of water frontage with dock. there is a gas grill along w fire pit on deck with lots of seating. We also have a tiki bar. THIS IS A HOUSE RENTAL ONLY. We have our personal electric boat lifts you can use when renting the house. 65ft of shore front that is exclusive and private to abnb renters for laying out and swimming.

Family Fun or Serene Setting?

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful Tippecanoe River cottage with access to Lake Schafer in Monticello, IN. Located about 15 minutes from the Indiana Beach amusement park and other warm weather activities. Plenty of books, games and activities to keep your kiddos busy while you relax out on the expansive deck that overlooks the water. Plenty of gathering space inside and out!

Waterfront Lake House

Soak up the sun, have fun, or relax at our waterfront home on Lake Freeman. The deck spans out over the dock and water for a picture perfect sun-rise or sun-set. Centrally located in Monticello near dining, Indiana Beach Amusement Park, Whyte Horse Winery, and shopping. Fully renovated stocked with the necessities and ready for your arrival.