Vacation rentals in Muttontown

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Muttontown

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favourite

A serene waterfront scene captures several boats anchored in calm waters, with a backdrop of trees showcasing autumn foliage. Vintage and modern homes are visible along the shore, creating a picturesque town ambiance along the shoreline.

Home in Cold Spring Harbor

Captain’s Cottage Water Views -3 Bdrm

Enjoy this this light and airy home with spectacular sunset & water views. 5 minute drive to private beach. Oversized deck and 2 porches all with water views. Located in idyllic, historic Cold Spring Harbor. Explore the green belt with access from rear yard. Walk to shopping, restaurants, live music, fishing or picnic in the local park. Sip a glass wine & enjoy the beautiful sunsets from the expansive deck with firepit. Upstairs loft bedroom has a fireplace & private deck w/ water view.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Guest favourite

A modernist house is surrounded by vibrant autumn foliage, showcasing a blend of red, orange, and green leaves. The structure features large glass windows and a roof that floats above the walls, offering scenic views of the lush forest.

Home in Rye

1956 House of the Year Award. Easy commute to NYC.

Architectural masterpiece, designed by famous architect Ulrich Franzen. House of the year awarded in 1956 by Architectural Record, featured in LIFE and House and Garden magazines. Taste the unique experience of modernist living, surrounded by nature yet walking distance to the beautiful town of Rye, the beach, natural parks and 45m by train to NYC. The house is filled with light,all the rooms have forest views,you feel inmersed in nature while enjoying the magical experience of modernist living!

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

Top guest favourite

An open floor plan is showcased, featuring a cozy living area with a gray sofa and a wooden coffee table. A dining area with a round mirror and a six-seat table is visible, along with a kitchen equipped with modern appliances. Natural light fills the space.

Home in West Hempstead

Modern 3 Bd Spacious Apartment in PRIME Location

Incredible home in the heart of Long Island NY! Guests will enjoy staying at this cozy, elegant, open floor plan 2nd floor marvel w/easy access to everything from this prime located home in heart of West Hempstead. Picturesque park/pond across st - 15 mins to Shopping/Malls - 10 mins to Long Island beaches - 15 mins to JFK, 5-10 mins to LIRR stations. Enjoy the comforts of quiet suburban living yet be a short drive/train ride away to the glamorous razzle/dazzle and adventures of New York City.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 220 reviews

Guest favourite

A spacious living room featuring a comfortable sectional sofa adorned with decorative pillows. A large area rug anchors the seating arrangement, which includes two lounge chairs. Natural light filters through multiple windows, highlighting the neutral color palette and decorative wall art.

Home in White Plains

Spacious 3b/3b Mediterranean in White Plains

Bring the whole family to this great place with lots of room for fun, relaxation or hosting! This 3bed/3bath Mediterranean is freshly renovated with stylish touches & comfy furniture. The main floor of this multi family serves as a great spot to bring the family while visiting the area. The house boasts an oversized living room, formal dining room, large chef's kitchen, and plenty of sleeping space. With heat & AC throughout the entire 2k sf unit, this house is great for anything& everything!

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

Guest favourite

A bright and airy studio space features a canopy-covered bed draped with sheer fabric. An ornate mirror and a small table with decorative items enhance the room's charm. Natural light fills the area through large windows, complemented by a cozy seating option.

Guest suite in Bayville

Romantic, Cozy and Private, 1 Block from Beach

Relax in your private romantic retreat with Canopy Queen Bed & Beautiful modern bathroom, 1 Block from beach, Second floor studio with small fridge, microwave, coffee maker, induction cook top, SmartTV... Just 7 min from the Long Island Railroad, Oyster Bay stop. Near to restaurants, shops, tennis courts. You can go biking, swimming, fishing, play golf, rent kayaks, motor boats, paddle boards. Visit Arboretums, Historic sites, Parks, walk along the water, go to the nearby movies and more...

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 634 reviews

Top guest favourite

Apartment in East Meadow

"Home away from home" in Long Island, NY

2-bedroom apartment in a safe neighborhood. 2 queen beds & Twin air mattress. Extra towels and sheets set. Plenty of space with access to kitchen, washer/dryer (not shared with anyone else), spacious living room & dining area. You will have your own entrance. Near many attractions, 25 mins from JFK, & a quick train ride or drive to NYC and near the beach! All types of fast food and delicious restaurants nearby! Apt is in excellent condition, sanitized and clean in a great environment.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 185 reviews

Guest favourite

Home in Huntington

Spacious Retreat w/Jacuzzis -1- Night Stay Welcome

* We are open for One Night Stays-please message for price$ Escape to this beautiful home on 3 private acres close to West Hills County Park. Enjoy the best of both worlds—serene outdoor adventures just minutes from the Walt Whitman Mall and top shopping spots. Designed for entertainment and family gatherings, this home boasts a stunning kitchen, luxurious bathrooms, and two relaxing hot tubs. Whatever your pleasure, this is the perfect getaway for nature lovers and city explorers alike!

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 45 reviews

Guest favourite

A light-filled living area features a comfortable sofa adorned with nautical-themed pillows. A wooden coffee table rests on a woven rug, while a stylish floor lamp and wooden chair enhance the space. The ceiling showcases exposed beams, adding character to the room.

Home in Cold Spring Harbor

Nautical Farm House on Working Farm with Animals

Completely renovated 3 bedroom home on working farm with fire place and piano. Lux kitchen features stainless steel appliances, Sub-zero refrigerator, and marble counters Private, fenced backyard with BBQ. Farm has goats, pigs, chickens, bee hives, ducks, and on-site cafe and bakery. Close to Huntington village, bike trails nature walks, restaurants, parks, and the beach. Fast wi-fi, laundry access and pet friendly. New beds and baby grand piano. Bedrooms have black out curtains.

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 313 reviews

Guest favourite

An outdoor deck is visible, featuring a spacious arrangement of gray wicker furniture and a glass-topped coffee table. The area is surrounded by a white fence, providing a sense of privacy. Sunlight brightens the deck, highlighting the wooden flooring.

Home in Glen Head

Family Home near NY Beach | Private Workspace

Your Perfect Family Getaway Pet Friendly Awaits!! ▶ Book our spacious 3BR home & couple of mins away from the beach, complete amenities ideal for big families! Don't miss out – reserve your stay today! ✔ Private workspace ✔ Spacious yard ✔ Charcoal Grill ✔ Crib and Pack n Play ▶ Close to locations such as: ✔ 6 mins to Tappens Beach ✔ 10 mins to Welwyn Preserve County Park ✔ 11 mins to Planting Fields Arboretum & Garvies Point Museum and Preserve ✔ 15 mins to Pryibil Beach

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 64 reviews

Top guest favourite

A modern living space is highlighted by a flat-screen TV mounted on a light blue wall. A dark sofa and a wooden coffee table create a cozy seating area. A dining table with four black chairs is situated against the wall, complemented by a decorative plant.

Guest suite in Freeport

2 Bed 1 Bath Suite Washer/Dryer - Mid-Term Rental

Enjoy a few days away with your family & friends here in Long Island, New York. Just 40 minutes out from New York City. Freeport, Long Island is located just 40 mins east of NYC. Enjoy the excitement of city life, with the peaceful pace of this working class suburb. Property is close to the LIRR train into Manhattan. Travel by car, bus, or train. Your stay is just- 20 mins away from Queens, NY 35 mins away from Brooklyn, NY 40 mins away from Manhattan, NY

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 227 reviews

Superhost

A spacious living and dining area features dark hardwood flooring and a modern dining table with black chairs. A sleek black sofa is positioned against the wall, complemented by a ceiling fan that circulates overhead. Natural light enters through the windows, enhancing the open layout.

Home in Farmingdale

3 bedroomprivate/Downtown heart/convenience galore

Beautiful newly renovated home in the village of Farmingdale. FULL HOUSE COMPLETELY PRIVATE 1min walk to Restaurants, Bars, LIRR to NYC, STARBUCKS, Free delivery Dry cleaners, SPA, Nail Salon, Barber Shop and Hair Salon, DUNKIN DONUTS, short drive to movies, mall, Long Island Beaches Vineyards and more! 5min from Bethpage Black Golf Course home of the PGA Tour

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Top guest favourite

Guest suite in Glen Head

Long Island Nature Retreat + Peloton + Shared Pool

Escape to a peaceful Long Island nature retreat surrounded by farmland and quiet countryside views—perfect for guests seeking calm and comfort. 🌿 2-acre lawn + private driveway 🏊 Shared outdoor pool (Only available from May to October) 🚴 Peloton vacation rental 🪵 Charcoal BBQ grills 🐴 Horse farm next door 🍎 Youngs Farm across the street

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews