Vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favourite
A quaint cottage is surrounded by lush greenery, featuring a welcoming front porch with seating. A circular stone firepit is arranged with blue Adirondack chairs, inviting gatherings. The landscaped yard includes a variety of trees and bushes, enhancing the serene countryside setting.
Home in Ashland
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

The Boathouse on Moon Lake

Quaint cottage overlooking Beurys Lake...or as my dad lovingly says..."its more like a shallow pond". For those who love a sweet quiet cottage get away with a gorgeous view, this is the perfect place for you. Kayaks and a small boat are here for your use...on my shallow, but pretty lake. Cottage has recently been renovated with love. 2 Queen bedrooms on main level…one with private full bath. Loft area has 2 twin beds…not navigable by very young kiddos or some adults (access is with a ladder)

Top guest favourite
A serene landscape is showcased with a winding path leading through lush greenery beside a calm river. In the distance, a large hill rises, providing a backdrop to the flowing water, while a stone arch bridge can be seen spanning the river.
Home in Harrisburg
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews

Fort Hunter Charm!

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil waterfront getaway. Enjoy lovely historic Fort Hunter Mansion and Park, just a short walk away with a beautiful view of the Rockville Bridge, the worlds longest stone arch bridge along the Susquehanna River ! You will be just a few hundred yards away from the Fort Hunter boat launch where fisherman from all over come to enjoy the muskie and walleye fishing. The Pennsylvania Farm Show Complex is just 6 minutes away! Hershey Park 20 minutes, Carlisle 20!

Top guest favourite
Place to stay in Shippensburg
5 out of 5 average rating, 447 reviews

The Frame ~ Charming Nature Escape ~ Hot Tub ~ BBQ

Escape to the charming 2BR 1Bath A-frame on a secluded wooded property just 10 mins away from Shippensburg, PA. Whether you're looking to savor nature‘s tranquility from the luxurious hot tub, share stories around the fire pit, or explore picturesque Cumberland Valley, this will be the ideal starting point for your adventures! *2 Comfortable BRs *Open Design Living *Full Kitchen *Smart TV *Backyard (Hot Tub, Sauna, Fire Pit, BBQ, Outdoor shower) *High-Speed Wi-Fi *Free Parking *EV charger

Top guest favourite
A spacious kitchen area is equipped with modern appliances, including a black refrigerator and a black oven. A wooden table, surrounded by four chairs, is positioned centrally. Large windows are dressed with dark curtains, allowing natural light to enhance the warm wood tones of the ceiling.
Home in Harrisburg
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 211 reviews

Come Relax at our Cozy Willow Retreat!

Welcome to our Cozy Willow Retreat ~ Relax in our one bedroom cottage located directly in between Hershey and Harrisburg. Close to all things - Hershey, Giant Center, Medical Center, Hollywood Casino, Harrisburg and lots of restaurants. Large yard leading up to beautiful creek. Features cozy decor aimed at convenience and comfort for your stay. Fully stocked kitchen to whip up your favorite treats. Comfortable Desk and Free Verizon GIG wifi free for students and remote workers!

Top guest favourite
The ranch-style home features a welcoming front porch with three chairs, surrounded by a neatly maintained lawn. The driveway leads to a gravel path and two garages. Lush greenery and trees provide a serene backdrop to the property, enhancing the secluded atmosphere.
Home in Halifax
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 201 reviews

Peaceful Getaway, with hot tub & fire pit.

Escape to Peaceful Getaway, where cozy comfort meets countryside charm. Nestled among the trees, this home invites you to slow down and enjoy life’s simple moments. Sip morning coffee on the deck as birds sing, spend the day exploring Lake Tobias or hiking the Appalachian Trail, then unwind in the hot tub or make s’mores by the fire pit under the stars. Whether for a romantic escape or family adventure, Peaceful Getaway offers the perfect blend of relaxation and connection.

Guest favourite
The cabin is set amidst a wooded area, featuring a red metal roof and dark exterior. A porch with red chairs welcomes guests. Gravel surrounds the cabin, accompanied by a picnic table and fire pit nearby, creating a peaceful outdoor space for relaxation.
Tiny homes in Mifflintown
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 399 reviews

Tiny Cabin In The Cove

Welcome to the tiny Cabin In The Cove! This beautiful cabin sits right in the woods of central Pennsylvania. The cabin is located 1000 ft away from the creek. State game land is a 5 minute drive for hunting. Acres of land for hiking, watch wildlife, or just relax. The Juniata river is a 10 minute drive to go kayaking. Amazing mom and pop resturaunts to eat at. This cabin is just one hour from Penn State main campus for football games and is an hour from Hershey Park.

Top guest favourite
The cabin's exterior features a welcoming front porch illuminated by warm lights, creating a cozy ambiance at dusk. Rocking chairs are arranged on the porch, offering a comfortable seating area. Stairs lead down from the porch to the gently sloped lawn, enhancing the outdoor space.
Cabin in Richfield
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 249 reviews

Hidden Pines Cabin in the Woods | Newly Renovated

This renovated cabin is perfect for a weekend getaway. Located on the beautiful Shade Mountain, it is a great spot to relax and unwind. Great for the family. Beds are two double beds, 1 single bed, a futon in our sitting room that sleeps 1 person. The cabin has running water, an indoor bathroom that includes a flush toilet, sink and a shower designed for shorten showers. A modernized kitchen has basic cooking accessories to prepare meals as well a coffee bar.

Top guest favourite
A modern cottage is nestled among trees, featuring a white exterior and contrasting dark roof. An outdoor patio with string lights provides a seating area, surrounded by natural stone landscaping and large rocks. The inviting structure exudes a serene charm, perfect for relaxation.
Home in Newport
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 440 reviews

Long Acre Farm Stay! Find seclusion on the back 40

Hi! Long Acre Hideaway is a secluded cottage dedicated to providing a quiet place for couples and/or small families to spend quality time with each other and with God. Come to the “back 40” of the farm to relax and rejuvenate! Experience some of the area’s best views on the walk around the perimeter of the farm on a 1.8 mile marked trail! Rest on the deck with a cup of coffee and watch for wildlife or soak in the private hot tub at night and watch the stars!

Guest favourite
The living area features large glass doors that lead to a spacious deck, allowing natural light to fill the room. Comfortable seating arrangements include a dark leather sofa and an armchair, complemented by wooden accents and a decorative clock.
Home in Mount Pleasant Mills
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

The St. Jude Tree Farm

The St. Jude Tree Farm might be what Davis and Bryan had in mind when they sang, “you can’t buy happiness, but you can buy dirt.” While you can’t rent happiness either, you can rent the SJTF. The SJTF offers family R and R with scenic views from a 900 sq. ft. deck, a 3 -acre lawn, basketball courts (one indoors), and a stone patio with a fire “wall” (as opposed to "pit"). There are several wineries, restaurants, shops and sights within a convenient drive.

Top guest favourite
A warm bedroom features a floral-patterned bedspread atop a spacious bed. Natural light filters through lace curtains on two windows. An antique dresser with a mirror and a lamp sit alongside a comfortable armchair, adding character to the cozy space.
Home in Hegins
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 123 reviews

Naomi's House

Forget your worries in this vintage country farmhouse. Nestled in the beautiful Hegins Valley, surrounded by farmland and the Appalachian mountains, this 3 bedroom 2 bath home is just minutes from local businesses and within an hour of numerous tourist attractions, amusement parks, off- road parks, wineries, outlets, golf courses, and restaurants. A stocked trout stream runs through the property within easy walking distance.

Top guest favourite
Cabin in Newport
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 331 reviews

A-Frame W/ HOTTub, MountainView,Pickleball/tennis

Welcome to Hilltop Haven A-Frame. Perched on top of the ridge and surrounded by trees, this unique getaway offers breathtaking views, total privacy, and a true connection to nature. Designed for both relaxation and recreation, this home has something for everyone—whether you’re unwinding in the hot tub, gathering around the fireplace, or enjoying a friendly competition outdoors.

Top guest favourite
The exterior of a two-story cabin is highlighted, featuring a light-colored facade with a gabled roof. A welcoming front porch includes two rocking chairs. The surrounding area is lush with greenery, emphasizing a connection to nature and tranquility in the setting.
Cabin in Landisburg
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 325 reviews

Cozy Ridge Cottage

Relax and reconnect with the whole family at this peaceful place. Or spend a wonderful time with your special person. Enjoy the sights and sounds of nature, and a beautiful view of the mountains. Our modern/boho cabin sleeps 6 guests, and offers the common necessities you will need on you’re stay with a few little extras along the way.

Popular amenities for New Buffalo vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Pennsylvania
  4. Perry County
  5. New Buffalo