Vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favourite
An open living area is highlighted by a large, comfortable sectional sofa positioned on a patterned rug. Exposed wooden beams adorn the ceiling, adding warmth. A stone fireplace and large windows provide natural light, while views of the outdoor deck and wooded surroundings can be seen.
Home in Harrisburg
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 328 reviews

Home away from home

Open floor plan on a wooded lot. 3 bedrooms, two bathrooms, kitchen, great room. Large deck over looks the yard and into the woods where the deer like to play. Close to Hershey, Lancaster and Gettysburg. Great places to eat within minutes. Queit neighborhood with some great views if your in the mood for a walk. Apartment on the bottom floor is occupied by my son and his cat while he attends PennState. He has separate parking and entrance. The only interaction with keegan would be if asked

Top guest favourite
The cabin is framed by lush greenery, featuring a large wraparound porch and tall windows that allow natural light to fill the interior. It showcases a striking modern wooden design with a sloped roof, nestled within a serene forest setting.
Cabin in Jonestown
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Tobias Cabin

This peaceful and centrally located cabin provides tranquility and relaxation in the Blue Mountains. The large wraparound porch surrounded by the lush landscape and natural beauty of the cold spring, creates an environment that you don’t want to miss. Spend your evening looking up at the stars in the hot tub or making s’mores over a fire creating lasting memories. If you choose to be adventurous there is hiking trails, biking, fishing, kayaking and several state parks with lakes nearby. Enjoy!

Guest favourite
The cabin features a charming exterior with a green metal roof and wooden accents. A welcoming porch offers seating for relaxation, surrounded by lush forest. Soft lighting enhances the cabin's warm presence, while a gravel driveway provides access.
Cabin in Millerstown
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

Cozy Cabin in a Private Wooded Hollow

Welcome to Hidden Hollow Cabin! Nestled in a private, wooded hollow, nature abounds in this forest retreat. Surrounded by ferns, pines and endless woodland views, escape to your own cabin getaway. Soak up nature as you sip your morning coffee on the deck, or relax around a crackling fire as the stars start to appear. Easily accessible & only minutes off of Route 322 in Millerstown. Within a mile of Sweet Water Springs Wedding Venue. For more of our story, find us on insta @hiddenhollowcabin

Top guest favourite
A serene landscape is showcased with a winding path leading through lush greenery beside a calm river. In the distance, a large hill rises, providing a backdrop to the flowing water, while a stone arch bridge can be seen spanning the river.
Home in Harrisburg
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

Fort Hunter Charm!

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil waterfront getaway. Enjoy lovely historic Fort Hunter Mansion and Park, just a short walk away with a beautiful view of the Rockville Bridge, the worlds longest stone arch bridge along the Susquehanna River ! You will be just a few hundred yards away from the Fort Hunter boat launch where fisherman from all over come to enjoy the muskie and walleye fishing. The Pennsylvania Farm Show Complex is just 6 minutes away! Hershey Park 20 minutes, Carlisle 20!

Top guest favourite
A single-story house is surrounded by lush green grass and a well-maintained landscape. A variety of trees and shrubs can be seen, along with a fenced yard in the background. Bright blue skies and scattered clouds create a serene setting.
Home in Shermans Dale
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 242 reviews

Country retreat, dogs ok, 15 min 81/76, Carlisle

Make yourself at home at the Country Retreat! Close to many area attractions for visitors & highways for through travelers. Plus, a huge fenced in yard & fire pit! Arriving late? The house is fully equipped with all kitchen necessities, Keurig coffee maker, microwave, coffee, tea, snacks, frozen pizzas, & canned soups. Out all day? Return & enjoy dinner under the covered pergola & a drink by the fire. Enjoy some yard games available in the shed. No cleaning/pet fee. $35/person/night over 2.

Top guest favourite
Place to stay in Shippensburg
5 out of 5 average rating, 452 reviews

The Frame ~ Charming Nature Escape ~ Hot Tub ~ BBQ

Escape to the charming 2BR 1Bath A-frame on a secluded wooded property just 10 mins away from Shippensburg, PA. Whether you're looking to savor nature‘s tranquility from the luxurious hot tub, share stories around the fire pit, or explore picturesque Cumberland Valley, this will be the ideal starting point for your adventures! *2 Comfortable BRs *Open Design Living *Full Kitchen *Smart TV *Backyard (Hot Tub, Sauna, Fire Pit, BBQ, Outdoor shower) *High-Speed Wi-Fi *Free Parking *EV charger

Top guest favourite
The ranch-style home features a welcoming front porch with three chairs, surrounded by a neatly maintained lawn. The driveway leads to a gravel path and two garages. Lush greenery and trees provide a serene backdrop to the property, enhancing the secluded atmosphere.
Home in Halifax
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 203 reviews

Peaceful Getaway, with hot tub & fire pit.

Escape to Peaceful Getaway, where cozy comfort meets countryside charm. Nestled among the trees, this home invites you to slow down and enjoy life’s simple moments. Sip morning coffee on the deck as birds sing, spend the day exploring Lake Tobias or hiking the Appalachian Trail, then unwind in the hot tub or make s’mores by the fire pit under the stars. Whether for a romantic escape or family adventure, Peaceful Getaway offers the perfect blend of relaxation and connection.

Top guest favourite
A spacious open-concept living area features modern cabinetry and a large kitchen island with seating. Warm string lights illuminate the space, highlighting the comfortable seating area and expansive windows that offer natural light. Hardwood floors add a welcoming touch.
Apartment in Midtown
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

Midtown's Coolest Penthouse Apt—Free Parking!

Historic Midtown Retreat: Discover the perfect blend of history and modern comfort in our spacious 2-bedroom, 2-bath apartment, located on the top floor of an old department store. Ideal for lively gatherings or cozy escapes, this unique space in Harrisburg’s trendy Midtown offers easy access to Downtown, the State Capitol, and local breweries. Enjoy free off-street parking, a fully stocked kitchen, and in-unit laundry. Explore Hershey and Harrisburg from this unique spot!

Top guest favourite
A modern cottage is nestled among trees, featuring a white exterior and contrasting dark roof. An outdoor patio with string lights provides a seating area, surrounded by natural stone landscaping and large rocks. The inviting structure exudes a serene charm, perfect for relaxation.
Home in Newport
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 442 reviews

Long Acre Farm Stay! Find seclusion on the back 40

Hi! Long Acre Hideaway is a secluded cottage dedicated to providing a quiet place for couples and/or small families to spend quality time with each other and with God. Come to the “back 40” of the farm to relax and rejuvenate! Experience some of the area’s best views on the walk around the perimeter of the farm on a 1.8 mile marked trail! Rest on the deck with a cup of coffee and watch for wildlife or soak in the private hot tub at night and watch the stars!

Top guest favourite
The living area features a mix of seating with a gray sofa and a brown leather chair, arranged around a round coffee table. A large television is positioned on a shelf unit, while soft light enters through a window adorned with sheer curtains.
Home in Midtown
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 651 reviews

Walk to Midtown From Contemporary Uptown Harrisburg Home

Beautifully remodeled, single family, brick rowhome in the "Olde Uptown" neighborhood of Harrisburg. Take advantage of the extra care and personal touches in this property such as complimentary beverages and snacks, continental breakfast items, professionally designed interior, and incredibly comfortable king sized bed. You can walk to the fantastic Broad Street Market, local coffee shop and cafe, and the beautiful riverfront trail.

Top guest favourite
Cabin in Newport
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 334 reviews

A-Frame W/ HOTTub, MountainView,Pickleball/tennis

Welcome to Hilltop Haven A-Frame. Perched on top of the ridge and surrounded by trees, this unique getaway offers breathtaking views, total privacy, and a true connection to nature. Designed for both relaxation and recreation, this home has something for everyone—whether you’re unwinding in the hot tub, gathering around the fireplace, or enjoying a friendly competition outdoors.

Superhost
A historic caboose, painted in muted tones, sits beside the riverbank. Stairs lead to a deck with river views, surrounded by greenery and a small tree. In the background, the stone arch bridge is visible against the rolling hills.
Guesthouse in Harrisburg
4.79 out of 5 average rating, 200 reviews

Rocky the Caboose at Fort Hunter Park

Rocky is a historic 1922 caboose at Fort Hunter Park. Imagine you are on the Orient Express! Next to the world's longest stone arch railroad bridge. On the riverbank for fishing or kayaking or incredible sunsets. We have bikes and kayaks. Not to be missed. SOCIALLY DISTANCED. SELF CHECK IN. SEPARATE ACCESS. HOSTS WANT YOU TO BE SAFE FROM WORRY IN THESE TRYING TIMES.

Popular amenities for New Buffalo vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Pennsylvania
  4. Perry County
  5. New Buffalo