Vacation rentals in New Middletown

Top guest favourite

Guest favourite

Staycation Lake View HUGE Year Round Spa Firepit

SAVE 10% for 3 days 12% for 4 days 15% for 5 days 20% for 7 days 40% for 28 days This mid 1800's log cabin, built as humble servant's quarters, has been completely transformed. It's now a spacious lake home with multiple additions and an unexpectedly gigantic swim spa for year-round relaxation, romance or fun! Feel at peace and at home connecting with loved ones in a tranquil natural setting. 8 Adults plus space for young kids! WIFI & Smart Roku TVs Boardman and Youngstown attractions.

Lanterman’s Chill

Designed specifically for Airbnb guests visiting the Youngstown Area, this warm and cozy smart-home with comfortable beds, black-out curtains, security measures, & modern features is a perfect fit for almost everyone. Professionals on business will find a quiet & effective work station (i.e. mesh wifi, printer, etc). Families with babies or dogs will have the amenities they need (i.e. pack & play, kennel, etc). Active travelers will enjoy other fun features (i.e. kayaks, bikes). Welcome Home!

Cute 3BR Pet-Friendly Home - Boardman!

Keep it simple at this peaceful and centrally-located place. Just minutes from Millcreek, nature is calling. A peaceful drive, a nice walk, an adventurous hike, relaxing by a waterfall or even some fishing! Located in the heart of Boardman, you are 2 minutes drive from 224 (our main road) and all the shopping/eatery/movies and more. If your a golfer don't forget to check out our new indoor diving range at the mall! At home you have the entire home to yourself, including the large backyard

Fishing pond Lower Level Guesthouse with hot tub

Forget your worries in this spacious 6 acre serene spot. Lower level guesthouse is yours to enjoy to yourself. Complete with a queen bedroom, closet, Full kitchen, living room, full bathroom, & laundry. Exercise equipment, hot tub on outside deck, Fishing pond, room to roam, fire pit, collect chicken eggs for breakfast. One Dog is welcome w/deposit. Our family lives above in the main house, but gone most of the summer. You'll have a relaxing time being close to downtown Poland & Boardman

Top guest favourite

Guest favourite

Cozy Pet-Friendly Home w/Fenced Yard Near YSU

Step into comfort the moment you arrive. This warm and inviting two-story home is made to make every stay feel cozy, and completely stress-free. Whether you’re visiting family, for work, exploring Youngstown, or passing through, you’ll have the entire house to yourself—with every comfort thoughtfully prepared for you. ✨Fast WiFi ✨Pets stay for FREE! ✨Quiet, safe neighborhood ✨Stocked kitchen ✨Cozy living room + office ✨Fenced yard ✨Entire home *stairs are semi steep!* *No oven, only stove*

Rainbow Bend

The home is situated on 13 acres of land bordering both sides of the Neshannock Creek. With towering old growth forest on all sides, you truly connect with nature. The property boasts exclusive access to the Neshannock Creek, including a creek side deck. A cascading waterfall borders us to the north. The log home is constructed with rough hewn timbers, granite countertop, and hardwood floors throughout. A towering buck stove stone hearth is the centerpiece of the great room.

Top guest favourite

Guest favourite

Michelle’s Log Cabin @ Horse Farm

Secluded log cabin getaway on a peaceful farm. Relax and enjoy the sounds of nature, pasture views, and beautiful sunrises. Note: Incinerator toilet. Feed the horses at the fence—treats provided! Enjoy a ½-mile winding trail around the pasture. Comcast Wi-Fi, 3 TVs, gas grill, gas fire table, fire ring, cornhole Please book for the correct number of guests. Pets welcome with approval—please keep them off furniture, bedding & carpets. Must be crated when unattended

Top guest favourite

Guest favourite

“The Henry” House with Private Hot Tub

A picturesque countryside getaway with the convenience of shopping and restaurants nearby. If you love breweries, hot tubbing, golfing, cruising the neighborhood in a Model T golf cart, or just relaxing in a really cool house, this place is for you! Antiquing and open summer concerts minutes away. Comfort awaits with beautiful cozy interiors and a vintage vibe. With a touch of history and a lot of charm, your stay at “The Henry” will be a fun and welcome retreat.

Top guest favourite

Guest favourite

Halfway between NY and Chicago, 1 hr to PGH or CLE

Cross posted on Home Exchange and available for guest points This cozy, four-bedroom home is close to everything! Located in the charming working-class Neighborhood of Brownlee Woods, it’s located 8 minutes from both Youngstown State University and Boardman shopping. If you are looking to explore Pittsburgh or Cleveland, there are both within an hour’s drive. We’ve worked hard to create a relaxing place for you to unwind. We hope you’ll come to stay!

Top guest favourite

Guest favourite

2 King Retreat • Near Mill Creek Park • 70” TV

Welcome to this stylish and well-equipped 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom retreat, designed for ultimate comfort and relaxation. Featuring luxurious king-sized memory foam beds, smart TVs in every room, a fully stocked kitchen, and a spacious living area with a massive 70" TV, this home is perfect for travelers seeking both coziness and convenience. Enjoy the added perks of an attached garage, in-unit washer and dryer, and a dining area that seats six.

Top guest favourite

Guest favourite

Quiet Country Side Home w/Hot Tub & Dog Friendly!

Three bedroom, two full bathrooms. We have 2-4 parking spaces available along with a huge backyard perfect for grilling season! We have a fully equipped kitchen and dinner table. On the main floor you will find the main bathroom. We are located 15-20 mins from your major shopping in Boardman, and yes DoorDash delivers! Pitts. Int. Airport is approx. 50mins and Mercy Health is approx. 15 mins away. Pets are welcome with a small fee!

Top guest favourite

Guest favourite

The Nantucket Nook @ Pine Lake

The Nantucket Nook is a gem featuring a beautiful view of the lake off the back deck. A huge 70-inch TV makes the living area perfect for watching a movie or keeping up with your favorite sports! Being right beside Route 7 gives you quick and direct access to Columbiana, Boardman, and Youngstown. Local favorite places to check out are the Vineyards at Pine Lake, The Amish Market, Firestone Farms, and the Shaker Woods Festival!