Vacation rentals in Nicks Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Nicks Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favourite
The cabin's exterior features a combination of modern rustic architecture, with large windows and a screened-in porch. A wooden deck with seating and an umbrella is visible, surrounded by a grassy area and bordered by natural stone. Lush trees provide shade and tranquility.
Cabin in Old Forge
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews

Camp Seneca Modern ADK Cabin w/outdoor sauna

Treat yourself at Camp Seneca, a 2 bedroom in the Adirondack Mountains. Enjoy a private location in the Hollywood Hills area, yet close to Old Forge and the Fulton Chain of Lakes. Wooded setting, thoughtful amenities, and modern rustic decor - even an outdoor sauna with shower for total rejuvenation. Lake and beach rights down the hill. Perfect place to enjoy adventures or just simply relax and unwind. Snowmobile from your door or check out McCauley Mountain Ski Center only a 10 min drive away.

Top guest favourite
A scenic view of a peaceful waterfront area, featuring a private dock painted in red. Two Adirondack chairs are placed around a stone fire pit, surrounded by lush greenery and tall grasses, with calm water reflecting the blue sky and clouds.
Apartment in Old Forge
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Moose River cottage on the water in Old Forge

Soak in the Adirondacks from this rustic, newly remodeled one-bed apartment with a king size bed, full kitchen and bathroom. Start your day with a beautiful view of the sunrise over the Moose River. Feel free to launch one of our kayaks from our private dock, watch the stars from the hot tub or by the fire pit, take a bike ride on our bikes or just watch the amazing wild life and sunset from your private deck. Close to restaurants, shopping, hiking, and all of the summertime fun in Old Forge.

Top guest favourite
A spacious interior of the tree house features wooden walls and a sloped glass roof, inviting natural light. A round table with two wooden chairs is set against a backdrop of large windows, providing a clear view of the surrounding greenery and the river.
Treehouse in Boonville
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

Amazing Tree House on Black River Near Old Forge

Perched in privacy on the Black River is a rustic Tree House designed for adults only who are looking to be off the grid and connect with Mother Nature. Glamping at its best! The very private Tree House is perched on a hill overlooking the peaceful river. The quaint treehouse has five sides of glass and screens to view the river. This is built around trees but you enter from ground level. A power pack is available to charge cell phones and make coffee. Relax by a campfire at river's edge.

Top guest favourite
An indoor salt-water pool is illuminated with soft blue lights beneath a wood-beamed ceiling. Surrounding the pool are lounge chairs and a small table, with large windows that provide views of the outdoors. The space features a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Cabin in Old Forge
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews

Luxury Cabin with Indoor HEATED Salt Water Pool

Welcome to Deer Meadows -The Most Unique Luxury Cabin in Old Forge! This property has serious WOW factor as soon as you pull down the private drive, and the WOW's get bigger & better as you open the door to this Adirondack paradise! This newly renovated property is the perfect blend of privacy, modern finishes, & total luxury. Deer Meadows offers a heated, INDOOR salt-water pool inside a massive pool room with 20' cathedral ceilings, BOTH POOL & ROOM ARE 78°, and 24 color changing LED's...

Top guest favourite
A charming two-story home features a light-colored exterior with multiple windows allowing natural light in. The gravel driveway accommodates parking for vehicles, and a welcoming front entrance is visible. Surrounding greenery enhances the tranquil setting of the property.
Home in Old Forge
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 279 reviews

Moose Riverside Bungalow 3BR Home Old Forge NY

Moose Riverside Old Forge in town. Ski,snowmobile,ice skate, fish, hike, swim, shop. Walking distance to everything in Old Forge. 3 bedrooms, fire pit, charcoal grill, generator, external security cameras. Check calendar availability. 1 Amazon firestick TV and 1 smart TV. Fans/window AC 1st & 2nd floors. Grab bars, bath seat 1st fl bathroom. Driveway 50 ' long /park 2 cars front of house. Review amenities & pictures. Rent Kayaks/canoes at Mountainman Outdoor Supply Co. Rte 28 in season

Guest favourite
Home in Old Forge
5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

*NEW* Cozy Cabin • Close to Town

Escape to this beautifully renovated cabin a short distance to town. Enjoy warm wood interiors, cozy living space, and a fully equipped kitchen. Sleeps 6 across two bedrooms: one queen, one full, plus a bunk bed. The cabin features a modern bathroom, comfortable furnishings, and rustic décor throughout. Perfect for families, couples, and anyone looking for a peaceful Old Forge getaway. **Sorry, there is no trailer parking but I’ve included info on where to park trailers in town.**

Guest favourite
Cabin in Old Forge
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

Tiny Pine Cabin

Tiny Pine Cabin welcomes you for your next getaway, located just a little over a mile up the road from the center of town. This unique cabin boasts one bedroom downstairs with a queen bed and a cozy loft just up the ladder with 2 twin beds, a well appointed kitchen with a custom built eat in island, beautiful granite countertops & heated tile floors in both the kitchen & bathroom, a comfy couch with electric recliners. Enjoy all that Old Forge and the ADK have to offer!

Superhost
A serene lakeside view showcases a wooden dock extending into calm waters, framed by lush greenery. A stone fire pit is positioned beside an inviting wooden bench, creating a cozy spot for relaxation while appreciating the natural surroundings.
Cabin in Thendara
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Laura’s Lodge

Welcome to our charming lakeside cabin, your perfect retreat nestled in nature. Soak in the Adirondacks from this rustic, newly remodeled waterfront cabin. This retreat offers a perfect blend of comfort and nature, making it an ideal destination for your next getaway. The private dock invites you to fish, swim, or paddle the calm waters of Lake Tekeni. Book your stay today and discover the beauty of this mountain paradise. Approximately 4 miles from Old Forge.

Top guest favourite
A comfortable living area features two dark leather sofas facing each other. A wooden entertainment center with an electric fireplace is positioned against the wall, and a large flat-screen television is mounted above it. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space.
Home in Old Forge
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 170 reviews

Deer Trax

Relax with the family at this peaceful retreat located at 116 Railroad Ave Old Forge . It is newly built, and is nestled a little into the woods. I’m sure you will see wild life during your stay. Deer Trax is walking distance to town. It is only minutes away from Enchanted Forest and all what Old Forge has to offer. This would be the perfect place to stay for snowmobiling. It is right on the trail, and with space to park your trailer.

Top guest favourite
Cabin in Thendara
5 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

State of the art cabin in Thendara/ Old Forge

Welcome to the Alexandra, our Adirondack wonderland. This peaceful cabin has been completely renovated and refurbished in 2022. The quaint atmosphere comes equipped with all the newest tech, and entertainment. ( full house Sonos, Xbox series S, 85" Samsung theatre room, full sized luxury pool table, bar, etc..). Enjoy time away from reality and cozy up around the fire pit with loved one's at our state of the art cabin, the Alexandra.

Top guest favourite
The spacious living area features wood-paneled walls and a warm, inviting layout. Comfortable leather seating is arranged around a central coffee table. A stone fireplace adds character, and large windows allow natural light to illuminate the room.
Home in Old Forge
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Mountain House

We have the fix for your cabin fever! Our 2 bedroom, 1 and 1/2 bath house is right in the heart of Old Forge. Walk to shopping, dining, hiking, and boating. Water Safari and Enchanted Forest too! Plenty of room to spread out in the single family home. Very clean and recently updated throughout. Large yard and bonfire area. Recent addition of garage and owners quarters above garage. Owners not on property May-Oct 1st.

Top guest favourite
The boathouse features a rustic exterior with a red roof and dark siding, nestled among trees showcasing autumn colors. The spacious deck, illuminated by warm lights, includes chairs and a table. The serene water reflects the structure and surrounding foliage.
Home in Old Forge
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 122 reviews

The Boathouse on Fourth Lake

This historic boathouse is a rare find, situated directly in the waters of the popular Fourth Lake in Old Forge. Complete unobstructed lake views from all three sides of the home provide breathtaking sights during all four seasons. Enjoy the spacious dock, the open concept living area, swim in the private sandy bottom waterfront, and bask in the all-day sun provided by the north shore.

Popular amenities for Nicks Lake vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Herkimer County
  5. Webb
  6. Nicks Lake