Vacation rentals in Paradise Hill

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Paradise Hill

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favourite
A spacious living area is furnished with two dark leather sofas and a matching armchair, centered around a large wooden coffee table. A neutral area rug complements the hardwood floor. Light floods in through large windows adorned with blinds, highlighting the room's high ceilings.
Home in Paradise Hill
5 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Paradise Hill Retreat!

Paradise Hill gem! Just up the hill from lake access at Strayhorn Marina and the State Parks on both sides of the lake. Soda Steve's, Fin and Feather, disc golf, Mexican food, hiking trails, DG, Illinois River fishing and float trips are ALL nearby. This house is one of the newest in Paradise Hill. Huge covered patio in front plus a dining and grilling patio in back. Split floor plan with large kitchen and living in the middle of it all. Oversized garage. When you come, you won't want to leave!

Top guest favourite
The exterior of a quaint red tiny home is featured, showcasing a working water wheel beside a covered porch. The structure is set against a backdrop of green trees, with a gravel area and stone pathway visible in the foreground.
Tiny homes in Tahlequah
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 185 reviews

The Spring House Tiny Home near the Illinois River

Get cozy and settle into this rustic space! This cozy tiny home is perfect for couples looking to get away from it all. Overlooking the scenic Needmore Ranch and featuring a working water wheel powered by the nearby Stephen's Spring, the Spring House Tiny Home is perfect for couples reconnecting with nature, accessing the nearby Illinois River, or relaxing with that significant other. Guests will have access to over 400 acres of private property to hike, explore, or view the local wildlife.

Guest favourite
An open living area showcases a warm color palette, featuring a brown leather sofa with green cushions and a white accent chair. A geometric area rug lies beneath a coffee table, with a stone accent wall and large windows allowing natural light. A contemporary chandelier hangs overhead.
Cabin in Paradise Hill
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 58 reviews

The Guide House - Cottage-feel Cabin w/ Lake View

Update: July 4th is now available w/ a 3 night minimum. Welcome to a paradise near Paradise Hills! Whether you are looking to slow down and relax or enjoy all the lake has to offer, the Guide House is the place for you! This modern A-frame cabin will welcome you with a serene, open concept interior with cottage touches throughout, tons of natural light, and a large deck with a treetop lake view of Tenkiller. Just a hop, skip, and a jump from Fin N' Feather, Soda Steve's, and Strayhorn Marinat

Top guest favourite
A hot tub is situated on the deck, surrounded by trees offering a serene view of the river. The bubbling water reflects natural light, and the landscape includes greenery along the riverbank under a clear sky.
Cabin in Tahlequah
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews

A-frame on the Illinois river

Modern, brand new a-frame cabin on the river. Overlooks the peaceful Illinois river. Watch the floaters go by from the comfort of your deck. The cabin is luxurious with all the modern amenities, hot tub professionally maintained, fast wifi, Roku TV. This is the perfect place to sneak away with a loved one for a long weekend on the river. By day you watch the stream of floater and kayakers, by early evening it’s the wildlife’s turn with eagles, owls and crane take over the banks of the river.

Top guest favourite
The exterior of the home features a single-story structure with a light-colored facade and brick accents. A covered porch is visible, along with a concrete driveway leading to the front. A green trash bin is situated near the driveway, and mature trees provide shade in the background.
Home in Muskogee
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Spotlight on Broadway

Welcome to our carefully crafted oasis designed for discerning travelers seeking comfort, spaciousness, and coziness. Our goal is to surpass the ordinary and offer a retreat that goes beyond expectations.The spacious interiors aim to provide a sense of freedom and tranquility, allowing guests to unwind and rejuvenate. Cozy corners and carefully chosen furnishings create an inviting atmosphere, ensuring guests feel at home from the moment they arrive. Travelers with pets please message me.

Top guest favourite
A hot tub sits on a deck, featuring bubbling water and a serene view of the surrounding trees and Lake Tenkiller in the distance. The sky is clear and bright, enhancing the peaceful atmosphere of the outdoor space.
Home in Paradise Hill
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 64 reviews

Enjoy The Fall Leaves From The Hot Tub

Tucked away in Paradise Hill on a secluded, wooded lot, this property was completely renovated in 2024 and comes with a peekaboo view of Lake Tenkiller from the new hot tub. It's a 6 minute drive to Strayhorn Marina, an 18 minute drive to Burnt Cabin Marina, and less than a mile to Soda Steve’s. Also, about 35 minutes from river floats. Relax inside with family board games, cook a meal in the fully stocked kitchen, or just unwind in front of the Roku TV with 1 gig internet speed.

Guest favourite
The exterior view of the newly renovated log home showcases a blend of wood and stone elements. The structure features a covered outdoor space with ample seating on the upper deck and a spacious entrance with a distinctive garage door, framed by lush greenery.
Home in Paradise Hill
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 83 reviews

Britton Home/Paradise Hill Tenkiller w/Boat Slip

This beautiful newly renovated log home sits on Paradise Hill overlooking Lake Tenkiller. It is minutes away from the Fin and Feather Resort and Soda Steves Restaurant. The house also comes with a boat stall for guests to park their boat while they are staying. The boat stall is minutes from the house, an easy walk or drive. The home features 2 large decks for sitting and a covered outdoor kitchen with a fire stove for cooking. Guests can unload boats at Strayhorn Marina.

Top guest favourite
A panoramic view captures the vibrant colors of sunset over Lake Tenkiller, with gentle waves reflecting the sky. Several green islands and wooded shores are visible, alongside boat docks nestled along the water's edge, creating a serene lakeside atmosphere.
Home in Gore
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Lake Tenkiller Retreat

Come enjoy Lakeside Haven on Paradise Hill. Lake lovers and outdoor enthusiast look no further than this charming vacation rental overlooking Lake Tenkiller. This 4 Bedroom 2.5 bath offers a great hillside lake view minutes from Strayhorn Marina and in close proximity to over 68,000 acres of public hunting ground. Lakeside Haven is a place where you can escape the everyday hustle and bustle and relax on the lake, catch a variety of fish, or chase that trophy buck!

Top guest favourite
The cabin, designed with a rustic charm, is surrounded by lush greenery. A spacious porch, featuring wooden railings, offers entry with steps leading to the front door. Large windows create a welcoming feel, allowing natural light to illuminate the interior.
Cabin in Gore
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 90 reviews

Summer Special! Trout River Lodge River Run Cabin

Escape to a river landscape with private access to the Illinois River below Lake Tenkiller, renowned for rainbow trout. Fishing is available all seasons on a stocked river. Private access with a beautiful walk to a private water access for the family. Cabin offers traditional cabin esthetics with amenities, wild game mounts, antique lighting, and premium furniture. Trout River Lodge offers family-friendly retreat for 6-12 people or couples.

Top guest favourite
Cottage in Gore
5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Lake Tenkiller, Fin & Feather, Strayhorn Area

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. The Trout Catcher is 1 mile from Strayhorn Marina on Tenkiller Lake, right across the street from Fin & Feather & Soda Steve's, and 2 miles from the best trout stream in Oklahoma. There is plenty to enjoy in this area. Come enjoy this cozy cottage on Tenkiller Lake. Whether it is out on the deck or inside playing cards with family or friends, this is a peaceful place to get away.

Guest favourite
Home in Park Hill
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

The Lofty Cabin at Pettit Bay

Start your next adventure and step into The Lofty Cabin at Pettit Bay, our picturesque 2 bedroom cabin in the rolling landscape of Tenkiller Ferry Lake, where you’ll be greeted with incredible views through floor-to-ceiling windows. Just half a mile away you will find both the Blue Water Bay Marina, and Pettit Bay Park with public boat ramps, swim beaches, campsites, and playgrounds. Perfect for family fun or romantic getaways!

Superhost
The exterior of a green Craftsman bungalow is visible, featuring a welcoming porch with two potted plants and a flag hanging to the side. A mailbox is positioned near a neatly maintained pathway, with greenery framing the entrance.
Bungalow in Muskogee
4.82 out of 5 average rating, 272 reviews

The Mint

2 Bedroom / 3 Bed / 2 Bath Enjoy a restful stay at this restored 1940 Craftsman's Bungalow located on a quiet All American street in historic Muskogee, Oklahoma. PERFECT for Work or Leisure Layovers. You get the quiet comfort of this lovely house but mere minutes from everything urban areas have to offer. We encourage you to read our entire listing * 👉Please read : OTHER DETAILS TO NOTE*

Popular amenities for Paradise Hill vacation rentals