Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Putnam County

The house was perfect for the four of us for the weekend. It wasn’t as close to campus as we would have liked, but the layout and all the extras were perfect. We would definitely stay here again.

Great location close to our family for Thanksgiving week! Home was cozy and great for fun with the kids- ping pong and pool were a big hit along with the fire pit when we made s’mores. Fav was our surprise outdoor guest Katie! She was a sweet heart and kept us company every time we were outside. Would stay again.

Cozy little place in close proximity to the lake. Quiet and peaceful. We enjoyed our time away. Host is very responsive and helpful.

This is our second time staying here. The house is always very very clean, it’s quiet with comfortable beds, and close enough to walk to get food or to CVS if needed. Other amenities, such as Krogers grocery store or the town square are just a very short drive. We also loved going to Fern Cliff Nature preserve and DePauw Nature Preserve to walk through the woods.

Had trouble with the side door lock was not working the garage door locked but when we went somewhere had to manually shut the garage door then the lock wouldn’t open the garage door. Had to call around 9 pm to get it taken care of Maggie was very helpful all went well the rest of the stay

Very nice home. So quiet and peaceful. Slept great!

We rented Deer Creek Farmhouse & The Pond House for my son's wedding in Green Castle mid Nov. This property is so gorgeous and peaceful. Just what we were looking for. We were blessed with sunshine & some warmer weather for our stay which made it more enjoyable in November. After the wedding rehearsal & dinner in town Friday evening, our immediate family that was staying with us, enjoyed a nice fire at the fire pit. Smores of course & lots of laughs. Saturday, was the wedding, so we were gone most of the time. But it was so nice to get dressed and ready there, instead of a hotel room. Sunday, a few were able to enjoy some fishing at the pond and the zip line. What a fun time had by everyone! This was my first experience with an Airbnb. Michelle was so wonderful from the beginning of planning this trip. I highly suggest their wonderful place!

The scenery was Incredible. Peace and quiet!!

What a beautiful place! The house has clearly been lovingly restored, and it was an incredibly relaxing place to stay for a few days while I was at a conference at DePauw! The thing I loved most was the full kitchen - I did mostly frozen meals but the kitchen is truly fully equipped.