Cottage vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

My family and I stayed at Tony’s place for a long weekend and I have to say it was amazing!! First of all Tony made sure that we had proper directions to the property and how to access the house. Upon entering the house we were astounded by how lovely Tony’s lake house is and then the views of the lake were just panoramic!! We could not have found for a better place to stay! We had easy access to our own private little beach, it was literally right outside the sliding glass doors and we could sit on the patio and watch the sun both rise and set. The kitchen was fully equipped, the house was very spacious and we were excited to find a bookshelf full of childrens books which made our little one very happy. Yes there were quite a few steps to access the property but we found the journey up and down the steps very doable and the path was very well lit. It was exciting going down those steps through the wooded property and watching the lake views unfold. We would definitely return!!

Very comfortable. It shows that you get breakfast but I think that is for the bed and breakfast price. Our price was excellent for what we received.

Very nice home in an awesome location. plenty of wildlife to see. So much to do in one location. .22 Range is such a neat feature.

My husband and I came for a one night get away in the dead of winter. We chose this location because it had plenty to do without going any where. The pool table and hot tub were great. We arrived and never left the house. The house was clean and spacious, has plenty of amenities, and the host was friendly and responsive. We really enjoyed our visit. We would look forward to coming back when its warm to enjoy the view of the marina and the town of Fairport Harbor. We might even schedule a stay next winter just to get away. Thanks for offering such a great space Pepperli

Great little cabin if you want to enjoy the quiet setting and the lake

We had a wonderful stay at Sunny’s lake house. We enjoyed sitting on the deck and barbecuing. We chose this home because of the first floor bedroom and bathroom and one step to enter as my 94 year old grandmother stayed with us. Doorways were all wide enough to accommodate her rollator walker. We loved being able to cook and bake together in the well stocked kitchen. Sunny responds quickly to inquiries and provided updates. We did not use the recreation room in the basement or pool/ hot tub but can see that these would be great for other groups staying here. Lastly, mattresses were very comfortable and everything was extremely clean.

Michael’s place is beautiful. The pictures do not do the view justice. It is simply breathtaking. The house was the perfect size for our family of four. The kids loved running around in the spacious yard while we relaxed. It is on the main road (easy to get to) but feels very secluded!

Brads cottage was beautiful and perfect for a weekend at Pymatuning! The state park entrance is only 5 mins down the road from the cottage so that was perfect. The hot tub was relaxing and the backyard very private. We loved the fire pit !

We had a great time at the Lodge. Big beautiful plot of land the lodge sits on. The fire pit and pre cut wood made the evenings outside very enjoyable. We will be back!

The Knotty Pine in Edinboro, Pennsylvania was a gem in a small quiet town, that has beautiful lake Edinboro within a couple blocks walking distance. Michelle is an awesome host and very responsive to any questions especially all the wonderful attractions and restaurants in the area. Her place is extremely clean and spacious for a family or a sporting event with lots of kids and just right for a couple or even a single person who travels. I really enjoyed using the fire pit at night in the backyard and walking and biking along the lake. Im definitely going back to Michelle’s in the near future.

Beautiful lake setting even for a rainy March weekend. Did get to enjoy fire on the 1 dry evening. Seating for meals was limited but outside table would help in warmer months. Also lower level bedrooms could be warmer. Loved the decor of old school local items.

Valerie was fantastic ! Everything about this place was wonderful and we had great communication ! I will be back very soon because my stay was not long enough !

The Carriage House is one of the most peaceful places that we've ever stayed. The Rustic character and decor felt welcoming and comfy. The view of the pond in the morning while listening to the birds and drinking a cup of coffee - unbelievably Zen. We enjoyed soaking in the jacuzzi and having a good steam in the Sauna. The quietness was particularly stunning as well. We really felt like we had our own personal Spa for 5 days. I'm from the Knox area and will be staying here from now on whenever we're home for a visit. Our black lab Bella also enjoyed chasing the ball in the big field and going for a swim in the pond as well. Perfect place for a dog! Thank you Maria for sharing this delightfully beautiful place with us!

Spotless, cozy, and exactly as described. Great location, responsive host, and thoughtful touches. Highly recommend!

We love Molly’s little cottage on their wonderful farm. It is so peaceful and the surrounding area is so beautiful and private. I don’t think we’ve ever stayed in a more well equipped kitchen….anything you could possibly need is provided! The hosts are so friendly and responsive, while also completely respecting your privacy. We definitely hope to stay again in the future. Truly one of our favorite airbnbs! =)

The house was very welcoming and cozy. Very quiet area and the neighbors were really nice as well! Very safe area and very clean.

Cottage was beautiful and very clean. Location was great very close to the strip but very quiet at night.

The Sunrise Inn provided a cozy and comfortable stay where great memories were made. Due to the weather, we unfortunately did not get to make a bonfire or enjoy the beautiful front porch with views of the lake, but we did see a rainbow over the lake! The kitchen and bathroom were spotless, and the kitchen was well equipped for cooking / entertaining. We made breakfast at the cottage and enjoyed eating at the local restaurants (The Anchor, Frog Pond, and Happi Jax). Valerie was a very friendly and responsive host, and we would definitely recommend her place to future guests visiting the lake!

We had a wonderful time at the cottage! It was cozy, had a great porch and was perfect for a small group. David & Joanne were great hosts!

Beautiful private neighborhood on a road with steps down to the beach. Glorious stars at night without competition from city lights. The cottage immediately felt like home. Comfy beds and well stocked kitchen and bathrooms. 8am weekday mass closeby and lived Deb’s diner afterwards.

Their little pocket of Conneaut is perfect. It’s so private and yet close to pier, beach, paths, etc better than we actually walked around and saw all the other rental properties and this one’s space and location are the tops!

It was a great house. Plenty of room and everything you need. Great location and close to the lake. Beds were very comfortable. Lots of things to keep your kids occupied, if you have them here. We were very pleased with our stay.

Thank you very much for letting us stay at the cottage. Everything was perfect and the atmosphere was peaceful. We hope to return.

We enjoyed our stay. Cottage is beautiful! It is very close to the lake. Host is super friendly and welcoming. Cottage is well maintained and super clean! 🧼 I would definitely recommend! Thanks!