Pet-friendly vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

I love this Airbnb! Will definitely be back. The house is BEAUTIFUL and you can walk to Mill Creek Park (Lanterman’s Mill is across the street) and it’s a 0.5 mile drive to the Blind Bear, a new bar/restaurant in Youngstown that is EXCELLENT. I enjoyed myself so much I didn’t want to leave and I was on a work trip! I’ll be back

Very convenient to grocery. Very clean and comfortable.

we had a quick little visit as we drove cross country, but Sharon we excellent and the house was perfect for my family and pets. loved the little touches like a kids coloring table and water bottles in the fridge.

This home is beautiful and had everything we needed and close to all the activities we came to do. They are very responsive and helpful..thank you

Great location, inviting, and accommodating for groups with 3 bathrooms and plenty of space!

Lindsey's house was great. Just as described. She answered all of my questions before booking and during our stay. Her instructions were clear and posted so there was no question. The house is in a great location and is easy to find. It's also easy to get in and out of the neighborhood. It worked out perfect for us as we visited our daughter at Mercyhurst University (only 10 minutes from campus). Would definitely rent the house again in the future.

Quiet neighborhood, no issues with neighbors at all. No excess noise (even though off fairly busy road, never bothered us); amenities, comfort, a few lux items; Casey was very responsive (quick and helpful!) re: TV streaming questions! We loved our stay!

Eduardo's place was exactly as advertised. Eduardo himself was easily reachable and very responsive to my inquiries. I will rent this place again every time it is available when I visit Erie

A very nice clean cozy cottage. Beds are comfy, plenty pillows. Our First Airbnb with excellent cable Service. Definitely will rebook.

We had the best vacation with wonderful memories. The most important part of our vacation was having a place to enjoy with our older dog who loves to swim. This may be our last summer with him and coming to Higbys was the best decision. They directed us immediately to the swimming area for him and it was perfect. Everyone was so friendly and went out of their way. Thank you for one of the best vacations. The memories will last a lifetime!

We really enjoyed our stay here, great area great amenities, very spacious. We could not have asked for anything more from check in to check out! Thank you very very much!

The hosts were welcoming and responsive. The campground was well maintained and quiet. All of the other campers were friendly during our stay. Being so close to the creek would have made fishing or kayaking easy, but we just ran out of time! I appreciated all of the extra amenities including playground equipment, individual fire rings, a pool, swings, pavilion and bathrooms. With not a lot of choices in this area, we were happy to find this place and enjoyed our stay. P.S. we had great cellular service during our stay and were able to use our apps to watch tv and remain connected to the world.

The Carriage House is one of the most peaceful places that we've ever stayed. The Rustic character and decor felt welcoming and comfy. The view of the pond in the morning while listening to the birds and drinking a cup of coffee - unbelievably Zen. We enjoyed soaking in the jacuzzi and having a good steam in the Sauna. The quietness was particularly stunning as well. We really felt like we had our own personal Spa for 5 days. I'm from the Knox area and will be staying here from now on whenever we're home for a visit. Our black lab Bella also enjoyed chasing the ball in the big field and going for a swim in the pond as well. Perfect place for a dog! Thank you Maria for sharing this delightfully beautiful place with us!

Great house, really quiet near the woods and grocery stores aren’t too far away. The host was very communicative and helpful with our stay

We had a wonderful stay at Sunny’s lake house. We enjoyed sitting on the deck and barbecuing. We chose this home because of the first floor bedroom and bathroom and one step to enter as my 94 year old grandmother stayed with us. Doorways were all wide enough to accommodate her rollator walker. We loved being able to cook and bake together in the well stocked kitchen. Sunny responds quickly to inquiries and provided updates. We did not use the recreation room in the basement or pool/ hot tub but can see that these would be great for other groups staying here. Lastly, mattresses were very comfortable and everything was extremely clean.

Sean and Michelle communicated almost instantaneously anytime I had a question, either before and during my stay; and continuously checked in with me regarding any needs I may have had after I checked in. The location was so peaceful and I wish my visit would have been the summer to enjoy the deck and the outdoors more. I loved the lambs, chickens, and roosters on the property too!

We had a wonderful stay at the cottage! It was exactly as expected—clean, comfortable, and located on a quiet street. Perfect for both kids and dogs. We appreciated the games, Keurig, and the convenience of the washer and dryer. Everything was spotless and ready for us to use. Highly recommend!

Wonderful place! Liz was a great host! Allowed for a later checkout to accommodate my 10 month olds nap. Recommended this place to my aunt for her out of town visitors

We enjoyed our 3 night getaway! The private beach was incredible. We enjoyed a peaceful time on the lake with our two dogs. - 85 inch TV in the family room for watching football - gas grill and blackstone for the barbecue - fire pit - beach supplies including 2 kayaks and life vests - comfortable master suite with jacuzzi tub - game room with pool table So much fun and many possibilities!

The cottage is in a perfect location for family to enjoy all the activities at Edinboro lake over the 4th July. Loved the smokeless fire pit. Great front porch to gather on. Would recommend this as a great family vacation destination.

Joann (Jo Jo) is a wonderful hoast. When I contacted her in the morning prior to making one of our several day trips, about the need of a grab handle for the bathroom she had it there later on that same day when we returned. This was our 4th vacation trip to the Ashtabula / Geneva on the lake area. We've stayed at different rentals every time. This is the first time that neighbors interacted with us and made us feel welcome. We've already book this place for the same time period next year. A gentleman that lives at the end of the drive invited us to come down and experience the sunset any time we wanted. The house was just the right size for myself the wife and our fur baby. There is a fantastic gas grill there and I used it twice to grill dinner, I plan to bring a griddle plate for next year so I can cook up some magic for the neighbor's. We are so looking forward to September 2025 and another 7 relaxing days at J Jo's beach house. You won't go wrong if you book this cottage.

Terry is a great host ! The place is super clean . The lake view is awesome and relaxing . Great location! Highly recommended. We will definitely stay there again !

The house was very welcoming and cozy. Very quiet area and the neighbors were really nice as well! Very safe area and very clean.

Perfect stay for our large group with kids in varying ages. Although not fully wheelchair accessible, 1 of our guests in a wheelchair (age 14) was able to easily access amd navigate the ground level with ease (including entry, bathroom, and a bottom bunkbed) with plenty of space for all to gather together on the ground level.