Vacation rentals in Sandy Hook Bay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sandy Hook Bay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

Guest suite in Middletown Township

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

Private 2-Bedroom with large patio

This is a private 2-bedroom unit with a full kitchen, living room and bathroom. There is a large deck space for outdoor dining and grilling, as well as a 36 ft. x 18 ft. pool that guests could use in the summer months The house is located within walking distance to NY Waterway Terminal and Bayshore Waterfront Park; 10-minute drive to Keansburg Amusement Park and Waterpark; and 15-minute drive to Sandy Hook & Sea Bright beaches! We have bikes and you are welcome to use them to explore the area!

Superhost

Home in Middletown

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Leonardo Marina 2 bed pet friendly

COVID-19 ready. Allow 48h between reservations for thorough sanitation. 2 bedroom house near the Leonardo Marina. Near stores, beaches, Sandy Hook is ten minutes away. Pets are welcome at no additional fee.There is a wrap around deck with table, chairs, umbrellas and barbecue. This is a clean simple home. If you have pet allergies this house is not for you. I strongly suggest you have a car to get around, I’d be happy to drive you when available. There is a $25 fee/night for the 5th person.

Guest favourite

Home in Keansburg

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Blue Haven – Relax at the Beach!

Enjoy the best of both worlds at Blue Haven: modern amenities blended with classic character. Our home is a peaceful retreat near the beach, ideal for unwinding and recharging—but just minutes from the NYC ferry, bus, or train. Dine on the patio, or gather in the living room for unhurried conversations. Curl up with a book or enjoy a movie night on our Roku HDTV. If you need to stay connected, we offer high-speed WiFi, dedicated workstations, & charging spots throughout the house. Reg # 3498

Guest favourite

Guest suite in Sayreville

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Contemporary Private Guest Studio close to NYC

Welcome to The Urban Guest Studio, a refined and modern retreat in vibrant Sayreville, NJ. Ideally located just off the Garden State Parkway and Routes 9 & 35, it’s a 40-minute drive to NYC and 30 minutes to Newark Airport. Enjoy quick access to the South Amboy Ferry, upscale shopping, top hospitals, Rutgers University, and New Brunswick’s cultural hub. Only 7 minutes from the iconic Starland Ballroom and 20 minutes to the PNC Bank Arts. Experience comfort, style, and effortless convenience.

Guest favourite

Home in Keansburg

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Seaside Cottage 20: 4min walk to beach, waterpark

Stay in this newly renovated home at the heart of the all the fun. Lounge on the beach, stroll the pier overlooking the NY skyline, splash at the waterpark, and play at the amusement park and speedway. With the free beach just a stone's throw from your door, fun in the sun is at your finger tips. Relax with the smart TV's or board game to play together. Delight your tastebuds at one of the various restaurants all just minutes away. Finish your evening by the fire pit out out back. Permit 382

Top guest favourite

Home in Red Bank

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Spacious home in Red Bank - great for groups

Spacious property and house under a mile to downtown Red Bank and 15 minutes to Sandy Hook, Sea Bright beaches and only 15 minutes to PNC Bank Arts Center. It has 4 large bedrooms, huge dining and living areas, 84” TV, two newly renovated full bathrooms, plus an office with a pull out couch. 1 block to a top rated NJ restaurant and 2 blocks to a local bakery/deli. Big yard space and patio with outdoor dining, fire pit, and yard games. Great for large groups and families. Plenty of parking.

Guest favourite

Cottage in Middletown

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews

Cozy Cottage Retreat on North Jersey Shore

Come and relax in our shore retreat cottage with private driveway and backyard a block from the sea. We are a retreat away from the hurly-burly of connected life, but we do have WiFi Internet. We are located in a safe quiet neighborhood 5-10 minutes walk from Leonardo state marina and beach, 2 miles from Atlantic Highlands with it's bustling main street and delightful harbor where you can take the Seastreak ferry to Manhattan; 15 minutes drive to Sandy Hook and the Atlantic Shore Beaches.

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Rumson

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Navesink River House on the water. Gorgeous views.

Navesink - Sandy Hook Beach - Hartshorne Woods - Located on the river, come relax in the countryside and kayak or hike through Hartshorne Woods. Beaches are just 3-miles away. **10min to Seastreak ferry, cafes and restaurants. Equipped kitchen and outdoor patio with grill and seating to enjoy al fresco dining. 1-bedroom upstairs with king bed and 2 twin beds. Downstairs interior half bath and outdoor shower. On property carriage house offers additional accommodation for 4.

Guest favourite

Apartment in Atlantic Highlands

5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Apartment in Atlantic Highlands

Escape to this cozy, fully furnished one-bedroom apartment just 5 minutes from the beach, Sea Streak ferry to NYC, Hartshorne Woods Park, and Sandy Hook beaches. Enjoy being in the heart of charming Highlands and Atlantic Highlands, with easy access to delicious restaurants, unique shops, and scenic spots. Perfect for a relaxing getaway or a day trip to the city, this comfortable retreat offers convenience and tranquility. A great home base for exploring the area!

Top guest favourite

Home in Atlantic Highlands

5 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Atlantic Highlands Carriage House: Rooftop Jewel!

Discover our two-bedroom, one-bath carriage house in Atlantic Highlands, perched on a hill among trees, minutes from Sandy Hook Beach! Enjoy a full kitchen, inviting living area, and a rooftop patio with ocean views for sun-kissed days or starlit nights. Just half a mile from the marina and downtown, it’s perfect for families or couples seeking beach fun, waterfront dining, and small-town charm. Book now—local shops, scenic trails, and waterfront bars await.

Guest favourite

Home in Keansburg

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Luxury Beach Villa 5 Min from the Ocean

BRAND NEW BEACH HOUSE | 3BR, 2.5BA | 1 BLOCK TO THE BEACH | BIKES, BABY GEAR & MORE! Welcome to your perfect JERSEY SHORE GETAWAY! This NEWLY CONSTRUCTED 2025 modern beach home is just 5 MINUTES from KEANSBURG BEACH and a SHORT WALK to the AMUSEMENT PARK and WATERPARK—FUN FOR ALL AGES! Only a 5-MINUTE WALK TO THE BEACH, a quick drive to SANDY HOOK, or take a scenic BOAT TO MANHATTAN. Enjoy the STUNNING NYC SKYLINE everyone is coming for.

Guest favourite

Guest suite in Highlands

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

HighlandsBeachEscape, Steps to Beach/NY ferry

Private entrance guest suite overlooking lawn, Steps to bay beach. 8/10 mile to Atl. Ocean. Peaceful & centrally located to town. Walk/bike along scenic bay & ocean. Cafes, parks, dining Al fresco all walking distance. NYCferry 7min walk. Cruises/live music on beach May-Oct. 2 beach chairs, Patio,Keurig, blender, mini fridge, micro. No TV or cooking appliances. *No animals due to allergies *M-F Sept-June may be 4pm check in.