Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Shinnecock Hills

We had a wonderful stay in the Hamptons during the off-season, which is our favorite time to visit. The house was fantastic—exactly as described, and the photos matched perfectly. It was well-stocked with essentials like cookware, towels, and more. Lindsay was very responsive to the few questions I had, even though they weren’t related to the home (surfing advice). The check-in instructions Lindsay provided were clear and detailed, covering everything we needed for our stay. We highly recommend this Airbnb!

Very beautiful house by the water nice neighborhood and very clean lovely home would love to stay here again

Ashley’s place was absolutely incredible for our girls weekend in Montauk. Impeccably clean, spacious, and tastefully furnished. The hot tub was perfect after a winter hike, and the firepit was great for s’mores and stargazing at night. There was also an indoor fireplace in the living room where we had a couple of really fun movie nights. The kitchen is a dream, and very well equipped with everything you would ever need to cook a fabulous meal. The spacious open plan kitchen/dining area/living room was perfect for communal cooking and hanging out. Gets great light and such a pretty view. The bedrooms were super comfortable and the master has an amazing tub. The location was perfect. Right in town and a short walk to the beach (also walking distance to the brewery!), but also felt very private. Lastly, Ashley was an excellent host- very communicative and helpful and super sweet- she even left a treat for us in the fridge when we arrived! Will definitely be coming back to stay at

Very nice house with lots of room to relax and a well-stocked kitchen to cook. The house was clean and the beds were comfortable. The neighborhood is quiet and close to so much! When we had a question, Ellen answered with a call within minutes. She was the perfect host!

What an absolutely gorgeous home! Staying here truly felt like being in paradise. The house itself feels so inviting; it took no time at all to relax and feel at home. Everything that you could possibly need is here in the house. Michael’s attention to detail deserves praise! This home stands out from all others because of the minor details. Thank you, Mike, for giving me a safe, pristine, relaxing place to call home for a while. I look forward to staying here again!

What a lovely place! Kitchen was a pleasure to use. Location was great for wineries and Greenport restaurants/bars. Spacious.

This home is beautiful and so spacious! Proximity to East Hampton and Springs, yet very private and peaceful. Couldn’t recommend enough!

We had another great stay at Claudia's place! This was our third visit to this location, and likely not our last. Thank you!!

I really liked the place

Amazing place to stay, enjoyed my weekend stay very much!

Paris is a wonderful host. His property and cottage is a perfect retreat for two. Charming accommodations with a beautiful view and an easy walk to town. We’ll be back soon! Angelo C.

Joanne greeted us when we arrived - wanted to make sure we were comfortable. She encouraged us to contact her with any questions. The apartment was clean, well equipped and spacious. We are native Long Islanders and this location was central to the family and friends we were visiting.

Beautiful home, terrific location for our needs. The perfect neighborhood!

Lovely, clean, comfortable, well-designed space. Hosts are friendly, responsive, and respectful of guests’ privacy. Would stay again!

amazing place would recomend

Perfect space to celebrate Christmas this year. The house is private (set back from the main road) and the views were beautiful. We had a question at check-in, the property management company was quick to respond and resolve the issue. Perfect location for a home base when visiting the Long Island wineries!

Alessandro was the best host I’ve had to date. He responded almost immediately every time, was accommodating with check in and check out times. It was mid April but we wanted to use the pool. He was nice enough not to only hear the pool for us but to start heating it 1 day in advance of our stay so it was ready when we got there. The house is beautifully renovated and sparkly clean. Beds were comfortable linens were great. We brought our two young girls and he had a few toys kept away that kept them entertained. The swing set was a major draw and a huge hit with our girls. The kitchen is fantastic. So comfortable to cook and socialize around. We used the outdoor grill and the air fryer. Town was close but it was such a pleasure to cook here we just stayed in. I’d stay here again no doubt. Aside from the place being great, Having a good welcoming host really makes the experience so much better. Thank you Alessandro for an amazing stay.

It was perfect for the holidays it made everything better for me and my family

My family and i stayed at Niraj's place , we had a nice time. Niraj is a very responsive host, and the house was very beautiful and clean . i will recommend this place .

My stay was nothing short of Amazing Check-in was smooth with clear instructions and the home was beautiful as pictured,I really appreciated the hospitality the host showed me and would definitely book again! Thank you Prime Reality

Wow, this has been one of the most beautiful homes I have stayed at. Straight out of Architectural Digest indeed - Jenna has a true eye for outstanding decor! Jenna is a host to dream of! Thank you we had a beautiful weekend!