Waterfront vacation rentals in Sugarloaf Key

Key Colony Beach is truly the gem of the Florida Keys. Staying at Cindy's apartment in the Continental was the perfect fit for my husband and I. The private beach was clean, easy to access, and just steps from the accommodation. The overall vibe here was quiet and peaceful, and the apartment had all the amenities we needed for a 5-day stay. Cindy's space is very clean and well-appointed. This location is perfect for morning walks around the immaculate and safe neighborhood, or short jaunts to Key Colony Inn or Havana Jack's for dinner/drinks. Honestly now, you're already here! What's your hurry? :)

Rhonda's place is terrific! Lovely location with full water views. Pool was excellent. The home was very comfortable, clean and convenient to restaurants and stores. Would definitely rent again.

Beautiful place with a well stocked unit…close enough to all the places we wanted to visit, yet far enough away for a quiet, relaxing day. We loved the area and our stay here. Thank you, Chris.

1st time in the keys and we stayed at Ana's lovely place for 4 days and 3 nights. It was the perfect jump off place to explore the keys. When we originally pulled up I was a little nervous as the exterior of the building is a little older and I was concerned maybe I booked something that was not as advertised, but the inside was absolutely gorgeous, better than the pictures and had everything we needed for a comfortable stay. The private beach and pier made for spectacular sunrises and sunsets, the only item to note was that the unit is upstairs and you need to hand carry your luggage to the top floor, so something to be aware of.

Condo was exactly as pictured. Beautiful resort and everyone very friendly onsite. Great location and close to lots to do. Cannot wait to book again.

An easy and relaxing family trip to the Florida Keys. Central location and a well appointed comfortable apartment. We will definitely return!

We arrived early on the day of check-in, and because previous guests has left early, we were able to check in first thing in the morning! Henry happened to be in Key West, working around his property, so he very kindly gave us a full tour of the apartment, the parking area, the grounds, pool, and beach. The apartment is whimsically decorated with pastel colors to fit the Key West vibe, and has lots of cute details. Amazingly, all the small appliances, dishes, glasses, and tableware are in the pink/rose colored family. Literally every appliance is pink (Cuisenart, coffee maker, toaster, Keurig, blender, tableware, and more). It gave the place a unified cozy feel. The living room is spacious, with lots of couch room for a family to watch TV together. The kitchen is eat-in, and the bathrooms and bedrooms are super nice. We felt very at-home in Henry's place, and appreciate the details he provides about checking in, keys, garage parking, etc. We had a great time.

The location, condo, grounds, access to restaurants and proximity to our fishing destination made this stay enjoyable. At the top of our list for our next trip.

We loved our stay at Jeffery's house. It is spacious and very comfortable. My husband appreciated the proximity to the pickleball courts - we could see them from our bedroom windows- and my son enjoyed fishing off the dock. The upper suite was wonderful for privacy and quiet when the older kids stayed up later than the adults. Jeffery was super helpful and responsive. We would love to stay here again!

The outdoor space is absolutely fabulous. The heated pool was enjoyed every day. The property is on the corner of two canals that had pretty clean water. We met several manatees who graced us with their presence often. Fishing was not great during the month so our fishermen were rather disappointed. The interior was very pleasant and cooking was easy. The entire third floor is the master sitting room, bathroom and bedroom. The only drawback for me personally is that the master bathroom is an "open concept " design which left me without a sense of privacy. Isa was extremely helpful and responded quickly with our questions. Thank you Isa!

The house is beautiful and well stocked. Javier provided ample information to facilitate a smooth check in process and to help my family plan for our stay. Would 100% recommend this listing to a friend!

Had an amazing stay at this house with my husband and 4 small kids. The house was spacious and clean, with lots of natural light at soon as the sun came up. The pool was so warm and had a large shallow area that was perfect for our 3 year old. Naomi was a wonderful communicator. It was so sad to have to leave.. Would definitely recommend staying here.

Our first stay at this property was truly unforgettable, and we can't wait to return! Francisco is an outstanding host, always quick to respond and attentive to every detail. The house exceeded our expectations—it was spotless, fully equipped, and conveniently located near stores and restaurants. The outdoor area was a peaceful and inviting space, thoughtfully designed with a refrigerator, sink, hot tub, gas fire pit, and ceiling fans to keep you comfortable. The soft lighting added a warm and welcoming ambiance, perfect for evening gatherings or simply relaxing under the stars. We especially loved the canal, which was incredibly easy to navigate and provided quick access to the ocean—a paradise for fishing enthusiasts! We even caught fish right in the canal, but the absolute highlight was spotting manatees from the dock. If you're looking for the perfect getaway, look no further. Book your stay with Francisco—you won’t regret it

Had a wonderful, peaceful stay. We fished off the dock area, enjoyed time at the cabana, walked every morning enjoying the views and participated in the sunset community almost every night at the park! Great vacation for our multigenerational needs!

We had an amazing week stay at this property. It was spotless with too of the line amenities. The street is very quiet with little to no traffic located at a dead end canal street. Bonus that we were able to dock our boat and it was pet friendly. The kitchen was fully stocked and we were very comfortable. We would definitely stay here again! This place is beautiful and exactly what we wanted for our week’s stay in Marathon.

Great Choice in Key Colony!! We were two couples and everyone enjoyed the stay - place was immaculate, eating outside looking at the canal, watching the birds/pelicans. We did have a manatee visit one day as well. Easy drive over to Sombrero beach and many very nice restaurants around. Having access to the Cabana club and the pool was an added benefit/interest. The place does have two bathrooms which I wasn't sure of when renting. Jorge was very nice.

Great space with everything you need. Patio is a perfect place to relax. The house is well stocked. Plenty of room for a group. Access to hotel pools/restaurant with transportation into town if you need it. Great host communication. All you could want!

The condo was well equipped and in a quiet spot. We loved the beach and didn’t have problems finding chairs. It’s not a huge beach so it wasn’t noisy or crowded. The pool is also very nice! There are beach towels, rafts and sand toys in the unit which was great. There is an area under the building with ping pong, a mini pool table and other games too. We have older kids but would’ve loved to have found this place when they were little. It’s perfect for young families with the pool and small beach. We definitely had a chance to unwind during our stay. Desy was super responsive to my questions and messages.

Sandra’s place was beautiful and she was a wonderful host. She was proactive in giving us all the information we needed to settle in AND also providing wonderful recommendations to restaurants around the area (three of which we tried and thoroughly enjoyed). Very responsive to any questions we had regarding locations of certain items or locations. The place itself was very cozy and homey. Felt very comfortable relaxing there in such a serene environment. Will gladly take an opportunity to stay here again.

Expect a nice, relaxing time. Beautiful scenery and lots to do in Marathon Key.

The unit is just like the photos and was very comfortable! John was helpful and helped make for an enjoyable stay! Would happily stay here again

Michelle was great! Very responsive and understanding when we had to make a last minute trip change. Unit was clean, bright and had a nice view. It’s a nice location between Key Largo and Islamorada making it convenient to explore both. We didn’t use any of the resort’s amenities, but there was an influx of seaweed at the small beach. Just one downside of this time of years in the Keys. But the pool looked great!

We had a wonderful stay! We loved spending time at the pool and on the pickleball courts. Definitely a great place for families!

We loved our stay at Nicole’s place. It was well stocked, super clean, and the decore was lovely. This is second time at Ocean Pointe. We enjoyed being in building 5 and the larger corner unit.