Restaurant
Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grille Sister Bay
31 locals recommend,
Tips from locals
Erin And John
November 22, 2021
We love Wild Tomato Pizza anywhere, but the Sister Bay location is our favorite! Situated right on the water, it offers both indoor and outdoor seating. Kids (and parents!) will enjoy the park and beach right next to the restaurant. It's less than 1 mile from The Sister Bay Haus and 4 miles from The Ephraim House! Local tip: Arrive early to snag a spot on the patio and enjoy the beautiful sunset views over the bay while you dine!
We love Wild Tomato Pizza anywhere, but the Sister Bay location is our favorite! Situated right on the water, it offers both indoor and outdoor seating. Kids (and parents!) will enjoy the park and beach right next to the restaurant. It's less than 1 mile from The Sister Bay Haus and 4 miles from The…
Kimberly
April 30, 2019
If you can't find a pizza that pleases everyone here, it doesn't exist.
Robert
July 9, 2017
The best pizzas on the peninsula.
Greg & Dan
January 10, 2017
Good wood fired Pizza
Diane
August 14, 2022
Great pizza, but don't miss out on the Door County spinach salad to go with it! Two locations, Sister Bay and Fish Creek, outside seating at both locations. The one in Sister is close to nice playground and park on the water.
Locals also recommend
Location
10677 N Bay Shore Dr
Sister Bay, WI