Skip to content
Food

Magic Fountain

8 locals recommend ·

Tips from locals

Hillary
Hillary
May 18, 2018
The ice cream flavors are inventive, and unexpected. It's just delicious and worth the 20 minute drive. Expect long lines.
Rich
Rich
April 10, 2018
Old school handmade ice cream counter serving also sorbets and yogurts. There is usually a line down the block from May through September
Ruchika
Ruchika
June 15, 2016
This place is a must go! Their homemade ice cream comes in custom and seasonal flavors that you will love. Plus its open late!
Alexis
Alexis
November 2, 2015
Best ice cream on the North Fork with creative flavors and fun atmosphere!
Jen
Jen
August 22, 2015
Best ice cream you will ever eat...ever. Be prepared to wait in line but it's worth it.

Locals also recommend

Grocery or Supermarket
“The grocery store, liquor store, Chinese take out, 7-11 and movie theater are located in this shopping complex. Many other local business on this road as well.”
  • 4 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Awesome Italian food. Small and noisy; you need a reservation. Simply delicious and worth the 25 minute trip to Jamesport.”
  • 12 locals recommend
Bakery
“Pastry shop located inside a house. Know for its Apple strudel and crumb cake”
  • 4 locals recommend
Italian Restaurant
“Nice bar area and quaint restaurant. Good thin crust pizzas and full course meals. Outdoor dining also.”
  • 5 locals recommend
Winery
“Gotta love champagne, and theirs is top notch! Large indoor and outdoor space, good for groups!”
  • 17 locals recommend
Location
9825 Main Road
Mattituck, New York 11952
Phone+1 631-298-4908
Hours of Operation statusOpen · Closes 10:00 PM