Vacation rentals with beach access in Treasure Cay

We've just returned from our stay at Wendell's unit at Treasure Cay Beach villas, and had a great time. Proximity to the beach, pool, cafe and convenience store were awesome. The unit was clean and well-stocked, perfect for the two of us. We ate at Treasure Sands Club and Sunset Pizza, both were great. We'll be back!

Great host, and a great place to stay, conveniently located in the center of the island. Highly recommend!

John's communicated well and his condo was a great fit for our family vacation. We hope to return soon.

Our stay at Molly’s place was more than we could ask for. Great location close to Bahama Beach Club and the access to the boat slip was great. The entire condo was extremely clean and beds were very comfortable. Can’t beat the view from the balcony. Molly was super accommodating and quick to respond. Can’t recommend this place enough. We will definitely be back!

We were so happy with our stay, we wish we stayed longer. The home was clean and spacious. We were able to check in early and explore. We found a great restaurant close by and were able to find snacks and water at the market. It was spotless and the AC was a gift. The beds were so comfortable. We were so happy after long flights. It was a little far from stores so having a car would help. We would definitely stay again. Thank you so much for being so responsive and helpful. We enjoyed our stay!!

Fantastic stay at this charming island getaway. Would definitely be back. Thank you Neal & Rachael. 🙏

We had so much fun staying the week at the condo! It was so peaceful and the dock was awesome to have with a boat. If we had any questions, Calvin was very helpful. The best time!

This is an amazing place! Great lay out, plenty of room for our family of five. Well-equipped kitchen super easy to cook at home. The back balcony offers a wonderful view of the canal. Easy walking distance to incredible beaches. Enjoyed dinner at the Beach Club and breakfast at Florence's. We loved our stay in Treasure Cay!

Very memorable place. Great living space on the island. Hi tech gadgets, soft warm beds, relaxing showers! Wonderful kitchen, I cooked 3 times, and Alexa! Good stuff 👍🏾

Christy was an amazing host and was very responsive to communications. The property was hygienic, the amenities abundant, and in pristine condition. If you're looking for some time in paradise, the area is amazing and will fulfill your needs.

Beautiful decor and fully stocked Kitchen all new appliances Awesome washer and dryer on demand gas water heater and brand new Generator when power goes out will definitely rent again

Great unit with nice furnishings and great view of the pool. Beautiful beach. Very comfortable place to stay!

Leslie met us at the ferry and she went above and beyond helping us settle in and enjoy our Green Turtle stay. She rescued us when our golf cart broke down. She was always there when we needed her. Leslie is a gem!!

We packed a lot of family into this house, and it worked. We had a great time. The sunroom provides a quiet escape from the great room. The guest house out back became the spot for nappers in the afternoon. The walk to Ocean Beach was so easy that the big kids were comfortable going back and forth solo within a day or two (to go between family at the house and on the beach). The kitchen worked well for us. The basic dry goods (spices, oil) helped us throw together dinner for a hungry crowd within minutes of arriving. Overall, GTC was chill and lovely, and this house was the perfect home for our visit. Billy and Erin were friendly and helpful, making it that much better throughout.

Absolutely perfect location in New Plymouth! Beautiful views and much to do within walking distance! Will definitely stay here again!

Paul’s Airbnb was absolutely fantastic! The place was spotless, beautifully maintained, and located in a stunning beachside setting. The comfort of the home made it easy to relax and unwind after a long day on the island. Paul was an exceptional host—proactive, thoughtful, and incredibly helpful. From the moment we booked, he provided great recommendations for food, groceries, transportation rentals, and ferry options, ensuring we had everything we needed for a seamless stay. His hospitality truly made a difference, and we couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Highly recommend staying here—thank you, Paul, for making our trip so enjoyable!

Awesome place to stay!! Paul was very responsive. Great little spot. Beautiful beach just steps from the front door!! Definitely would recommend and will be back.

Heather was a terrific host, very helpful and accommodating to our needs. it was a great place to stay with an amazing view and lots of amenities.

The environment was safe and clean. The amenities provided were helpful to creating a pleasant stay. We enjoyed it and we would stay again.

It couldn’t have been more perfect! Bahama Beach Club is beautiful and the location of the condo on the property is fantastic! The condo was like brand new with the finest of furnishings. Matthew called me ahead of my stay to answer my questions and share island recommendations which was incredibly kind and helpful. 100% would stay again and would recommend to others!

My stay at this Airbnb was fantastic! The condo was clean, cozy and beautifully decorated. The Ed and his wife were extremely accommodating and provided great recommendations for local attractions and restaurants. The location was perfect, close to many shops and cafes. I had a wonderful experience and would highly recommend this Airbnb to anyone visiting the Marsh Harbor, Abaco Bahamas area.

Alan’s condo is very convenient and the dock was right outside the door, with dock lines available for use. Everything in the unit was fresh and new. I would highly recommend, especially if you come by boat, or plan to rent a boat from Treasure Boat Rentals.

The pictures do not do this place justice with fantasic views views from any window! Well furnished and very comfortable. The staff were all very friendly and accommodating. Would highly recommend for a nice relaxing beach vacation stay!