Vacation rentals in Tuckernuck Island

South of Town Surf Shack. Best Deal on Island.

Redecorated for summer 2025 with new linens and Casper beds! While the exterior is the picture perfect Nantucket cottage home surrounded by hydrangeas, you will be surprised by the casual, surf-vibe of the decor. Enjoy the best of Nantucket by walking to Town (under 1 mi) at this prime location property. The lot has privacy hedges and borders conservation land. This property has a separate living area home to two of the homeowner's employees. No parties, dinner parties, or events are allowed.

Beachfront Cottage

This 2-bedroom New Seabury beachfront cottage overlooks the Nantucket Sound which offers breathtaking views & a spacious patio perfect for morning coffee, barbecues, and stargazing. It is only a few steps to the private beach and a short walk to Popponesset Marketplace, the best place to grab food & drinks while enjoying live music & mini golf - quintessential Cape Cod summer living! *Popponesset Marketplace (10min walk) is closed during the off season but Mashpee Commons(10min drive) is open*

Lovely 2 BR Oak Bluffs Apartment

This 100% private apartment is on the first floor of a shared house where owners and their son live upstairs. There are no shared spaces. You have a private entrance and parking. The living room, bedrooms, bathroom, and kitchenette are bright and clean. It is exactly 1 mile from Oak Bluffs Center, a half mile from The Cottages and Farm Neck Golf Course, and a block from Tradewinds walking trails. Across the street is the bike path, & the bus stop is on the corner for easy island transportation!

Spectacular beach & pool combo; beautiful sunsets!

Close to airport, you’ll love backyard beach, water view, pool/grass yard, ambiance and outdoors space. Beach & Pool (POOL HEAT STARTS SUMMER, ENDS 9/1) is a hard to find combination!! Location is private, yet it's close to the 3 largest towns on Martha's Vineyard. Great for couples, families (with kids), and big groups. Enjoy dinner with the indoor/outdoor Sonos music system during a beautiful sunset! NOTE; Rate increase in high season, pool/spa is a combined unit & ONLY heated in summer!

Edgartown Designer Retreat With Pool & Hot Tub

Located in Katama, this 3,000-square-foot home has undergone a complete renovation, and offers privacy and easy access via bike path to downtown Edgartown and South Beach. Everything is brand new. There is a salt water heated pool & hot tub! Highlights include 8 inch wide white oak flooring, a custom marble vanity, ultra thick quartz countertops, custom lighting, high end art throughout, all new high end appliances and designer furniture, outdoor shower, gym, and 4 bedrooms / 3.5 bathrooms.

Cuddle In Cottage near Surfside Beach

This charming Nantucket chic decorated cottage is your ideal vacation spot. Perfect for 2 and a max of 4 people. The cottage is less than a mile from Surfside Beach, voted the islands favorite, and across the street from a bike path offering biking to the beach or town a safe and easy option. The cottage boasts privacy with fully stocked kitchen, in and out door shower, radiant heat, AC unit in the bedroom, 2 flat screen TV's, top drawer linens, towels, beach chairs and an out door grill.

Modern Luxury Apt. | 7 min from Commons

This luxury 1Br + 1bth apartment is the perfect getaway. - 650 square feet, newly renovated - 15 Minutes from Old Silver Beach, South Cape Beach, and Falmouth Heights beaches - Steps from 1,700 acres of walking trails (Crane Wildlife) - 7 minutes to Mashpee Commons (shops and restaurants) - 15 minutes to Main Street Falmouth - 13 minutes to Ferry for Marthas Vineyard - 85” smart TV - 5 minutes to Shining Sea Bike Trail - Coffee/Espresso Machine - 2 minutes from Paul Harney Golf Course

Beautiful Custom Nantucket Home

Our custom built home is located on a private, natural and secluded location in the beautiful Fishers Landing neighborhood in Madaket. It is perfect for a family of 4. The home is close to beaches, crabbing, bike paths and Madaket Millies. We have a large private landscaped yard for the kids to play in. We also have a great deck in the back of the house for outdoor dinners, an outdoor shower with and BBQ area. It's a great house in a great spot and we have many happy repeat guests.

Martha's Vineyard Getaway Cottage

Contemporary cottage on quiet, private, wooded lot. Pristine, bright & comfortably furnished. Open living area, hardwood floors, vaulted ceilings, indoor/outdoor fireplaces, well appointed kitchen, washer/dryer, cable/internet/phone with unlimited national calling, SmartTV with Netflix and additional internet streaming services. Walk or bike to beaches and trails, 5 minute drive from downtown shops and restaurants. Property abuts West Chop Woods with lovely, quiet walking trails.

Beachfront Cottage + Studio w. Town Access

Welcome to The Rudder Cottage! Fully renovated 1930's cottage on an ocean front compound, with a picturesque porch overlooking the outer harbor, full basement with washer/dryer and central air. An additional detached studio provides a third bedroom/work space. Stunning views of the Edgartown lighthouse and Cape Poge. Access to private beach. Access town with just a 10 minute walk (or 1 minute drive) to the Chappaquiddick Ferry, and be in downtown Edgartown in 15 minutes or less!

Spouter Cottage

A unique upside down two bedroom cottage with a deck and a view of the Harbor. A curated space with antique beams, handcrafted doors, flooring and cabinetry, antiques and fine art. It all lends a vintage feel to an up to date with all the amenities home. There is a private small side yard and garden with outdoor grill and seating. This is not a party house, it’s a sensitive house, I live right on the property, adjacent to the cottage, you have full privacy but no shenanigans.

Madaket Bright and Airy Guest Cottage

Escape to this charming guest cottage in Madaket, just a short walk from Madaket Beach, known for its stunning sunsets. This peaceful retreat offers a cozy, light-filled space with a well-equipped kitchen and comfortable sleeping arrangements. Enjoy mornings on the private patio, bike scenic paths, or dine at Millie’s. Easily explore Nantucket’s shops, restaurants, and history. End your day with a breathtaking sunset—your perfect island getaway awaits!