Monthly Rentals in Bakers Bay

We had an unforgettable stay at this beautiful property near Leverick Bay. The location is stunning—perched above the bay with sweeping views that truly have to be seen in person to be believed. It felt peaceful and private, yet still close to everything we needed. Emily was a fantastic host—welcoming, attentive, and incredibly responsive throughout our stay. The house is thoughtfully designed with an open layout and modern finishes. We especially appreciated the well-equipped kitchen, which made it easy to prepare some great meals with ingredients from the Chef’s Pantry just down the hill.

Ajit was very nice and generous with his communication. We had some problems with connections and confusion finding our way there from St. Thomas and Ajit was in communication with me the whole time, trying to help me figure out my way. We arrived to meet the wonderful Sonny, one of our highlights was meeting him and getting to know him a little. The views, sunsets, moon-rise, pool, sea, friendly rooster, snorkeling on the beach just below the property, amenities, everything was great. I did not realize the property is shared so closely with two other units, but we were lucky to not have a another guest below us, and never saw the other people in the detached unit below as theirs was more private and they had their own pool. Definitely recommend staying in the pool past 3:00 to avoid the no-see-ums! A highlight of our trip was going to The Baths. A must! Walked up the hill to the Sugarcane restaurant three times! Loved the view from Hog Heaven. The locals were so nice! Thank you!

Loved this place! Wonderful villa with fabulous views and easy walk to secluded beach. Big deck with sunset views, well equipped kitchen, comfortable living area. The layout has a very private master suite off to one side, and the two other bedrooms on the other end. 5 min walk to beach, where we were the only ones (late April so shoulder season). A good restaurant with pool 5 min walk away. Very thoughtful and communicative host. What’s not to like? Hope to come back!

We had such a great time at Cooten House! The view is absolutely beautiful and we soaked up every moment. The hot tub is a wonderful bonus! The area is definitely tricky to drive around as it has very steep hills. We enjoyed Josia’s Beach where we rented boogie boards and had a delicious dinner at The Dove restaurant. I would recommend cooking meals at the house so you can enjoy the view as much as possible. Thank you for your hospitality, Jeremy!