Monthly Rentals in Fire Islands

A nice place for 2 people. A quiet basement apartment in a good location, close to shopping, museums, and the shore.

Wally’s place is advertised. More an old school beach house than a luxury stay. A bit no frills, but it certainly had what our group needed, and the location more than makes up for it. The design is a bit unorthodox (kitchen/living room separate from the rest of the house), but worked for us. Make sure you watch the video tour, as it provides a more accurate view of the house than the photos. ACs functioned, grill heated up, speaker connected, and always enjoy an outdoor shower. Easy 5 min walk from the ferry (less if you’re not carrying bags) and even shorter walk to the beach. Really enjoyed Kismet, just a quiet, friendly neighborhood and a nice break from real life. Wally was very responsive, making sure to touch base before check-in and check-out, and we were able to leave our bags on the porch after checkout to get some extra time on the beach, which we certainly appreciated.

This place was amazing! so nice and cozy. it was very peaceful as well. there are a good amount of places to eat at or order from at walking distance. the neighborhood is very quiet. the house itself is very clean and elizabeth is super friendly and welcoming!

The place was exactly like the photos, and the host was incredibly kind and responsive. When I caught a cold, they were so thoughtful and even brought me some medicine. I also loved hearing the occasional baby sounds—it made me happy. I truly wish the host and their family all the best! The train station is about a 35-minute walk or a $10 Uber ride away. There’s a bus to the station, but the nearest bus stop is a 20-minute walk. The closest Starbucks is also about a 20-minute walk, but I actually enjoyed walking there often. The neighborhood is very quiet and friendly.