Monthly Rentals in Fishers Island

We loved visiting the Beach Cottage on Benson! Amy and Jay were perfect hosts and made us feel welcome. The movie theater and back deck were very cool and the cottage was clean and included everything you will need.

The house was beautiful, we loved staying there so much! The wallpaper in the bathroom was gorgeous, along with all the other decor/furniture in the home. The neighborhood was beautiful and the hosts gave great instructions for everything you could need. We had a great time staying here and I would recommend it to anyone finding somewhere to stay in the area. It was perfect!

Would definitely stay again! Very responsive hosts. Very, very clean place and smelled so good the minute we walked in. Very convenient location to all the activities we had planned.

Stayed here for a little mini vacation with my kids! We loved it.