Beachfront vacation rentals in Long Island

Place was great for the value, turtle cove is gorgeous, Atil was a great host. Make sure you touch base with him before the day you get there. I forgot to do this and had some complications finding the right place.

We stayed here for our anniversary trip and everything was awesome. Nice cool sea breeze. Beautiful sunrise and moon rise view. Quiet. Peaceful. Cozy. Check in n out was a breeze. They even decorated the place for valentines. We loved it.

What a great place to stay right in the heart of Salt Pond and the fact that the ferry from Georgetown arrives right at the resort's dock is a plus! The staff are so friendly and accomodating, I can't wait to stay here again!

Goodness, this place is a gem. And Michelle is an absolutely gorgeous host. Nothing is too much trouble and she is so thoughtful about the detail and hospitality. Pristine linens, stylish cottages (I stated at 2) very very comfortable beds and pillows. I felt so very much at home and thankful for all the brilliant introductions and recommendations. The restaurant next door is super fun and the food delicious - loved the shrimp salad. Thank you to Marvin too for the best boat trip of my life (kindly arranged by our host). Thanks for the endless trouble to make me comfortable and have a very happy time at Tiny’s. Only downside is that leaving an honest and good review will mean you might get more booked up!

Tiny’s Lime Cottage is a real gem in so many ways! We stayed here for ten days and have already booked for next year and that says it all. The cottage is extremely comfy and very nicely designed and decorated. We also enjoyed having the beach bar on the property for those evenings when we wanted to stay in after a day of adventure. Michelle goes out of her way to make your stay comfortable and memorable. We were especially grateful for the beach chairs and the sun umbrella which was provided. It meant we were able to make our own shade on the secluded beaches we discovered during our stay. Michelle is also happy to give tips for excursions and anything else you might want to do. In other words, this is the place to stay on Long Island!! Book and you won’t regret it 😊.

Stay was great and staff were very helpful, an awesome base for us to explore Long Island from.

This is a beautiful and private location. We very much enjoyed each morning with mimosas on the small table overlooking the beach. House was well stocked, there were things either left by other guests or the owners keep their own things here, not sure which one. Lounge chairs were comfortable. A grill but it did show up mid trip, that will be a nice amenity for future guests. Food at nearby Harbor Breeze Villas was very good. Be aware of bug bites on the island. This was our third trip & the most I had ever been affected by them, having to visit Urgent Care as soon as I got home. Do some research and see how you can protect yourself. The only downside of this property for us was the amount of cameras outside that faced the patio doors. We felt like it slightly invaded our privacy. I completely understand owners of rental properties needing to keep an eye on their home, but out of respect for guests with good reviews I feel the cameras could be turned off during their stay.

Stunning location, great people - we ended up staying in the Flamingo house which was amazing. Loved the natural pools and the resort pools. Beach was gorgeous. Views hard to believe. Bar food was great and our waitress Shanelle was awesome. Love Beach was just down the road and very nice also. Snorkeled at the rock pools. Beds are older and decor is dated however space and decks were very nice. Resort food was good however a bit pricey for our budget, found some great takeaways just down the road. Met some really great people - had fun at the resort rum punch party. Drove to the Stella Maris lot at the cape (they also provide a shuttle), cabanas were taken up but the most beautiful beach I’ve ever seen! Only negative is I didn’t notice until we arrived that power was extra on top of the nightly price (fine print).

Flamingo house at Stella Maris was a perfect place for our family of 10. The house has a a short trail to the ocean and another to the ocean side bar/pool. The food at the bar and upper restaurant was fantastic. The service at Stella Maris is above standards. The cleaning staff was so nice and did more than expected. A wonderful man from maintenance changed our flat tire.. like I said "above and beyond." Jill is wonderful and so responsive with any request. Flamingo is not fancy but so perfect for our crew. Thanks Stella Maris staff for a wonderful stay.

We had a great stay at Rainbow house. Bedroom set ups were perfect for our guests. Great location at Stella Maris, close to the airport and we were able to explore the island.

Great location within the Stella Maris Resort area, very on theme gecko house. Everything is as in the photos and the oceanfront view is just as great as the hosts.

Our stay at Ryan’s Ocean View met every expectation we had of a tropical reprieve from a cold Maine winter. The house is spectacular with incredible views of the ocean and beach. We regularly walked and explored the beach on our way to a swim. The design of the house is perfect for 4 people to share but has enough spaces for anyone looking for solitude. We took full advantage of the wraparound porch and the hot tub. Long Island is a gem. We explored many back roads and were almost always rewarded with incredible endless beaches with not a human in sight! We had multiple snorkeling experiences which is always magical, Dean’s Blue Hole, Compass Rose and Columbus Point. We visited Hamilton Cave and had a lovely and informative tour from Mr Cartwright and his wife, visited the northern end of the island and the southern end too. The host, Bill, was easygoing and responsive and pleasure to work with.

The Communication was super easy and welcoming. This House truly is a pearl at the caribbean ocean. First this house is definetly filled with love. It became a home for us. We are humble and glad to be able to visit many countries, continents and beaches. This leads to secondly. This Beach within two minutes walking distance is world class and breathtaking. Words cant describe how beautiful it is. Thirdly: Jerry the cat enlarged our homely feeling. What a beautiful personality. You can do groceries nearby. Kenny from Eagles nestings serves awesome waffles for breakfast and/ or takes you snorkeling. A rental car is a must have on Long Island. The Island Itself is very laid back and local and yes people make the difference. Everybody, sincerly everybody we met was nice, friendly and welcoming. We look forward coming back to this beautiful Island and enjoying this Air BnB which for us has a die class of its own. Thank you very much.

We love Long Island and the Fox 2 house in Stella Mari’s was a great home base for us! Everything was exactly as described and we appreciated the beach towels and chairs. A little cooler would be a nice addition! Such a beautiful island with such happy and friendly residents. Hope to return and would rent this house again!

Centrally located to both the north and south ends of the island. Close to the primary gas station and food store. Great view of both the Atlantic and Caribbean sea.

Robin is super helpful and the place was perfect for our stay. The views are amazing. The snorkeling is challenging with some of the tides out front, but if you time it right, well worth the effort! Would definitely stay here again.

My husband and I spent 2 weeks at Heavenly Oasis, and could not have felt more lucky to have chosen this place to spend our time in while exploring Long Island. The home itself had all the amenities and comforts you could hope for, and the beach was truly spectacular - one of the best we found on the entire island. Nerissa who greeted us at the home was very gracious and helpful. Location wise - it was very convenient to both north and south sides or the island, and near many restaurants and a big grocery store. Definitely an amazing spot!

We had an unforgettable trip! The place was perfect for our family of 6! Tiny’s hurricane hole had good food and great atmosphere. The grocery store had everything we needed. (Tip: bring some grocery bags). We went deep sea fishing, reef fishing, and on an eco tour with Marvin from big v adventures! Thank for all the tips and great communication!