Vacation rentals with beach access in Pymatuning Reservoir

The airbnb was clean and beautiful. It looked exactly like the photos and had a ton of space. The co-host Will was always reachable and responded timely with questions, etc.

We were looking for a peaceful weekend getaway and that is what we got! The place was clean and felt like home. Had a great view of the lake and sunset. Would definitely recommend!

This is my second stay at Bryan’s rental and it was just as good as the first time. It’s a great location - close to Ashtabula Harbor and Conneaut Township Park. Easy to find, quiet location, but close to some local restaurants.

great spot to stay, great hosts.

Here on an emergency business trip, this cozy apartment was exactly what we needed. Facing the bay, and on a quiet street, we could easily relax when the time came. It is a well-furnished apartment with heavy doors and antique hardware. A classy and warm European-style kitchen with separate laundry areas for both floors, and really comfortable furniture, made it feel like we left the cold windy city every time we walked through the door. It's stocked with teas, italian syrups and coffee, among other spices. Topped off with a gas range and cozy artwork. It has a fully stocked kitchen with plenty of nice dishes and high-end cooking knives. It has nice hardwood floors and tiles. There is a lot of storage for clothes and luggage. We will definitely try to book here first the next time we come up! Thanks Anastacia!

3rd time staying at this location for a girls weekend away and it's always been lovely! House is always super clean, beds and furniture are comfortable and you can't beat hearing and seeing the lake from the 2 porches! Will definitely return and highly recommend!

This is a beautiful, cozy, corky old town, Lake Milton getaway. I felt right at home. It is a friendly, peaceful area that I recommend to friends and family. The host, Sandy, was quick to respond and helpful with any questions and recommendations for local events in the area. Thank you for making it an overall wonderful place to stay!

This was my third time staying at Cheryl’s Airbnb—if that’s any indication of how much I love it! It’s truly one of the warmest, most inviting places I’ve stayed. Tucked in a quiet neighborhood with shops and restaurants nearby (including a great bagel shop within walking distance), it’s both convenient and peaceful. The beds are super cozy, the home is spotless, and the bathroom is warm with great ventilation. The kitchen has everything you need—from coffee to cooking utensils—and the living room is full of thoughtful touches like throw blankets and small amenities that show how much care Cheryl puts into the space. The lake is just a short walk away and stunning in every season. Cheryl is kind, quick to respond, and genuinely welcoming. I’ll absolutely be back again!

What a wonderful stay at the Little Clubhouse! We had everything that we needed and it was a perfect location for us and our large dog. We hope to come back and highly recommend!

Bill is the super host of super hosts. Despite some trying circumstances for each of us, he was the epitome of grace, kindness, friendliness, and caring. He really makes me feel like family. Me and my dogs. I felt so welcome in such an amazing house. Bill thank you as always.

Wendy's Lakehouse was exactly what my husband and I needed for our mini-retreat after our daughter's wedding. We were mentally, physically, and emotionally exhausted when we arrived; but after a couple of days of complete quiet and privacy in the house, walking and laying on the private beach, listening to the water, watching the sunsets, and basking in the fresh Lake Erie breezes: we felt restored and refreshed. The only thing that disappointed us was that we couldn't stay longer... life rolls on! 😅 Within hours of our arrival we were making plans to return- next time with our 4 sons- as soon as possible! We even were dreaming about bringing future grandkids in years to come! 🥰 Thank you, Wendy, for providing this peaceful retreat!

Mark is very responsive to the texts and any questions about the local area. He is very friendly and laid back. Off the main road, the lake scenes from front balcony are super nice. There is a local dock for fishing, swimming, or launching a canoe. Some good restaurants and a meat-seafood market are nearby for grilling. He supplies everything, so just bring the family or friends to start your relaxing stay. The house was clean and well stocked. This was our second stay.

this was a peaceful home. Mary was so responsive and professional. I would definitely recommend staying here.

Adorable home in a great location ! Within walking distance to Walnut Beach and local restaurants and shops. No complaints here and plan to stay again in future trips made to Ashtabula !

Nice place but it is older house, communication with owner was great.

We spent a relaxing and beautiful weekend on the shore of Lake Erie! The balcony was the perfect place to meet with God and enjoy your morning coffee watching the sun rise and listening to the waves crash on the beach. This condo is conveniently located on the first floor and had everything we needed for our stay. This was our 2nd visit to this complex and we will definitely be back soon!

We were celebrating my wife’s birthday. She loves Lake Erie so I was looking for a place close to the lake. You can’t get much closer to the Lake than this place. We really enjoyed our stay.

My wife and I recently celebrated our 21st wedding anniversary, and it was truly a memorable occasion. The location was absolutely stunning! Each morning and evening, we were captivated by the breathtaking views of Lake Erie, with the sun casting a golden glow on the water as it rose and set. We spent our days lounging by the inviting heated swimming pool, relishing the warmth even during the cooler hours. The convenience of being close to delightful restaurants added to the experience, allowing us to indulge in a variety of culinary delights. In the evenings, we would unwind by curling up together and watching our favorite shows, easily casting them to the smart TV in our cozy bedroom. Overall, our time there was incredible, and I wholeheartedly recommend this enchanting place for anyone looking to create unforgettable memories.

Great location. Very close to the water. Very affordable rates. There are some businesses close by that add some outside noise, but we expected that being right in town.

The condo was very nice. It's in a great location easy to walk to the strip or the walking trail at the lodge. The kitchen had everything that you would need to cook. I loved the directors chairs that was on the porch and it was a beautiful view of the lake.

Shells on the Beach was perfect for a long weekend away. The unit itself is pristine and looks exactly like the photos. We loved the balcony with view of Lake Erie and hearing the sound of the waves in the living room. We were there in the winter so much of Geneva-on-the-lake was closed, but the wineries were all open and within a 15-20 minute drive. The amenities were great. There were copious amounts of towels & linens, coffee, tea, creamer, laundry & dish soaps. Although we never cooked, there seemed to be every appliance you’d need to cook and feel right at home. Highly recommend!

We had an incredible stay at this newly updated condo in downtown Conneaut Lake! The space was stylish, clean, and thoughtfully furnished, making it the perfect place to relax. The lake views from the deck were absolutely stunning—a great way to start and end the day. The location couldn’t be better. We opened the window to Rising River Brewery and could smell bacon every morning while on the outside deck from the Lake Dinner below. The spacious layout, comfortable king bed, and 2 Queens, which was prefect for our little family. If you're looking for a peaceful yet conveniently located getaway, this is the perfect spot. Highly recommend, and we would definitely stay again! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

We really enjoyed our stay. The condo was very clean and well kept with beautiful lake views. The beds were very comfortable and the place had everything we needed. Scot was very responsive and accommodating. We will definitely be back again next year!