Vacation rentals in Windermere Island

This charming cottage in Rainbow Bay, Eleuthera, is the perfect island retreat! Nestled in a peaceful setting with breathtaking ocean views, it offers a cozy and well-appointed space for relaxation. The location is very nice, just minutes from beautiful Rainbow Bay Beach and local dining spots. Toni and Alex were quick to reply to any of our messages leading up to the stay and their property manager was very kind when we messaged her during our stay as well.

Perfect Stay in a gorgeous well-appointed home. Stunning views, Bright open space with everything we needed for our stay. Comfy beds and couch, lots of outdoor space for relaxing or dining. Communication was great and I've already booked my trip back!

The Sea Spray Cottage is the perfect getaway. If you’re just trying to relax and look out over the water listening to the sounds of the waves, then this is the place for you. Absolutely stunning views. Wonderful hosts. And the surrounding neighborhood is full of friendly people

Our family of 4 had an amazing stay at Rainbow Charm. Our 2 teenagers loved the pool, jumping off the rocks, the hammocks. We have been to Eleuthera 5 times and this is our fav rental when bringing the kids ! The location is great for both north and south beaches/restaurants. We felt safe ( as usual in Eleuthera ) and Chris really knows what guests want at a vacation rental. We didn’t need to reach out to David the caretaker but we did meet him at Mel’s Snack Shack and he’s lovely! We are rebooking the home for our fall trip!

Outstanding place highly recommended! Beautiful setting. Very well designed home with comfortable indoor and outdoor spaces. Mike was super in communication.

The pictures and description are perfect, it's exactly as wonderful as it looks. Thanks to Mary Morgan and Todd for doing such a wonderful job maintaining their property and sharing it with us. A few notes for prospective guests--there are plenty of spices and pots/pans for cooking, towels for exploring and linens for sleeping/relaxing. You're as comfortable here as you are at home, except you're in Eleuthera so it's probably much better. Power was reliable and the wifi was flawless (if that's important to you). The path down to the beach is magical. We had a week of onshore wind and next to no surf, but there's plenty to do otherwise. You can get by here without a high clearance vehicle if you drive carefully, the roads to the house are in pretty good shape, though for many of the places we visited that's not the case. I can't recommend MM and Todd's place any more highly.

we stayed in the sunset apartment. the windows face the forest. it was very comfortable. we describe it as beach rustic. Doon, Taja's mom, who runs the Airbnb, was very helpful and available for questions and recommendations.

My husband and I stayed at the Bird Cage for a quick wedding anniversary trip, and it was a wonderful experience. The Bird Cage was immaculate, with a modern and tastefully decorated interior. Although we spent most of our time indoors, the location was convenient, being just a short drive from Governor's Harbour, ATMs, shops, and more. Check-in was very smooth, and Solivia graciously allowed us to arrive early. She personalized our stay with a beautiful welcome message, wine, candles, and drinks in the fridge. The kitchen was well-equipped, making it easy for us to prepare meals at home. We felt so comfortable and relaxed that we didn’t want to leave. We would definitely recommend this place to couples looking for a relaxing and private getaway. You won't regret it! Thank you, Solivia; we will be back for sure!

Beautiful New, Clean, and Well-appointed house! We enjoyed it so much we plan to adopt the house layout for our retirement home. Sitting on the screened porch for morning coffee or gazing at the night stars listening to the ocean waves in the distance was idyllic.