Vacation rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Serene Escape: Hiking Trails & A-List Amenities

Trade the city for the forest! Our upscale forest cabin offers discerning guests the perfect winter retreat. Cozy up in pure comfort with a roaring wood fireplace (firewood provided), a wood stove, and a private hot tub for stargazing in the crisp air. Enjoy a gourmet coffee & tea bar, plus games and movies (Netflix/Prime) inside. Explore on-site hiking trails by day and listen for owls at night. Perfect for couples, friends, or small families (sleeps 4). Book your modern forest sanctuary now!

A room with view - great location

This room is a good value. It is close enough to Indianapolis yet peaceful, clean, quiet, and private. We are: 7.1 miles (10 minutes) from Indianapolis international airport. 18 miles (26 minutes) from downtown Indianapolis, 17miles (20 min drive) from Indianapolis convention center and Lucas stadium. 35 miles (52 minutes) from Indiana University in Bloomington. ~3 miles from I-70. If interested in booking please answer our pre booking questions found at the beginning of the house rules.

Cataract Lake Getaway - Cozy Lofted Cabin (#2)

This brand new cabin on a private road is a serene setting perfectly blending rustic charm and modern comfort. Only a half-mile from Cataract Lake, quick and easy access to boating, fishing, kayaking, etc. awaits! Numerous nearby attractions are sure to provide great experiences (Cataract Falls, Exotic Feline Rescue Center, Terre Haute Casino, state parks, brewery/winery, local shops/eateries, etc.) And of course, simply enjoying time in and around the cabin itself is a fulfilling getaway!

Maria’s Haven

Welcome to “Maria’s Haven”💕 A beautiful cozy home in the heart of a beautiful small town. This home belonged to my mother, Maria, who passed away in 2020 to breast cancer. This home was truly her “Haven”. Take a walk to the local diner, museum, Gosport playground, local shops, or to our delicious Amish bakery. We are also just a few miles from the popular “Hilltop” restaurant as well as McCormicks Creek State Park. Our mission is to make you feel like you never even left home. ☺️

Grandpa's Cabin at Heidenreich Hollow

Grandpa’s Cabin at Heidenreich Hollow offers exclusive lodging on our hilly 5 acre wooded property. We offer a peaceful getaway from life while being right in the middle of both Indianapolis and Bloomington! Our quiet rustic cabin has a loft bedroom with stair access that includes a King size bed, 2 twin beds and an air mattress. We have a spacious bathroom and a fully equipped kitchen to help you feel at home. Search YouTube for Grandpas Cabin at Heidenreich Hollow for a video!.

The Main Street Retreat-NO CLEANING FEES

Enjoy your time to simply get away or as a must need sleep over due to travel or work. Only 14 miles south of I70. A Dollar General Store, Subway and Gas Station are nearby. Ten minute drive south to Sullivan for Walmart, restaurants, and grocery stores. Fifteen minute drive north to Terre Haute for all the city attractions. County and State Parks are near by as well. Located in a great neighborhood on main street with privacy. Maximum of only four adults allowed per reservation.

Enjoy Comfort & History! - Suite w/ Private Entry

We look forward to welcoming you to a private suite that is the guest quarters in our home. You’ll have a private entrance & 3 rooms to yourself. There’s a living room with a table and chairs, a bedroom with a queen-size bed - nightstands, dresser and closet space with hangers for your use - and a newly remodeled full bathroom. There’s also a kitchenette in the hallway which is an antique Hoosier Cabinet equipped with a microwave, mini-fridge, coffee pot, and hot water pot.

Captain Bill's Guest House/seasonal swimming pool

Welcome to Captain Bill's Guest Lodge at Cagels Mill Lake! This gorgeous home offers modern amenities in a countryside setting. Perfect for bikers, boaters, fisherman, and anyone looking to enjoy lake life. Our guests are welcome to join us poolside at the main house. Our private pool is open only to us and our listed guests at our two Airbnb units. We're located seconds from the boat ramp and a short drive to Cataract Falls and Lieber State Park. Pool is seasonal.

Strawbale Bungalow. Bloomington Indiana USA.

Art and book filled. Located in Bloomington Indiana. My 1920s bungalow includes two guest bedrooms with queen sized beds, down comforters, feather/down pillows, line curtains and private bathroom. The guest area also includes a garden porch, private entrance, living room and, dining area with microwave, small refrigerator and handmade maple table. NO KITCHEN. The bathroom is between the bedrooms and includes a Toto washlet bidet and EO toiletries.

Parke County Dream Cabin

Come experience the serenity of country living and get away from the daily grind of everyday life. Come fish in our five-acre lake (catch & release only), paddle-boat, kayak, or stroll through the woods. A covered porch and seating lakeside for relaxing. Located close to Mansfield and Bridgeton, 30 minutes from Turkey Run State Park, and only 30 minutes toTerre Haute or Greencastle. Come explore everything Parke County has to offer! KIDS WELCOME!

Luxury Lake House: Stay French Lake

This bright and airy 4 bedroom home is a destination getaway perfect for your family, friends, or business retreat. With new furniture, appliances, and décor this retreat is the perfect getaway or staycation for your leisure or business needs. Nearby Attractions: Queen of Terre Haute Casino, Griffin Bike Park, Fowler Park, Laverne Gibson Cross Country Course, Rose Hulman, Indiana State University, and The Mill Concert Venue

Camper in Wooded Floral Setting. Grill, Firepit

Save with NO added cleaning fees!! Coleman Lantern LT 24 ' Camper set up with everything you need for a cozy getaway. Situated at the edge of the woods along the flower gardens and fire-pit seating area. ONLY ONE BED ONLY TWO GUESTS I don't know why Airbnb continues to list two beds when there are not my apologies for that there is only one bed and no fold outs of any kind nor is there room for a fold out or an extra person